Explainer: what genetics and psychology say about "race realism" claims
Academics Jonathan Goodman and Rebecca Sear argue that "race realism", the claim of innate intelligence differences between racial groups, is not supported by genetics, evolutionary biology or psychology. The essay first appeared in The Conversation and was republished by Ars Technica.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Left · 2An essay by Jonathan R. Goodman (University of Cambridge) and Rebecca Sear argues that "race realism", also called "race science", is not scientifically sound. It says claims of innate intellectual differences between racial groups are not supported by genetics, evolutionary biology or psychology. The ConversationLC “But, as we argue, they are not actually scientific.” Read at The Conversation ↗ Ars TechnicaLC “No part of this claim can be scientifically supported; not from the point of view of genetics, evolutionary biology, or psychology.” Read at Ars Technica ↗ Left · 2The authors open with political context. They cite President Donald Trump saying at this year's World Economic Forum in Davos that people from Somalia are "low-IQ people", and a similar 2024 statement about Haitians by Donald Trump Jr. They describe these as symptoms of a re-emergence of racial views of human nature. The ConversationLC ““I always say these are low-IQ people,” he said in his speech.” Read at The Conversation ↗ Ars TechnicaLC “These statements and their consequences are symptoms of a growing trend in Western politics” Read at Ars Technica ↗ Left · 2They say the researcher Nathan Cofnas recently drew public attention by accusing the late Jason Arday of plagiarism. They add that Cofnas has links to a network making claims about the innate intelligence, criminality or sexuality of racial groups, some of whom are university-affiliated and publish in a handful of mainstream journals. The ConversationLC “One member of this community, Nathan Cofnas, recently attracted public attention by accusing the late Jason Arday of plagiarism.” Read at The Conversation ↗ Ars TechnicaLC “Yet they regularly succeed in publishing this work in (a handful of) mainstream academic journals.” Read at Ars Technica ↗
Left · 2The authors say proponents present themselves as persecuted but legitimate scientists. They often defend "hereditarianism", the idea that genetic differences, rather than purely environmental ones, play a key causal role in differences in behaviour and intelligence between groups such as races. The authors call this thinking "flawed and wrong". The ConversationLC “Contemporary race scientists position themselves as persecuted but legitimate scientists who are prevented from pursuing their work for ideological reasons.” Read at The Conversation ↗ Ars TechnicaLC “Yet scientific evidence has shown repeatedly and from many points of view that hereditarian thinking is both flawed and wrong.” Read at Ars Technica ↗ Left · 2On genetics, they cite Richard Lewontin's 1970s finding that there is more genetic variation within human groups than between them. They say later genomic knowledge supports this and that variation does not fall into clusters matching conventional racial categories. They add that traits such as skin colour and lactose digestion track environment rather than race, and that ancient DNA shows constant mixing between populations, which undermines ideas of genetic "purity". The ConversationLC “We now know considerably more about the human genome than Lewontin did in the 1970s, but his conclusions are supported today.” Read at The Conversation ↗ Ars TechnicaLC “It ultimately makes any belief in the genetic “purity” of European or African populations meaningless.” Read at Ars Technica ↗ Left · 2On IQ data, they say hereditarians rely heavily on the "national IQ" database, which they say researchers have repeatedly shown to be deeply methodologically flawed. They cite analysis suggesting low-IQ samples were deliberately chosen to represent sub-Saharan Africa. They also argue that IQ cannot be measured identically across cultures with different exposure to formal education. The ConversationLC “Researchers have repeatedly demonstrated that this database is deeply methodologically flawed.” Read at The Conversation ↗ Ars TechnicaLC “There’s even analysis suggesting that low IQ samples were deliberately chosen to represent sub-Saharan Africa, to make the IQ for black populations artificially low.” Read at Ars Technica ↗
Left · 2The authors say the Flynn effect, the large rise in IQ scores during the 20th and 21st centuries, shows scores are heavily shaped by environment, because so rapid a rise must have environmental rather than genetic causes. They also say intelligence is hard to define and that IQ tests capture only specific abilities, leaving out things like social intelligence or creativity. The ConversationLC “Such a rapid rise over a short period of time must have environmental, not genetic, causes.” Read at The Conversation ↗ Ars TechnicaLC “IQ tests only measure specific cognitive abilities, ignoring things like social intelligence or creativity, for example.” Read at Ars Technica ↗ Left · 2On evolution, they say no prominent mainstream view of human intelligence's evolution concludes there are innate cognitive differences between racial groups. They describe mainstream opinion in the evolutionary behavioural sciences as holding that all human groups are cognitively the same on average, with individuals differing, and that behavioural diversity comes from flexible adaptation, culture and social learning. They criticise the "cold winters theory" as a "just-so" story that ignores half a century of research and makes unsupportable assumptions about Africa's environments. The ConversationLC “Not one of the prominent mainstream views on the evolution of human intelligence concludes there are innate cognitive differences between racial groups.” Read at The Conversation ↗ Ars TechnicaLC “Their “cold winters theory,” for example, claims that the challenges of cold winters in Europe and east Asia created evolutionary selection pressures for greater intelligence after human groups migrated out of Africa.” Read at Ars Technica ↗ Left · 2The authors conclude that hereditarianism does not hold up from the standpoint of genetics, anthropology, evolutionary biology or psychology. They then turn to the historical context and consequences of these views, arguing such claims fuel far-right propaganda and social media misinformation. Ars TechnicaLC “hereditarianism does not hold up.” Read at Ars Technica ↗ The ConversationLC “are fuelling far-right propaganda in some of the world’s largest democracies” Read at The Conversation ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left2 outlets
- Framing
- Both outlets present the same expert-authored explainer, which says race realism is pseudo-science that gives far-right politics a veneer of legitimacy. It links the topic to Trump's statements at Davos and to a network of academics.
- Emphasis
- Lewontin's finding on within-group genetic variation, flaws in the national IQ database, the Flynn effect, and the mainstream view that human groups are cognitively the same. Proponents' work is described as 'methodologically deeply flawed'.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Neither outlet presents the proponents' own arguments or responses in its own words; Cofnas and the 'race realist' network are described only through the authors' criticism. No outlet from the centre or right covered the story.
- Charged language
- “race realism”“race science”“hereditarianism”“just-so”“far-right propaganda”“the mask of legitimacy”
- For example
-
“‘Race realism’: why scientifically flawed approach fails to present a realistic view of race” — The Conversation
““Race realism” isn’t realistic—and it isn’t good science” — Ars Technica
“Some within this network are affiliated with universities, giving their work the mask of legitimacy.” — Ars Technica
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Both outlets carry the same essay by Jonathan R. Goodman and Rebecca Sear, first published by The Conversation.
- Both open with Trump's Davos remark about Somali people and a 2024 statement by Donald Trump Jr about Haitians.
- Both state that hereditarian claims of innate racial intelligence differences are scientifically unsupported.
Left2 articles
-
‘Race realism’: why scientifically flawed approach fails to present a realistic view of race
Critical Longform Conversation Insights essay by university researchers, arguing that race science is flawed and politically harmful.

-
“Race realism” isn’t realistic—and it isn’t good science
Critical Ars Technica republication of the Conversation essay with a headline saying race realism 'isn't good science'; text is essentially the same with US spelling.

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 13 Nov 10:17 First The ConversationLC ‘Race realism’: why scientifically flawed approach fails to present a realistic view of race
- 21 Nov 12:01 +193h 44m Ars TechnicaLC “Race realism” isn’t realistic—and it isn’t good science
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…