Extinct yak relative identified from DNA in Denisova Cave bone fragments
Researchers analysing genomes from bone fragments in Denisova Cave and nearby sites have identified a previously unknown extinct bovine related to the wild yak, provisionally called "yak X".
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Centre · 2Researchers have identified a previously unknown extinct species of bovine from DNA in bone fragments recovered at Denisova Cave in the Altai foothills of Siberia, Russia, and it is currently known only as "yak X". New ScientistN “A newly identified species of bovine, currently known only as yak X” Read at New Scientist ↗ The Times of IndiaN “ancient DNA recovered from the remains has revealed a previously unknown bovine species” Read at The Times of India ↗ Centre · 1Love Dalén of Stockholm University and colleagues began studying the fragments hoping to learn about bison evolution, but found that nearly all of them carried DNA matching no living bovine, nor the extinct steppe bison or aurochs. New ScientistN “nearly all bone fragments in the cave had DNA that didn’t match any living bovine species, nor did it match the extinct steppe bison or aurochs” Read at New Scientist ↗ Centre · 2The team analysed hundreds of tiny fragments from the cave plus material from three other nearby sites and one near the Ural mountains, and constructed genomes from 20 individuals spanning roughly 200,000 years. New ScientistN “From these, the researchers were able to construct genomes from 20 individuals.” Read at New Scientist ↗ The Times of IndiaN “analyzed 20 ancient genomes spanning roughly 200,000 years” Read at The Times of India ↗
Centre · 1The Times of India, citing a Phys Org report, says the work was published in Current Biology and involved the Center for Paleogenetics in Stockholm, the University of California, Santa Cruz, and the University of Vienna. The Times of IndiaN “Researchers from the Center for Paleogenetics in Stockholm, the University of California, Santa Cruz, and the University of Vienna”“The discovery, published in Current Biology” Read at The Times of India ↗ Centre · 2The lineage appears to have diverged from the wild yak (Bos mutus) around 400,000 years ago, become genetically isolated by about 250,000 years ago, and gone extinct by around 30,000 years ago; the youngest specimen examined dates to about 27,000 years ago. New ScientistN “The species seems to have diverged from the wild yak (Bos mutus) around 400,000 years ago.” Read at New Scientist ↗ The Times of IndiaN “The youngest specimen examined in the study dates to around 27,000 years ago.” Read at The Times of India ↗ Centre · 1Dalén compared the divergence time to that between polar bears and brown bears, suggesting yak X was probably quite a different animal, just as American and European bison are no longer the same species. New ScientistN “The divergence time is similar to that between polar bears (Ursus maritimus) and brown bears (Ursus arctos), says Dalén.” Read at New Scientist ↗
Centre · 1The Times of India, relaying Phys Org, says the split coincided with a strong warm period around 400,000 years ago, and that around 120,000 years ago, in the last interglacial, the animal appears to have undergone a population replacement with declining genetic diversity. The Times of IndiaN “Around 400,000 years ago, the region experienced a particularly strong warm climatic period.”“around 120,000 years ago, the newly identified bovine appears to have undergone a population replacement accompanied by declining genetic diversity” Read at The Times of India ↗ Centre · 1Researchers found little evidence that it interbred with steppe bison or aurochs. The Times of IndiaN “researchers found little evidence that the newly identified bovine interbred with other large bovines living in the region” Read at The Times of India ↗ Centre · 1Dalén suspects yak X may correspond to yak-like remains previously described by Russian palaeontologists as a subspecies of the Himalayan yak, but the team does not yet know what unique traits it had until further work, including on possibly misidentified remains, is complete. New ScientistN “We suspect that yak X might actually correspond to yak-like remains that have been [previously] described by Russian palaeontologists as a subspecies of the Himalayan yak”“the team has no idea what unique traits the new species may have had” Read at New Scientist ↗
Centre · 1All the bones found so far come from much lower elevations than the modern yak's native Tibetan Plateau range, which Jonas Oppenheimer of Stockholm University said may mean yak X was less adapted to extreme mountain environments. New ScientistN “yak X may have been less adapted to extreme mountain environments, says Jonas Oppenheimer” Read at New Scientist ↗ Centre · 1There is no direct evidence yet that it was hunted by Denisovans, Neanderthals or modern humans, but Dalén says it is likely they and carnivores such as hyenas and lions preyed on it. New ScientistN “There is, so far, no direct evidence of yak X being hunted by different human species” Read at New Scientist ↗ Centre · 1The cause and exact timing of its extinction remain unknown, and the species has no formal scientific name. The Times of IndiaN “researchers cannot yet determine exactly when or why it became extinct”“the species remains without a formal scientific name” Read at The Times of India ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre2 outlets
- Framing
- Both centre outlets present a straightforward science-discovery story. New Scientist leads with the new species and researcher quotes; The Times of India rewrites a Phys Org report, stressing climate and Altai as a refuge.
- Emphasis
- New Scientist: researcher quotes, possible link to earlier Russian fossil descriptions, human hunting and altitude. The Times of India: climate influence, population replacement, lack of interbreeding, unresolved extinction.
- Leaves out or plays down
- The Times of India omits the hunting question and the possible link to Russian-described fossils; New Scientist omits the journal, institutions and climate/interglacial findings.
- Charged language
- “extraordinary evolutionary story”“long-lost Siberian bovine”
- For example
-
““It’s not every day that one discovers a previously unknown extinct megafaunal species,” says Love Dalén” — New Scientist
“A handful of unremarkable bone fragments from caves in southern Siberia have turned out to hold an extraordinary evolutionary story.” — The Times of India
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Genetic analysis of bone fragments from Denisova Cave and other Siberian sites revealed an unknown extinct bovine related to the yak.
- Genomes from 20 individuals were analysed.
- The lineage split from the wild yak around 400,000 years ago and became distinct around 250,000 years ago.
- The divergence is comparable to that of polar and brown bears.
- The species has no formal name yet and the reason for its extinction is unknown.
Denisova Cave place
The cave, famed for the first Denisovan remains, is presented as also holding the DNA of a previously unknown bovine, showing the Altai region's importance beyond human evolution.
“The new bovine discovery reveals the region’s significance extended way beyond human evolution.” — The Times of India
“The cave is most famous as the place where the mysterious Denisovans were first identified from a finger bone found there.” — New Scientist
Yak topic
Modern wild yaks are now restricted largely to the Tibetan Plateau; the extinct relative lived at lower elevations in Siberia.
“Modern wild yaks are now restricted largely to high-elevation areas of the Tibetan Plateau” — The Times of India
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre2 articles
-
Extinct yak relative discovered from DNA in Denisova cave
Neutral Researcher-led account of the discovery, with caveats about unknown traits and no direct evidence of hunting.

-
Ancient DNA reveals an unknown extinct bovine related to modern yaks
Neutral Secondhand rewrite of a Phys Org report, emphasising climate effects and the Altai as an Ice Age refuge.

Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 5 Oct 16:00 First New ScientistN Extinct yak relative discovered from DNA in Denisova cave
- 6 Oct 12:23 +20h 24m The Times of IndiaN Ancient DNA reveals an unknown extinct bovine related to modern yaks
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.