Family of student who died after charity boxing bout sue organisers for £200,000
The father of Jubel Reji Kurian, 23, who died in 2023 after collapsing in a charity boxing match in Nottingham, is suing organiser Ultra Events Ltd for £200,000. The company denies liability, and a High Court pre-trial hearing allowed the family's expert referee evidence ahead of a trial next year.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2The family of Jubel Reji Kurian, a 23-year-old student, are suing the organisers of a charity boxing match for £200,000 over his death in 2023. Daily MailR “The family of a student who died after suffering a brain injury during a charity boxing match have sued the organisers for £200,000.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ MetroLC “The family of a student fatally injured in a charity boxing match are suing for £200,000” Read at Metro ↗ Mixed · 2Mr Kurian died on 29 March 2023, four days after he collapsed in the ring towards the end of the third and final round of an amateur bout at Nottingham's Harvey Haddon Sports Centre; he never regained consciousness and his life support was turned off. Daily MailR “passed away on March 29, 2023, four days after he collapsed in the ring towards the end of the third and final round of an amateur bout” Read at Daily Mail ↗ MetroLC “never regained consciousness before he died in hospital” Read at Metro ↗ Mixed · 2His father, Reji Kurian, is suing Ultra Events Ltd, the organiser, on grounds that the contest should have been stopped before the final punch was delivered. Daily MailR “is suing organisers Ultra Events Ltd on grounds that the contest should have been stopped before the knockout punch was delivered” Read at Daily Mail ↗ MetroLC “suing Ultra Events Ltd” Read at Metro ↗
Mixed · 2The family's barrister, Harry Trusted, told the High Court in London: 'My case boils down to saying that, if that punch had not been delivered, Mr Kurian would have survived.' He accepted the claim would succeed only 'if a sufficient level of carelessness is demonstrated by the defendants'. Daily MailR “'My case boils down to saying that, if that punch had not been delivered, Mr Kurian would have survived.'” Read at Daily Mail ↗ MetroLC “The family has accepted that the case could only be successful” Read at Metro ↗ Mixed · 2Ultra Events denies all liability, saying the referee was highly experienced and competent and able to supervise an amateur bout. Its barrister, Daniel Tobin, said Mr Kurian had done more than 33 hours of training at a local boxing gym and that the family would have to prove a 'very high degree of carelessness', which he said was completely absent. Daily MailR “The organisers, however, deny any liability.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ MetroLC “more than 33 hours of training in a local boxing gym” Read at Metro ↗ Left · 1According to Metro, Mr Tobin also said that training was provided by coaches acting for Ultra Events and that boxing is a full contact sport which carries a high risk of serious injury. MetroLC “Boxing is a full contact sport which carries with it a high risk of serious injury” Read at Metro ↗
Mixed · 2The hearing was a preliminary one, before Master John Dagnall according to Metro, in an action due to go to trial next year, and concerned what evidence the trial judge should hear. The family asked to call a referee with over 40 years' experience in amateur and professional boxing to comment on video of the bout. Ultra Events objected that the expert had no specific knowledge of white-collar boxing rules and no medical expertise, and its barrister said there is no regulatory framework for white-collar events with university students for charity. Daily MailR “in the preliminary stage of an action that is due to reach trial next year”“in respect of the regulations and safety framework for a white collar event with university students for charity, there is nothing” Read at Daily Mail ↗ MetroLC “the judge, Master John Dagnall, during a pre-trial hearing in London” Read at Metro ↗ Mixed · 2After a short hearing, the judge allowed the evidence to be heard at trial, and Ultra Events may call its own expert. Daily MailR “the judge agreed to permit the evidence to be heard at the trial, although Ultra Events will also have the option of calling their own expert witness” Read at Daily Mail ↗ MetroLC “the judge agreed to permit the evidence to be heard at the trial” Read at Metro ↗ Mixed · 2Mr Kurian had moved to Britain six months earlier to study for a master's degree in sports medicine, hoping to become an NHS physiotherapist. His parents flew from the United Arab Emirates to be with him. Daily MailR “study for a master's degree in sports medicine, with the aim of becoming an NHS physiotherapist” Read at Daily Mail ↗ MetroLC “parents flew from the United Arab Emirates to Nottingham” Read at Metro ↗
Mixed · 2An inquest in 2024 heard he was competing well before 'the tide turned in the third round'. It found he died from a 'devastating' brain injury, with bleeding on both sides of the brain; Metro reports the coroner ruled he died by accident. Daily MailR “A witness to the inquest told how Mr Kurian was holding his own during the bout, but that 'the tide turned in the third round'.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ MetroLC “the coroner ruling that he died by accident due to bleeding on both sides of the brain” Read at Metro ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Metro leads with the family's claim that he would have survived had the referee stopped the match, and gives the organiser's defence, including that boxing carries a high risk of serious injury.
- Emphasis
- Court exchanges, the company's training and risk arguments, the judge's name and the coroner's finding of accidental death.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the lack of a regulatory framework for white-collar boxing, which the Daily Mail reports.
- Charged language
- “killed”
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- The Daily Mail leads with the death of a student after a 'devastating' brain injury and the family's lawsuit, with a sympathetic account of his background.
- Emphasis
- The knockout blow, the absence of rules for white-collar boxing and the organisers' defence.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the coroner's accidental death finding or the point that training was provided by Ultra Events' coaches.
- Charged language
- “devastating”“knocked out”
- For example
-
“Family of student, 23, who died of 'devastating' brain injury after being knocked out at charity boxing match sue organisers for £200,000” — Daily Mail
“there is nothing” — Daily Mail
What every side reports
- Mr Kurian, 23, died on 29 March 2023, four days after collapsing in an amateur charity bout at Nottingham's Harvey Haddon Sports Centre.
- His family is suing organiser Ultra Events Ltd for £200,000; the company denies liability.
- The High Court hearing was preliminary, with trial due next year, and the judge allowed the family's expert referee evidence.
- The family's barrister is Harry Trusted and Ultra Events' is Daniel Tobin.
Where accounts differ
-
Format of the bout
- Left
- Metro says the bout comprised three two-minute rounds.
- Right
- The Daily Mail says it comprised two three-minute rounds, while also describing a third and final round.
Jubel Reji Kurian person
Mr Kurian, a sports medicine master's student, is portrayed as competing well before the final round; his family says he would have survived had the fight been stopped.
“The graduate student had been 'competing well' in the fight” — Daily Mail
“claiming he would have survived if the ref stopped the match.” — Metro
Left1 article
-
MetroLC ·
Family of student killed in charity boxing match suing organisers for £200,000
Neutral Reports the claim and defence in even-handed court-report style, adding the coroner's finding and the company's risk argument.

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right1 article
-
Sympathetic Reports the lawsuit with emphasis on the 'devastating' injury and the student's ambitions, and with detail on the legal arguments.

- 13 Oct 11:18 First Daily MailR Family of student, 23, who died of 'devastating' brain injury after being knocked out at charity boxing match sue organisers for £200,000
- 13 Oct 13:14 +1h 55m MetroLC Family of student killed in charity boxing match suing organisers for £200,000
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…