Report: federal probes found evidence Omar married a sibling, but case was time-barred
The New York Times reported that a 2016 federal investigation found evidence suggesting Rep. Ilhan Omar and Ahmed Nur Said Elmi were siblings, but prosecutors judged any crime outside the five-year statute of limitations. Omar has called the allegation a right-wing conspiracy theory.
1 / 4
The story, neutrally told
Right · 1Federal investigators found evidence suggesting that Rep. Ilhan Omar, a Minnesota Democrat, had entered a sham marriage with Ahmed Nur Said Elmi, a man believed to be a sibling, during a 2016 FBI and Department of Homeland Security investigation, according to a New York Times report relayed by the New York Post. New York PostR “Federal investigators found evidence that Rep. Ilhan Omar had entered into a sham marriage with a man believed to be her brother during a 2016 investigation by the FBI and Department of Homeland Security” Read at New York Post ↗ Right · 1The case stalled because prosecutors concluded that the potential crime, a felony, fell outside a five-year statute of limitations, according to the Times, which cited six current and former officials. Hot AirR “that case stalled chiefly because prosecutors concluded that the potential crime, a felony, fell outside a five-year statute of limitations”“according to the six former and current officials familiar with the case” Read at Hot Air ↗ Right · 1The Times, as quoted by Hot Air, said agents had limited investigative tools because prosecutors did not pursue the matter, and that Elmi obtained a provisional two-year green card based on the marriage. When he sought permanent status and immigration officials asked for more evidence of the marriage's validity, he left the United States and abandoned the petition, two former officials said. Hot AirR “because prosecutors did not pursue the matter, the agents had limited investigative tools, the officials said.”“Instead of responding, Mr. Elmi left the United States and abandoned his green card petition, the officials said.” Read at Hot Air ↗
Right · 1The New York Post confirmed the Times reporting and quoted a source familiar with the probe as saying the "Biden US Attorney in Minnesota shut it down" shortly after taking office in 2021. The Post said it was not immediately clear what specific evidence was uncovered. New York PostR “first reported by the New York Times and confirmed by The Post, with a source familiar with the probe claiming the “Biden US Attorney in Minnesota shut it down” shortly after taking office in 2021”“It is not immediately clear what specific evidence was uncovered about Omar’s marriage to Elmi.” Read at New York Post ↗ Right · 2Omar has insisted that the allegation is a racist conspiracy theory pushed by the far right; the Times said Omar has long called it a right-wing conspiracy theory that federal officials debunked during the 2016 race, when Omar was a first-time candidate for the Minnesota legislature. President Trump repeated the accusation last week. New York PostR “has insisted allegations that she married her brother so he could obtain a green card are a racist conspiracy theory pushed by the far-right” Read at New York Post ↗ Hot AirR “She has long called it a right-wing conspiracy theory that federal officials debunked during her first race for elected office in 2016.” Read at Hot Air ↗ Right · 1The Post also reported that earlier this month federal agents executed a search warrant at the Washington home Omar shares with current husband Tim Mynett, seizing a cellphone, notebooks, personal computers and a passport. Its sources said investigators are examining whether Omar was part of a family conspiracy to commit immigration fraud, which could lead to denaturalization and deportation. New York PostR “federal agents executed a search warrant at the DC home Omar shares with her current husband, Tim Mynett, seizing her cellphone, notebooks, personal computers and her passport.”“investigators are examining whether Omar was part of a family conspiracy to commit immigration fraud, which could lead to her denaturalization and deportation.” Read at New York Post ↗
Right · 1Hot Air's Ed Morrissey argued that the Obama-era administration declined to pursue the matter for political reasons, that civil or administrative action remained possible, and that the Times story adds little to evidence already public. These are the columnist's opinions and allegations, not findings in the Times account as quoted. Hot AirR “The answer to this mystery appears to be that the Obama administration didn't want to pursue this after Ahmed fled.”“The DOJ and DHS always had the option of pursuing a civil/administrative case against 'Omar' over her false identity and fraudulent naturalization.” Read at Hot Air ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right4 outlets
- Framing
- Both outlets treat the Times report as vindicating long-standing allegations against Omar. The Post reports it as a news item with the statute-of-limitations detail and the ongoing federal probe; Hot Air runs an opinion column accusing the Obama administration of a political cover-up and calling Omar a fraud.
- Emphasis
- The evidence of a sibling relationship, the Biden-era shutdown claim, the search warrant, and possible denaturalization; Hot Air stresses Obama-era inaction and Democratic Somali-community politics.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Neither carries a response from Omar to the new Times report; the Post notes it is unclear what evidence was found, and Hot Air's claims about a changed name and false identity are asserted by the columnist and others rather than established in the Times excerpts.
- Charged language
- “sham marriage”“bombshell”“fraudster”“Omar-ish”
- For example
-
“Feds found evidence Ilhan Omar was in sham marriage with her ‘brother’ during 2016 probe” — New York Post
“'Omar' is a fraud and a fraudster” — Hot Air
What every side reports
- The New York Times reported that a 2016 federal investigation found evidence suggesting Omar and Ahmed Nur Said Elmi were siblings.
- The case stalled because prosecutors concluded any potential crime fell outside a five-year statute of limitations.
- Omar has denied the allegation, calling it a conspiracy theory.
Where accounts differ
-
Why the 2016 case did not proceed
- Right
- The Post's source said the Biden-era US Attorney in Minnesota shut it down in 2021; the Times (via Hot Air) cited the statute of limitations and limited investigative tools; Hot Air's columnist alleges Obama-administration political calculation.
-
Whether the allegation was debunked
- Right
- Omar says federal officials debunked it; the Times-based reporting says agents found evidence suggesting the two were siblings and that the case stalled on limitations.
Ilhan Omar person
Omar has called the marriage allegation a racist, right-wing conspiracy theory; the coverage contains no new response to the Times report.
“has insisted allegations that she married her brother so he could obtain a green card are a racist conspiracy theory pushed by the far-right” — New York Post
Barack Obama person
Hot Air's columnist accuses the Obama administration of declining to pursue the case after Elmi left the country, for political reasons; the article gives no response from the former administration.
“The answer to this mystery appears to be that the Obama administration didn't want to pursue this after Ahmed fled.” — Hot Air
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right4 articles
-
Feds found evidence Ilhan Omar was in sham marriage with her ‘brother’ during 2016 probe
Critical News report presenting the Times findings as federal evidence of a sham marriage, adding the search warrant and denaturalization angle.
-
Hot AirR ·
Oh, Brother: NYT Drops Bombshell on Ilhan Omar-ish Marriage and Obama Admin
Alarmist Opinion column treating the Times report as proof of fraud and an Obama-era political cover-up, with sweeping claims about the DFL and Somali community.
-
BreitbartR · · Opinion
Nolte: NY Times Admits Obama DOJ Found Evidence of Ilhan Omar’s Suspected ‘Sham Marriage’
-
- 29 Oct 13:18 First New York PostR Feds found evidence Ilhan Omar was in sham marriage with her ‘brother’ during 2016 probe
- 29 Oct 14:40 +1h 23m Hot AirR Oh, Brother: NYT Drops Bombshell on Ilhan Omar-ish Marriage and Obama Admin
- 29 Oct 14:52 +1h 34m BreitbartR Nolte: NY Times Admits Obama DOJ Found Evidence of Ilhan Omar’s Suspected ‘Sham Marriage’ Opinion
- 29 Oct 15:05 +1h 47m Fox NewsR Obama admin first launched the investigation into Ilhan Omar's alleged brother marriage
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…