FIFA accuses UEFA of election interference as Swiss FA withdraws Infantino backing
FIFA told a US court UEFA is running a "misinformation campaign" to influence its presidential election, while the Swiss Football Association dropped its support for Gianni Infantino's re-election bid.
Updated (version 2). Rewritten with the latest reporting.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
FIFA has accused UEFA of waging a "misinformation campaign" and trying to influence the race for the FIFA presidency. Al JazeeraLC “FIFA has accused European football’s governing body, UEFA, of waging a “misinformation campaign” and trying to influence the race for its presidency” Read at Al Jazeera ↗ On Tuesday FIFA urged a US court to reject UEFA's discovery request, which is tied to Gianni Infantino's investment proposal for World Cup rights. Al JazeeraLC “urged a court in the United States on Tuesday to reject UEFA’s discovery request” Read at Al Jazeera ↗ UEFA had asked a US federal court last month for testimony and documents for a planned criminal complaint in Switzerland against Infantino over the abandoned plan to move World Cup commercial rights into a subsidiary, FIFA Forward Enterprise (FFE). Al JazeeraLC “UEFA asked a US federal court for permission to obtain testimony and documents for use in a planned criminal complaint in Switzerland against Infantino” Read at Al Jazeera ↗
UEFA alleged Infantino developed the proposal in secret and bypassed normal governance; it said investors would have paid $4.2bn for a stake, valuing the business at about $20bn, which it said undervalued the rights. Al JazeeraLC “investors would have paid $4.2bn for a stake in FFE, valuing the business at about $20bn.” Read at Al Jazeera ↗ FIFA's filing in the Southern District of Florida called UEFA's claims false or misleading, said the plan needed approval from member associations and the FIFA Council, and argued UEFA confused equity value with enterprise value, which it put well over $30 billion. Al JazeeraLC ““UEFA, whether deliberately or through ignorance, conflates equity value with enterprise value,” FIFA said.” Read at Al Jazeera ↗ FIFA said UEFA filed its application just before the election, which Infantino, seeking a fourth term, faces in March. Al JazeeraLC ““Just before FIFA’s election, UEFA filed this 1782 Application (and three others) spreading misinformation regarding Mr Infantino,”” Read at Al Jazeera ↗
The FFE project was abandoned in July after opposition from several confederations, including UEFA, over a lack of consultation. Al JazeeraLC “The FFE project was abandoned in July following opposition from confederations, including UEFA” Read at Al Jazeera ↗ Separately, the Swiss Football Association said on Wednesday its executive committee withdrew its support for Infantino's candidacy at a 25 September meeting, having endorsed him in June. CNAN “The executive committee reversed its support for the Swiss soccer administrator in a meeting on September 25 after endorsing his candidacy in June.” Read at CNA ↗ The SFV said incidents at FIFA raise "fundamental questions regarding leadership, governance, transparency and decision-making processes". CNAN “various incidents raise fundamental questions regarding leadership, governance, transparency and decision-making processes within FIFA” Read at CNA ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Presents the story as a FIFA-UEFA legal and governance tussle, leading with FIFA's accusation and setting out both sides' arguments in detail.
- Emphasis
- Court filings, the valuation dispute ($20bn equity vs over $30bn enterprise value) and the growing governance crisis.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the Swiss Football Association's withdrawal of support, which came a day later.
- Charged language
- “misinformation campaign”“governance crisis”
- For example
-
“amid a growing governance crisis in the sport” — Al Jazeera
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- Short report on a national federation withdrawing its endorsement of Infantino, quoting its statement on governance concerns.
- Emphasis
- The SFV's reversal from its June endorsement and its stated reasons.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the FIFA-UEFA court dispute or the FFE proposal.
- For example
-
“The Swiss Football Association (SFV) has withdrawn its support for Gianni Infantino's bid for another term as FIFA president” — CNA
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Gianni Infantino is seeking another term as FIFA president.
- Questions about FIFA's governance and decision-making are at the centre of the dispute.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether UEFA's court filings are legitimate legal action or an attempt to influence the FIFA election
- Left
- Al Jazeera reports FIFA's allegation of a 'misinformation campaign' and UEFA's counter-allegations of secrecy and undervaluation, presenting both sides' filings.
- Centre
- CNA does not cover the UEFA dispute; it reports the Swiss FA citing governance and transparency concerns at FIFA.
FIFA organisation
Says UEFA's filings contain false or misleading statements and are meant to influence its presidential election; defends the FFE plan as subject to member and Council oversight.
“This court should reject any attempt to influence FIFA’s presidential election based on these grounds.” — Al Jazeera
UEFA organisation
Alleges Infantino developed the FFE proposal in secret, bypassing governance, and that the valuation undervalued FIFA's commercial rights; seeks evidence for a planned Swiss criminal complaint.
“UEFA alleged Infantino developed the proposal in secret with a small group of advisers and investors” — Al Jazeera
Gianni Infantino person
Seeking a fourth term; proposed an independent review of FIFA decision-making and said he is willing to discuss distributions to member associations. FIFA says UEFA's claims against him are without merit.
“Infantino wrote to all 211 member associations proposing an independent review of the governing body’s decision-making processes.” — Al Jazeera
Left2 articles
-
In FIFA-UEFA tussle, European body accused of ‘misinformation campaign’
Neutral Detailed account of FIFA's court response, giving both sides' filings and placing them in the wider governance dispute.
-
Centre1 article
-
CNAN ·
Swiss Football Association withdraws support for Infantino
Neutral Brief factual report of the Swiss FA's withdrawal of support, relying on its statement.
Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 29 Sep 12:12 First Al JazeeraLC In FIFA-UEFA tussle, European body accused of ‘misinformation campaign’
- 30 Sep 16:50 +28h 38m CNAN Swiss Football Association withdraws support for Infantino
- 30 Sep 17:38 +29h 26m Al JazeeraLC Swiss Football Association withdraws support for FIFA boss Gianni Infantino
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.