Fleetwood Town beat Arsenal 5-3 on penalties in Carabao Cup after 1-1 draw
League Two Fleetwood Town knocked Arsenal out of the Carabao Cup fourth round on penalties after a 1-1 draw at Highbury Stadium. Arsenal's 16-year-old Max Dowman was sent off late in normal time.
Updated (version 2). New coverage since the last version from ABC News (Australia), BBC News, CNA, IJR.
1 / 6
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2League Two side Fleetwood Town eliminated Arsenal from the Carabao Cup fourth round, winning 5-3 on penalties after a 1-1 draw at Fleetwood's Highbury Stadium. Evening StandardN “Fleetwood Town 1-1 Arsenal (5-3 on penalties)” Read at Evening Standard ↗ The GuardianLC “they were dumped out of the Carabao Cup on penalties” Read at The Guardian ↗ Mixed · 2Fleetwood's Aaron Loupalo-Bi, on loan from Fulham, scored first in normal time, spinning and holding off 17-year-old Marli Salmon before slotting under goalkeeper Illan Meslier; Viktor Gyökeres equalised in the second half. The GuardianLC “spinning and holding off the 17-year-old before slotting under Illan Meslier” Read at The Guardian ↗ Evening StandardN “Aaron Loupalo-Bi put Fleetwood in front. Viktor Gyokeres equalised in the second half” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Mixed · 2ABC and CNA timed the goals at the 21st minute for Loupalo-Bi and the 50th minute for Gyökeres; ABC said Fleetwood's goal came from one of only two shots on target the hosts managed all match. CNAN “Aaron Loupalo-Bi put the League Two side ahead in the 21st minute” Read at CNA ↗ ABC News (Australia)LC “scoring with one of just two shots on goal the hosts managed for the entire match” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗
Left · 1The Guardian reported that Gyökeres bundled the equaliser in from a cross by 18-year-old debutant Ceadach O'Neill, after Martin Ødegaard and Ben White were brought on at half-time. The GuardianLC “He showed skill on the left wing before darting in a cross which Gyökeres was able to bundle home”“Martin Ødegaard and Ben White coming on in an attempt to turn things around” Read at The Guardian ↗ Mixed · 2Arsenal's Max Dowman, 16, was sent off with five minutes to go after kicking out at Fleetwood's Harrison Neal; the Guardian said the red card looked harsh, while the Evening Standard called it a straight red. The GuardianLC “The 16-year-old caused a melee on the touchline after kicking out at Harrison Neal” Read at The Guardian ↗ Evening StandardN “Max Dowman was then shown a straight red card” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Mixed · 2ABC put Dowman's dismissal at the 86th minute. CNA called the incident an altercation, while the Evening Standard said he reacted angrily to a heavy challenge and kicked out "even if the force was minimal". ABC News (Australia)LC “Arsenal teenager Max Dowman was sent off in the 86th minute” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ Evening StandardN “Dowman reacted angrily to a heavy challenge from Harrison Neal and kicked out at the defender, even if the force was minimal.” Read at Evening Standard ↗
Centre · 1As Dowman left the pitch, Arteta leaned towards him with arms crossed and spoke angrily. Arteta told BBC Radio 5 Live it was "something that we discussed already before the match", and said he would rewatch the incident before assessing it. Evening StandardN “Asked after the match what he had told Dowman, Arteta told BBC Radio 5 Live: "Something that we discussed already before the match."”“So I prefer to watch it back properly and then I can assess the situation.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Centre · 1Former Arsenal player Paul Merson said on Sky Sports the card was harsh and "could easily have been a yellow", and that Arteta should have put an arm around the 16-year-old. It was Dowman's second red card of the month, after one for England Under-19s. Evening StandardN “It could easily have been a yellow, but you've got to remember he's 16, he's a kid” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Evening StandardN “It was the second red card Dowman has picked up this month.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Mixed · 2Fleetwood goalkeeper Jay Lynch made late saves from White and Gyökeres, then saved Bruno Guimarães' penalty in the shootout before teenager Conor Haughey scored the winner, prompting a pitch invasion. The GuardianLC “Goalkeeper Jay Lynch held his nerve to save from Bruno Guimarães in the shootout before the teenager Conor Haughey scored the winner” Read at The Guardian ↗ Evening StandardN “Bruno Guimaraes’ saved penalty proved crucial, as Conor Haughey then sparked utter bedlam” Read at Evening Standard ↗
Mixed · 2In the shootout Fleetwood scored all five penalties; Guimarães' miss, which ABC placed on Arsenal's fourth attempt, was a save by Lynch according to the Evening Standard. ABC News (Australia)LC “Fleetwood was perfect from all five attempts, while Bruno Guimarães's miss for Arsenal on the Gunners' fourth attempt” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ Evening StandardN “Bruno Guimaraes saw his spot-kick saved in the shootout.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Mixed · 2Play was briefly paused early on because a drone was flying over the pitch, after pyrotechnics were set off before kick-off; the Guardian put the stoppage at about six minutes, while CNA reported more than eight and ABC nearly eight. CNAN “The match had been interrupted early on for more than eight minutes after a drone was spotted above the stadium.” Read at CNA ↗ ABC News (Australia)LC “The delay lasted nearly eight minutes” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ Left · 1Manager Mikel Arteta fielded a mix of youngsters and senior players including Kai Havertz and Gyökeres, while Fleetwood, managed by Matt Lawlor, sat deep and defended in numbers. The GuardianLC “starting Kai Havertz and Gyökeres showed there was no ambition for a shock”“Matt Lawlor’s side continued to hold firm, defending deep but with conviction” Read at The Guardian ↗
Mixed · 2Fleetwood sit 18th in League Two, and ABC noted 84 league positions separate the clubs; Arsenal had won seven of their opening eight Premier League matches and play Liverpool at Anfield this weekend. ABC News (Australia)LC “A whopping 84 positions separate the London giant from its League Two minnow opponent” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ CNAN “an Arsenal side who had won seven of their opening eight Premier League matches” Read at CNA ↗ Centre · 1After the match Arteta said he could not fault the players' attitude, adding that Arsenal had many chances and shots but failed to capitalise. Evening StandardN “"I cannot fault at all the attitude of the players," Arteta said.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Centre · 1The Evening Standard's player ratings said Arsenal did not show up at any point and "got what they deserved", giving Havertz 1/10 and Guimarães 3, with Ødegaard the main positive. Evening StandardN “ultimately got what they deserved, in one of the great cup upsets”“Bruno Guimaraes (Zubimendi 82’) 3” Read at Evening Standard ↗
Centre · 1The Evening Standard's analysis called the result a "humiliation" despite nine changes, argued the line-up was good enough to win, and said Havertz missed three big chances and Gyökeres' goal was fortuitous. Evening StandardN “Arsenal made nine changes for this match but the starting lineup was more than good enough to get the job done.”“He missed three big chances and was nowhere close to the required level.” Read at Evening Standard ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left2 outlets
- Framing
- Narrative match report celebrating Fleetwood's resilience; ABC Australia frames it as an all-time upset with league-pyramid context.
- Emphasis
- Fleetwood's defending, goalkeeper Lynch, the drone delay, the pitch invasion; ABC stresses the 84-place gap and Fleetwood's two shots on goal.
- Leaves out or plays down
- The Guardian text does not give the shootout scoreline; ABC gives little on Dowman's sending-off context or Arteta's reaction.
- Charged language
- “all-time upset”“minnow”“boilover”
- For example
-
“Arsenal knocked out of League Cup by fourth-tier minnow in all-time upset” — ABC News (Australia)
“in a massive boilover” — ABC News (Australia)
Centre3 outlets
- Framing
- CNA reports the upset briefly; the Evening Standard frames it as an embarrassing Arsenal failure and runs follow-ups on Arteta's treatment of Dowman; BBC places it among the biggest cup upsets.
- Emphasis
- Arsenal's failings, selection for the Liverpool game, Dowman's red card, Arteta's reaction and Merson's criticism.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Little on Fleetwood's play or the drone delay in the Standard pieces.
- Charged language
- “humiliation”“embarrassing night”
- For example
-
“On one of the worst nights in the club's recent history, Arsenal were dumped out of the Carabao Cup” — Evening Standard
“pulling off a major upset at Highbury Stadium” — CNA
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- IJR gives a short result summary of the shock, with Dowman's red card and Arteta's stern words.
- Emphasis
- Fleetwood's perfect shootout, Guimarães' miss, Dowman's dismissal.
- Leaves out or plays down
- No detail on the drone delay, Fleetwood's performance or the red-card debate.
- Charged language
- “stunned”
- For example
-
“League Two Fleetwood Town stunned Premier League champions Arsenal in the Carabao Cup fourth round” — IJR
What every side reports
- Fleetwood Town beat Arsenal on penalties after a 1-1 draw in the Carabao Cup fourth round.
- Loupalo-Bi scored for Fleetwood and Gyökeres for Arsenal.
- Max Dowman was sent off late in normal time.
- Bruno Guimarães' penalty was saved and Conor Haughey scored the winning penalty.
Where accounts differ
-
Length of the drone stoppage
- Left
- ABC: nearly eight minutes
- Centre
- CNA: more than eight minutes
- Right
- Not stated
-
Whether Guimarães' penalty was saved or missed
- Left
- ABC: a miss on Arsenal's fourth attempt
- Centre
- Evening Standard: saved
- Right
- IJR: missed from the spot
-
Severity of Dowman's red card
- Left
- Guardian: looked harsh
- Centre
- Standard: straight red, force minimal; Merson: harsh, could have been yellow
- Right
- IJR: sent off for kicking out
-
Fleetwood won the shootout 5-3 after a 1-1 draw.
Supported- Supports 2
- ABC News (Australia), CNA
- Reports 2
- Evening Standard, IJR
-
Arsenal's Max Dowman was sent off for kicking out at Fleetwood's Harrison Neal, with little force.
Reported- Reports 4
- ABC News (Australia), CNA, Evening Standard, IJR
Fleetwood Town organisation
Presented as the deserving underdogs who defended deep with conviction and won the shootout.
“Matt Lawlor’s side continued to hold firm, defending deep but with conviction.” — The Guardian
Arsenal organisation
Presented as the favourites who dominated possession but failed to break down Fleetwood, then went out on penalties.
“The Gunners did not show up at any point at Highbury Stadium” — Evening Standard
Left2 articles
-
Fantastic Fleetwood seal shootout success in Carabao Cup shock against Arsenal
Sympathetic Match report that praises Fleetwood's performance and adds colour on the drone and pitch invasion.

-
Arsenal knocked out of League Cup by fourth-tier minnow in all-time upset
Celebratory Treats it as one of the biggest upsets in the competition's history, with pyramid context.
Centre8 articles
-
Critical Short result report presenting the defeat as a cup exit for Arsenal.
-
Critical Harsh player ratings blaming Arsenal's players for an embarrassing upset.
-
CNAN ·
Fourth-tier Fleetwood stun Arsenal in League Cup shootout
Neutral Concise result report stressing the upset and Fleetwood's league position.
-
Mikel Arteta left with Arsenal selection headache for Liverpool clash after Carabao Cup humiliation
Critical Opinionated analysis blaming Arsenal's performance and selection, looking ahead to Liverpool.

Show 4 moreShow fewer
-
Mikel Arteta explains angry reaction to Max Dowman after Arsenal red card
Neutral Reports Arteta's explanation of his reaction to Dowman and his praise of the players' attitude.
-
Where does Fleetwood beating Arsenal rank in biggest cup upsets?
Neutral Historical context ranking Fleetwood's win among the biggest FA Cup and League Cup upsets.

-
Arsenal: Mikel Arteta called out for reaction to Max Dowman red card
Critical Relays Merson's criticism that Arteta should have comforted Dowman.

-

Right1 article
-
IJRRC ·
League Two Fleetwood stuns Arsenal in Carabao Cup shootout
Neutral Brief factual summary of the upset, noting Arteta's stern words to Dowman.
- 27 Oct 22:01 First IJRRC League Two Fleetwood stuns Arsenal in Carabao Cup shootout
- 27 Oct 22:11 +11m Evening StandardN Fleetwood Town 1-1 Arsenal (5-3 on penalties): Gunners crash out of Carabao Cup after penalty shootout loss
- 27 Oct 22:22 +21m Evening StandardN Arsenal player ratings vs Fleetwood: 5/10s and lower across the board as striker handed 1/10 for 'horror show'
- 27 Oct 22:26 +25m The GuardianLC Fantastic Fleetwood seal shootout success in Carabao Cup shock against Arsenal
- 27 Oct 22:40 +39m CNAN Fourth-tier Fleetwood stun Arsenal in League Cup shootout
- 27 Oct 22:48 +47m Evening StandardN Mikel Arteta left with Arsenal selection headache for Liverpool clash after Carabao Cup humiliation
- 27 Oct 22:54 +54m ABC News (Australia)LC Arsenal knocked out of League Cup by fourth-tier minnow in all-time upset
- 27 Oct 23:21 +1h 21m Evening StandardN Mikel Arteta explains angry reaction to Max Dowman after Arsenal red card
- 27 Oct 23:35 +1h 34m BBC NewsN Where does Fleetwood beating Arsenal rank in biggest cup upsets?
- 27 Oct 23:37 +1h 36m Evening StandardN Arsenal: Mikel Arteta called out for reaction to Max Dowman red card
- 28 Oct 00:01 +2h Evening StandardN Arsenal: How many games Max Dowman will miss after Carabao Cup red card
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…