Football regulator chair Kogan says he would resign over political interference in Man City case
David Kogan, chair of the Independent Football Regulator, said he would resign if ministers interfered over Manchester City's future. He also said the regulator would wait for City's appeal before acting.
1 / 4
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2David Kogan, chair of the Independent Football Regulator (IFR), said he would resign if the regulator came under political interference over the future of Manchester City. BBC NewsN “The head of English football's independent regulator says he will resign if he encounters any political interference over the future of Manchester City.” Read at BBC News ↗ City A.M.RC “any form of political interference in the way we operate is going to result in my resigning from this role, and I stand by that completely.” Read at City A.M. ↗ Mixed · 2Kogan told BBC Sport that no politician had tried to influence the regulator, and said the Prime Minister was "entirely entitled to make his own observations on anything". BBC NewsN “The Prime Minister is entirely entitled to make his own observations on anything.” Read at BBC News ↗ City A.M.RC “we’ve come under absolutely no political pressure whatsoever on this or any other topic” Read at City A.M. ↗ Centre · 1The comments followed Prime Minister Andy Burnham's remark last month that he would be "really concerned" if City's Abu Dhabi owners decided to sell. Burnham was criticised for it, and later denied that his reaction had "downplayed the seriousness of the findings". BBC NewsN “Last month, the Prime Minister Andy Burnham was criticised for saying he would be "really concerned" if Manchester City's Abu Dhabi owners decided to sell up.”“before later denying his reaction had "downplayed the seriousness of the findings"” Read at BBC News ↗
Centre · 1BBC Sport said some Premier League clubs were "astonished" by Burnham's stance and, according to its sources, were concerned about political interference in the appeal process. It also said Burnham's earlier role as mayor of Greater Manchester had raised questions about his relationship with City's owners. Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch demanded details of his meetings with senior club figures, and the government released them on Monday. BBC NewsN “some Premier League clubs were so "astonished" by Burnham's stance that sources told BBC Sport they were "concerned" about political interference in the appeal process.”“The government released these details on Monday.” Read at BBC News ↗ Mixed · 2An independent commission found City broke Premier League financial rules over nine years, from 2009 to 2018, using "sham" contracts with commercial partners to secretly channel more than £830m into the football operations. City say they are innocent and have appealed. BBC NewsN “creating "sham" contracts with commercial partners to secretly funnel more than £830m into their football operations. City insist they are innocent and have appealed.” Read at BBC News ↗ City A.M.RC “City’s appeal against more than 100 convictions of financial rule-breaking” Read at City A.M. ↗ Centre · 1The commission's report said "a number of important club witnesses gave false evidence in key respects". City were found guilty of all charges except one, relating to non-cooperation with the Premier League investigation. BBC NewsN “a number of important club witnesses gave false evidence in key respects and that some knowingly gave untrue and dishonest evidence”“with City also guilty of all charges except one relating to non-cooperation with the Premier League investigation.” Read at BBC News ↗
Mixed · 2Kogan said the IFR could not reach any conclusion until the appeal outcome is known, and that its action would follow a statutory process and legal advice. The IFR's powers concern individual owners, directors and senior executives and whether they can run a club safely and with probity. BBC NewsN “We cannot reach any conclusion at this stage because we don't know the outcome of any appeal and once we do then we will act accordingly.” Read at BBC News ↗ City A.M.RC “which Kogan said would be based on legal advice.” Read at City A.M. ↗ Right · 1City A.M. reported that the regulator could disqualify City's owner, Sheikh Mansour, and force a sale. If he missed a deadline, a third party would take over the sale at a price City could not control. City A.M.RC “If disqualified, Sheikh Mansour would be given a deadline to sell which, if not met, would trigger a third party taking over the sale at a price City would have no control over.” Read at City A.M. ↗ Centre · 1Separately, the independent panel will hold a sanctions hearing that could take months to convene. Possible punishments range from a fine or points deduction to expulsion from the Premier League or loss of trophies, and City can appeal both the verdicts and the sanction. BBC NewsN “The independent panel will hold a sanctions hearing - which could take months to convene - to decide the punishment.”“City can appeal both the guilty verdicts and the sanction” Read at BBC News ↗
Right · 1Kogan also said that if the IFR faced a long-running legal challenge from a wealthy owner, it would ask the government for extra financial support outside its levy-funded budget. Kogan said they did not expect a problem with the Treasury or the Department for Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS). City A.M.RC “If we’re facing a long-running legal challenge, we will clearly go back to government and get financial support from government.”“I don’t expect a problem with the Treasury or with DCMS” Read at City A.M. ↗ Right · 1City A.M. noted that Kogan previously donated to the Labour leadership campaigns of Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy and Keir Starmer. It also reported that Kogan and CEO Richard Monks were speaking at the launch of the draft State of the Game report. They said the regulator would take a broader, more proactive view of loopholes in clubs' financial rules, and that it would announce its levy plans next week. City A.M.RC “who previously donated to the Labour leadership campaigns of Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy and Burnham’s predecessor Keir Starmer.”“The IFR will next week reveal its plans for the levy on clubs” Read at City A.M. ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre2 outlets
- Framing
- Leads on Kogan's resignation pledge. Puts it in the context of the Burnham row, the commission's findings and the process still to come.
- Emphasis
- Burnham's comments and the criticism of them, club concern, Badenoch's demand for meeting details, the nature of the rule-breaking, and possible sanctions.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention Kogan's past Labour donations or the regulator's plan to seek extra government funding for legal fights.
- Charged language
- “sham”“astonished”
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Frames the story as a warning to Prime Minister Burnham. Raises the prospect of government meddling and an Abu Dhabi legal challenge.
- Emphasis
- Kogan's independence pledge, his past Labour donations, the possible forced sale of the club, the funding of legal fights, and wider regulator business such as loopholes and the levy.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention Burnham's denial, the clubs' concern, Badenoch's demand for meeting details or the commission's finding of false witness evidence.
- Charged language
- “meddle”“meddling”“fears of government interference”
What every side reports
- Kogan said he would resign if the IFR faced political interference over Manchester City.
- Kogan said the IFR has faced no political pressure so far.
- City have appealed the findings that they broke Premier League financial rules.
- The IFR will wait for the appeal outcome before acting.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether Burnham's remarks raised a real risk of interference
- Centre
- BBC says Burnham was criticised, and that some clubs were concerned about interference in the appeal. It also reports his denial that he downplayed the findings.
- Right
- City A.M. says Burnham's concerns prompted "fears of government interference". It presents Kogan's resignation pledge as a warning to Burnham.
David Kogan person
Says the regulator's independence is absolute and that he would resign over political interference. Says no pressure has been applied, and that it will follow statute and wait for the appeal.
“Our independence is absolute, and my independence personally is absolute” — City A.M.
“Process is going to drive what we do.” — BBC News
Independent Football Regulator organisation
Says it will act independently and under statute once the appeal outcome is known. It would seek extra government funding for any major legal fight.
“We are not a black and white, tick-box regulator” — City A.M.
“we will bring in a view in terms of our own investigation and statutory powers if we need to do so.” — BBC News
Andy Burnham person
Said he would be "really concerned" if City's owners sold up. He later denied that this downplayed the seriousness of the findings. Kogan said the Prime Minister was entitled to his own observations.
“before later denying his reaction had "downplayed the seriousness of the findings"” — BBC News
Manchester City organisation
Insists it is innocent and has appealed the findings.
“City insist they are innocent and have appealed.” — BBC News
Left1 article
Centre2 articles
-
Football regulator says he would quit over political interference in Man City case
Neutral Reports Kogan's pledge in the context of the Burnham controversy and the commission's findings, with sourced detail on the next steps.

-

Right1 article
-
Football regulator warns Burnham: I’ll quit if ministers meddle in Manchester City
Mixed Presents Kogan's pledge as a warning to Burnham, and adds detail on funding and the regulator's wider agenda.

- 13 Oct 17:00 First City A.M.RC Football regulator warns Burnham: I’ll quit if ministers meddle in Manchester City
- 13 Oct 17:00 First BBC NewsN Football regulator says he would quit over political interference in Man City case
- 13 Oct 17:00 First The GuardianLC Football regulator chair insists he will resign if politically pressured over Manchester City
- 13 Oct 18:15 +1h 15m Anadolu AgencyN English football regulator chief vows to resign if there is political interference in Manchester City case
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…
