Don Warrington set to return to Death in Paradise as Commissioner Selwyn Patterson
Don Warrington appears in the cast for the next Death in Paradise series, after his character left the BBC show and then briefly reappeared. His return was revealed by a cast-wrap photo shared by a co-star.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Don Warrington, who has played Commissioner Selwyn Patterson on the BBC detective drama Death in Paradise since it began in 2011, is set to return for the next series. The IndependentLC “The actor has played Commissioner Selwyn Patterson on the cosy detective show since it started in 2011” Read at The Independent ↗ Radio TimesN “he's confirming that he's actually returning to the BBC drama for its next run” Read at Radio Times ↗ Mixed · 2His involvement was given away by co-star Élizabeth Bourgine, who shared a photograph of the cast celebrating the end of filming on the new series. The IndependentLC “His role was inadvertently confirmed by co-star Élizabeth Bourgine, who shared an image of the entire cast celebrating the wrap” Read at The Independent ↗ Radio TimesN “a cast-wrap photograph shared by co-star Elizabeth Bourgine that showed him alongside the team” Read at Radio Times ↗ Mixed · 2The character's departure was announced in 2024: Selwyn left the fictional Caribbean island of Saint Marie because of a family crisis. Radio Times places this in season 14. The IndependentLC “It was announced in 2024 that Warrington’s character Commissioner Selwyn Patterson was leaving” Read at The Independent ↗ Radio TimesN “leave the fictional Caribbean island of Saint Marie during season 14 because of a family crisis” Read at Radio Times ↗
Mixed · 2Selwyn then made a brief return in the following series, and some viewers felt misled about his exit. The IndependentLC “made a brief return in the following series, which led to confusion from viewers” Read at The Independent ↗ Radio TimesN “the whole furore did lead some viewers to feel misled about his exit” Read at Radio Times ↗ Mixed · 2Warrington told The i it was only a storyline: producers thought it would be interesting to have Selwyn reach a crisis and then return after dealing with it, with "no Machiavellian intent". He said it was nice to learn viewers liked the character. The IndependentLC ““That was just the storyline, nothing more. The producers thought it would be interesting to have Selwyn reach some kind of crisis” Read at The Independent ↗ Radio TimesN “There was no Machiavellian intent.” Read at Radio Times ↗ Centre · 1Radio Times reports Warrington has previously urged fans to "assume nothing" about Selwyn's long-term future and made no guarantee about how long he will stay, saying the commitment is taken "a year at a time". Radio TimesN “"My advice is to assume nothing," he told Radio Times”“the commitment is taken "a year at a time"” Read at Radio Times ↗
Left · 1Don Gilet currently leads the show as Detective Inspector Mervin Wilson, its fifth lead since 2011 after Ben Miller, Ardal O'Hanlon, Kris Marshall and Ralf Little. Warrington recently praised the series for having two Black leads. The IndependentLC “Death in Paradise stars Don Gilet as Detective Inspector Mervin Wilson, the fifth lead that the show has had since it premiered in 2011.”“Warrington recently praised the series for having two Black leads” Read at The Independent ↗ Mixed · 2The BBC has recommissioned the show for two more seasons and confirmed two more Christmas specials. The Independent says the new season is expected in January after a Christmas special, while Radio Times says season 15 began on 30 January 2026 and the next run is expected in early 2027 after a Christmas special. Radio TimesN “recommissioning it for two further seasons and confirming two more Christmas specials”“the next run expected in early 2027 after a Christmas special” Read at Radio Times ↗ The IndependentLC “The new season is expected to air in January, following a Christmas special.” Read at The Independent ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- A short news item announcing a fan favourite's comeback, with Warrington's quotes on the confusion over his exit.
- Emphasis
- The return, the cast photo reveal, past leads and Warrington's praise for the show's two Black leads.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the BBC's recommissioning or how long Warrington will stay.
- Charged language
- “Fan favourite”
- For example
-
“Fan favourite is set to return to screens in new season” — The Independent
“they’d had the wool pulled over their eyes regarding his exit” — The Independent
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- Warrington is shown clearing up confusion about his comeback and his future, with emphasis on his own words.
- Emphasis
- His 'assume nothing' warning, the year-at-a-time commitment and the BBC's recommissioning of the show.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the show's earlier leads or Warrington's comments on diversity.
- Charged language
- “furore”“debacle”“outcry”
- For example
-
“Don Warrington clears up the confusion over Commissioner Selwyn Patterson's comeback.” — Radio Times
“the whole furore did lead some viewers to feel misled about his exit” — Radio Times
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Don Warrington has played Commissioner Selwyn Patterson since 2011.
- Co-star Élizabeth Bourgine's cast-wrap photo revealed his return.
- Selwyn left over a family crisis, then briefly reappeared, which upset some viewers.
- Warrington told The i it was just a storyline with no Machiavellian intent.
Where accounts differ
-
How long Warrington was away
- Left
- The Independent frames the return as coming after two years away, despite his brief reappearance in the following series.
- Centre
- Radio Times says the character left in season 14 and reappeared the next season, and does not give a two-year gap.
Don Warrington person
Says the exit and return were only a storyline with no intent to deceive viewers. He makes no promise about how long he will stay and tells fans to "assume nothing".
“There was no Machiavellian intent.” — Radio Times
“"My advice is to assume nothing," he told Radio Times” — Radio Times
Death in Paradise other
The BBC drama has been recommissioned for two further seasons and two more Christmas specials.
“recommissioning it for two further seasons and confirming two more Christmas specials” — Radio Times
Left1 article
-
Death in Paradise star returns to BBC show two years after exit
Neutral Brief news report of the return, with background on the earlier exit and the show's lead actors.
Centre1 article
-
Death in Paradise favourite addresses future in the franchise following previous character exit
Sympathetic Warrington's return is presented as welcome news, using his own quotes on the confusion and on how long he will stay.
Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 28 Oct 11:25 First The IndependentLC Death in Paradise star returns to BBC show two years after exit
- 29 Oct 11:02 +23h 37m Radio TimesN Death in Paradise favourite addresses future in the franchise following previous character exit
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…