Four killed fighting wildfires in Bromo Tengger Semeru National Park, East Java
Four people died fighting a wildfire in a national park in East Java on Thursday, Indonesia's Forestry Ministry said. The deaths come as the country faces its worst forest fires in over a decade, with hotspots rising sharply.
1 / 3
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Four people died fighting a wildfire on Thursday in Bromo Tengger Semeru National Park in East Java, Indonesia's Forestry Ministry said on Friday 16 October. CNAN “Four men have died fighting wildfires in a national park on Indonesia's Java island, the forestry ministry said on Friday (Oct 16)” Read at CNA ↗ Al JazeeraLC “The victims were caught in the flames on Thursday in Bromo Tengger Semeru National Park in East Java, the ministry said on Friday.” Read at Al Jazeera ↗ Centre · 1According to national park spokesman Endrip Wahyutama, two of the dead were national park officers and two were security guards helping them; they were trapped by flames and thick smoke, and three died at the scene and a fourth later in hospital. CNAN “Two of the fallen men were national park officers and two were security guards helping them, according to national park spokesman Endrip Wahyutama.”“Three died at the scene and a fourth fourth later in hospital.” Read at CNA ↗ Mixed · 2Two others suffered serious burns: CNA names them as a volunteer firefighter and a hotel security guard who jumped in to help, and says both are receiving medical treatment. CNAN “A volunteer firefighter and a security guard from a nearby hotel who also jumped in to help were receiving medical treatment, said Endrip.” Read at CNA ↗ Al JazeeraLC “Two others suffered serious burns and are receiving medical treatment.” Read at Al Jazeera ↗
Left · 1The ministry's statement did not identify the victims, and called the deaths a reminder that extinguishing forest and land fires is a high-risk operation; it said safety must be the main concern, including tracking fire spread and wind direction and keeping evacuation routes ready. Al JazeeraLC “The ministry did not identify the victims.”“adding that safety “must be the main concern”, including tracking how the fire is spreading and the wind direction, keeping evacuation routes ready” Read at Al Jazeera ↗ Mixed · 2The deaths come during a months-long crisis of blazes and toxic smoke, which Al Jazeera, citing Reuters, describes as Indonesia's worst forest fires in more than a decade. CNAN “as the Southeast Asian country battles a months-long crisis of blazes and toxic smoke” Read at CNA ↗ Al JazeeraLC “as the country battles its worst forest fires in more than a decade” Read at Al Jazeera ↗ Mixed · 2Satellite monitoring detected 799 hotspots nationwide by Thursday evening, up from 372 a day earlier, most in Central Kalimantan followed by southern Sumatra; the ministry cautioned that hotspots are not necessarily individual fires. CNAN “By Thursday evening, the number of hotspots stood at 799 nationally, up from 372 a day earlier.” Read at CNA ↗ Al JazeeraLC “The ministry cautioned that hotspots are not the same as fires, as one blaze can register as several.” Read at Al Jazeera ↗
Centre · 1The ministry voiced particular concern about the area around Tanjung Puting National Park, a habitat for endangered orangutans, and said water-bombing and cloud-seeding have been hampered by low visibility from smoke. CNAN “The ministry expressed particular concern about an area around the Tanjung Puting National Park, an important habitat for endangered orangutans.”“Water-bombing and cloud-seeding operations to make rain have been hampered by low visibility due to smoke from the fires” Read at CNA ↗ Centre · 1Haze has reached unhealthy to very unhealthy, locally hazardous levels in parts of Sumatra and Kalimantan, and the ministry advised people to reduce outdoor activity and wear masks if conditions worsen. CNAN “"unhealthy to very unhealthy conditions, even locally hazardous" due to the haze emitted by the blazes” Read at CNA ↗ Left · 1Al Jazeera, citing Reuters, reports that President Prabowo Subianto has approved accepting help from neighbouring countries, according to Foreign Minister Arrmanatha Nasir; Malaysia offered three helicopters, an aircraft and 52 personnel last month without follow-up, and Singapore says it is ready to help. Al JazeeraLC “Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto has approved accepting help from neighbouring countries, Foreign Minister Arrmanatha Nasir said, according to Reuters.”“Malaysia offered last month to send three helicopters, an aircraft and 52 personnel, but there has been no follow-up, Reuters reported.” Read at Al Jazeera ↗
Left · 1Al Jazeera adds that the smoke has blanketed neighbouring countries, caused respiratory problems for hundreds of thousands of people and forced school closures in Malaysia and East Timor, and that Indonesia has faced heavy criticism over the fires. Al JazeeraLC “Indonesia has faced heavy criticism over the fires, which have caused respiratory problems for hundreds of thousands of people and forced school closures in Malaysia and East Timor, according to Reuters.” Read at Al Jazeera ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left2 outlets
- Framing
- Places the deaths in the wider context of Indonesia's worst fires in over a decade and the regional and diplomatic fallout.
- Emphasis
- Acceptance of foreign help, Malaysia's unanswered offer, cross-border haze, criticism of Indonesia.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Gives no detail on who the victims were or on haze conditions and the Tanjung Puting concern.
- Charged language
- “worst forest fires in more than a decade”
- For example
-
“Indonesia has faced heavy criticism over the fires, which have caused respiratory problems for hundreds of thousands of people” — Al Jazeera
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- Focuses on the incident and the ministry's operational update: who the victims were, hotspot numbers, haze and obstacles to firefighting.
- Emphasis
- Victim details, hotspots by region, orangutan habitat, haze health advice.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the foreign help offers or regional criticism.
- For example
-
“Two of the fallen men were national park officers and two were security guards helping them, according to national park spokesman Endrip Wahyutama.” — CNA
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Four people died fighting a wildfire on Thursday in Bromo Tengger Semeru National Park, East Java, per the Forestry Ministry.
- Two others were seriously burned.
- Nationwide hotspots reached 799 by Thursday night.
- The ministry called firefighting a high-risk operation.
Where accounts differ
-
Size of the hotspot increase
- Left
- Al Jazeera says 799, up 427 from the day before (implying 372).
- Centre
- CNA says hotspots rose to 799 from 372 a day earlier.
Left2 articles
-
Four killed as Indonesia battles worst forest fires in more than a decade
Mixed Frames the deaths within a larger crisis and Indonesia's regional criticism, relaying Reuters.
-
Centre1 article
-
CNAN ·
Four killed fighting wildfires in Indonesian national park
Neutral Factual report of the deaths and ministry update, with victim details.
Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 16 Oct 05:59 First CNAN Four killed fighting wildfires in Indonesian national park
- 16 Oct 06:15 +16m Al JazeeraLC Four killed as Indonesia battles worst forest fires in more than a decade
- 16 Oct 08:09 +2h 10m ABC News (Australia)LC Four dead and two others badly burnt in Indonesia wildfire
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…