Skip to content
Bramble

US

Freedmen group says reparations should cover only descendants of enslaved people, not immigrants

Activists from the U.S. Freedmen Project told Fox News Digital that reparations programs in states such as New Jersey and New York should be limited to lineal descendants of enslaved people. Only two right-leaning outlets, one republishing the other's report, covered it.

2 outlets · 0L · 0C · 2R First reported Account updated
Image: Fox News
Image: New York Post

1 / 2

The story, neutrally told

Activists from the U.S. Freedmen Project told Fox News Digital that recent immigrants and non-foundational Black Americans should not be included in government reparations programs. Spokesperson Annette Wilcox said policies cite slavery and Jim Crow but then direct resources to a wider group, which she called using "one group of people's history to then give remedies to a wider group". The group describes itself as made up of self-identified "Foundational Black Americans" and says true reparations must be lineage-based, reserved for direct descendants of enslaved people in the United States.

Wilcox reacted to New Jersey's proposed Truth, Reconciliation, and Repair Act, sponsored by Assemblywoman Verlina Reynolds-Jackson and state Sen. Angela McKnight, which would set up a framework for state-level reparative policies. Group president Devine Prince said the left is "conflating reparations with racial justice and social justice", and argued that a policy tied to lineage rather than race is more likely to survive legal challenges. At a New York hearing on Long Island, supporter Aubrey Muhammad said politicians had directed resources away from historic Black communities, and claimed Democrats "imported 25 million immigrants", 70% of whom he said settled in poor Black neighborhoods; the articles do not test those figures.

The articles cite Census data showing Hempstead is now 43.2% Black and 45.3% Hispanic or Latino, against roughly 14% Hispanic in 1990. Evanston, Illinois, which distributed government-funded reparations, faces a class-action lawsuit alleging its race-based eligibility violates the Equal Protection Clause; Fox names Judicial Watch as the plaintiff, while the Post adds the Trump administration. The New Jersey lawmakers did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on.

Left0 outlets

No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Centre0 outlets

No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Right2 outlets

Framing
Presents the Freedmen Project's view as an intra-Black critique of Democratic-led states, saying they use slavery's history to fund a broader agenda. The New York Post republishes the Fox News Digital report almost verbatim under a Fox byline.
Emphasis
Quotes from Freedmen Project leaders, criticism of Democrats and 'people of color' coalitions, immigration and demographic change in Hempstead, and legal vulnerability of race-based programs.
Leaves out or plays down
No voices from New Jersey lawmakers, the New Jersey Reparations Council or advocates for broader eligibility; the claim about 25 million immigrants is not fact-checked; no detail on what the New Jersey bill would actually provide.
Charged language
“in a sick way”“flooded with immigrants”“hijack the legal definition of reparations”
For example
“Reparations activists call out blue states for using slavery history to fund broader agenda” — Fox News
“Reparations activists call out Democrat states for using slavery history to fund broader agenda” — New York Post