Georgia election board director asks DOJ to bar QR-code vote counting before midterms
Georgia State Election Board executive director James Mills wrote to the Justice Department asking it to prohibit QR-code vote tabulation, after a split board vote. At a Thursday meeting, board Republicans also declined to advance a separate RNC proposal on a ballot-secrecy flaw.
Updated (version 2). New coverage since the last version from Just the News, Washington Examiner.
1 / 4
The story, neutrally told
Right · 3In a letter to US Attorney General Todd Blanche and Assistant Attorney General Harmeet Dhillon, who heads the Justice Department's Civil Rights Division, James Mills, executive director of Georgia's State Election Board, asked the department to "prohibit" the state's QR code-based vote counting; Raw Story dated the letter Thursday, 1 October, while the Washington Examiner and Just the News said Wednesday. Raw StoryL “In a letter sent Thursday, board Executive Director James Mills asked Attorney General Todd Blanche and Assistant Attorney General Harmeet Dhillon” Read at Raw Story ↗ Washington ExaminerR “Board executive director James Mills penned the letter to Attorney General Todd Blanche, Assistant Attorney General for Civil Rights Harmeet Dhillon, and Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin on Wednesday.” Read at Washington Examiner ↗ Just the NewsRC “penned the letter to Attorney General Todd Blanche and Assistant Attorney General for Civil Rights Harmeet Dhillon on Wednesday.” Read at Just the News ↗ Left · 1Mills also urged federal officials to set a binding six-month deadline for Georgia to switch to a different voting system, to force a statewide software update before November, and to investigate the secretary of state's office over allegations that it withheld or altered election records. Raw StoryL “Mills also urged federal officials to "set a binding six-month deadline" for Georgia to switch to a different voting system.”“to investigate the secretary of state's office over allegations that it withheld or altered election records” Read at Raw Story ↗ Right · 1The Washington Examiner described the letter as asking for "review and, where appropriate, investigation and intervention" on Georgia's voting system, ballot secrecy, election records, and the sharing of voter registration and motor vehicle data with outside organizations. Washington ExaminerR ““review and, where appropriate, investigation and intervention concerning Georgia’s voting system, ballot secrecy, preservation and access to election records, and the sharing of voter registration and motor vehicle data with outside organizations.”” Read at Washington Examiner ↗
Left · 1Mills argued that "unreadable, unverifiable QR code-based vote tabulation" violates the Help America Vote Act because voters cannot check the vote that is actually counted, and said the system "can be compromised in seconds with an ordinary ballpoint pen, as demonstrated in federal court." Raw StoryL “"unreadable, unverifiable QR code-based vote tabulation" runs afoul of the Help America Vote Act (HAVA)” Read at Raw Story ↗ Left · 1The letter followed a resolution passed earlier in the week directing Mills to seek help from the Trump administration; Carolyn Roddy introduced it, and Vice Chair Janelle King and Salleigh Grubbs joined her in passing it, while Chairman John Fervier, Gov. Brian Kemp's appointee, opposed it. Raw StoryL “Member Carolyn Roddy, the Republican Party's appointee, introduced the measure, and Vice Chair Janelle King and member Salleigh Grubbs joined her in passing it”“Board Chairman John Fervier, Gov. Brian Kemp's appointee, opposed it.” Read at Raw Story ↗ Left · 1Fervier said he has "a fundamental issue with the federal government becoming involved in Georgia elections"; Democracy Docket, cited by Raw Story, noted that the Constitution leaves election administration to state and local officials and that the Justice Department has no legal power to declare voting machines unlawful on its own. Raw StoryL “"I have a fundamental issue with the federal government becoming involved in Georgia elections," Fervier said.”“the Justice Department has no legal power to declare voting machines unlawful or seize them on its own, Democracy Docket noted” Read at Raw Story ↗
Left · 1Mills copied Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin, who has separately asked the Justice Department to declare QR code machines unlawful under HAVA. Raw StoryL “Mullin has separately asked the Justice Department to declare QR code machines unlawful under HAVA.” Read at Raw Story ↗ Right · 2Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger's office criticised the letter; spokeswoman Michon Lindstrom said, "People who are serious about election security don't inject chaos in the eleventh hour," and that Georgia's 159 election directors would run the election in about 30 days. Washington ExaminerR ““People who are serious about election security don’t inject chaos in the eleventh hour,” Raffensperger spokeswoman Michon Lindstrom said.” Read at Washington Examiner ↗ Just the NewsRC “Raffensperger's office slammed the allegations and the letter” Read at Just the News ↗ Right · 2Justice Department officials told the Atlanta Journal-Constitution, as relayed by the Washington Examiner, that any decision on action is made independently "based on the facts and the law"; Just the News said state officials have said a software update cannot be completed before voting begins because it takes months. Washington ExaminerR ““any decision on whether to take action is made independently by the Department, based on the facts and the law.”” Read at Washington Examiner ↗ Just the NewsRC “State election officials have said updating the software cannot be completed before voting begins because it is a months-long process.” Read at Just the News ↗
Right · 1The resolution urges the secretary of state to upgrade voting software to address a ballot-secrecy flaw and other vulnerabilities; the board's lone Democrat, Sara Ghazal, said it was too close to the midterms for an update and opposed federal intervention. New York PostR “The resolution also called on the board's executive director to seek help for the effort from the Trump administration.”“said it was too close to the midterm elections for a software update and that she opposed federal intervention in state elections” Read at New York Post ↗ Right · 1According to AP, the flaw, found by researchers in 2022, does not allow votes to be changed or cast doubt on results, but allows ballots to be put back in the order cast, so that with other public data someone could match voters to their ballots. New York PostR “The software vulnerability does not allow votes to be changed or cast doubt on election results, but it could let someone see how others voted.”“the equipment's software flaw allows them to be put back in the order they were cast, according to a report by researchers who discovered it in 2022” Read at New York Post ↗ Right · 1At a Thursday meeting, King and Roddy criticized a separate proposal from the Georgia Republican Party and the RNC to have county officials shuffle ballots at polling sites before they are cast, citing burdens on counties and timing days before early voting starts on 13 October; the board adjourned without voting on it. New York PostR “such a requirement would impose new burdens on county election officials, including possibly having to hire additional poll workers”“The board adjourned Thursday without taking a vote on the proposal by the RNC and the Georgia Republican Party” Read at New York Post ↗
Right · 1Election security expert Ben Adida told the board the state had already taken steps to reduce risks and that a software update days before a major election could cause bigger problems. New York PostR “told the board Thursday the state had already taken steps to reduce risks to the voting system and that a software update days ahead of a major election could cause bigger problems” Read at New York Post ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Leads on the board's request to the Trump DOJ and the chair's opposition, stressing federal overreach.
- Emphasis
- Mills's letter demands, Fervier's objection, and the DOJ's lack of legal power to declare machines unlawful.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the ballot-secrecy flaw details, the RNC proposal, Raffensperger's office's response, or the expert and Democratic objections to a software update.
- For example
-
“Georgia's Republican-controlled State Election Board is asking the Justice Department to declare the state's voting machines illegal ahead of the midterms.” — Raw Story
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right3 outlets
- Framing
- Washington Examiner and Just the News frame it as a request that the DOJ investigate Georgia's voting systems, with Raffensperger's rebuttal; the New York Post runs AP copy on Republicans criticising their own party's ballot-shuffling proposal.
- Emphasis
- The scope of the request (QR-code tabulation, software, records), Raffensperger's "eleventh hour" response, election timing, and the secrecy flaw's limits in the AP copy.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Neither Examiner nor Just the News mention Chairman Fervier's dissent or the board vote; the AP copy does not mention Mills's letter.
- For example
-
“The executive director of Georgia’s State Election Board has asked the Justice Department to investigate the state’s voting systems.” — Washington Examiner
“The Georgia State Election Board asked the Justice Department this week to investigate the state’s voting systems” — Just the News
What every side reports
- Georgia's State Election Board passed a resolution this week directing its executive director to seek Trump administration help on voting software.
- Roddy, King and Grubbs backed the resolution; the board's Democrat opposed federal intervention.
- Early voting in Georgia starts 13 October.
Where accounts differ
-
What the board's actions amount to
- Left
- Presented as a Republican-controlled board defying its chair to ask the Trump DOJ to declare the machines illegal.
- Right
- Presented as Republican board members declining to advance their party's plan to fix a ballot-secrecy flaw; the DOJ letter is not covered.
-
Mills's letter asks the DOJ to prohibit Georgia's QR-code-based vote tabulation.
Reported- Reports 3
- Raw Story, Just the News, Washington Examiner
-
Mills's letter accuses the Georgia secretary of state's office of withholding or altering election records.
Reported- Reports 3
- Raw Story, Just the News, Washington Examiner
Georgia State Election Board organisation
Divided: a majority passed a resolution seeking federal help, its executive director wrote to the DOJ, while the chair opposed federal involvement and members criticized the RNC shuffling plan.
“Board Chairman John Fervier, Gov. Brian Kemp's appointee, opposed it.” — Raw Story
“The board adjourned Thursday without taking a vote on the proposal” — New York Post
Left2 articles
-
GOP board defies chair in demand that Trump DOJ declare state's voting machines illegal
Critical Frames the letter as a Republican board defying its chair to invite Trump's DOJ into state elections.

-

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right3 articles
-
New York PostR · · via AP
Georgia election board not moving forward with GOP plan to fix election system flaw
Neutral AP copy explaining the ballot-secrecy flaw and Republican objections to the party's proposed fix.

-
Georgia State Election Board asks Justice Department to investigate voting machines
Neutral Short report stating the letter's asks and Raffensperger's office's response, noting a software update cannot finish before voting.

-
Georgia election board asks DOJ to investigate voting machines
Neutral Reports the letter as a DOJ investigation request with Raffensperger's rebuttal and Georgia's election-integrity backdrop.

- 1 Oct 23:21 First Raw StoryL GOP board defies chair in demand that Trump DOJ declare state's voting machines illegal
- 1 Oct 23:43 +22m New York PostR Georgia election board not moving forward with GOP plan to fix election system flaw via AP
- 2 Oct 19:41 +20h 20m Washington ExaminerR Georgia election board asks DOJ to investigate voting machines
- 3 Oct 03:12 +27h 51m Just the NewsRC Georgia State Election Board asks Justice Department to investigate voting machines
- 5 Oct 13:59 +86h 39m Raw StoryL Chaos as rogue elections staffer asks Trump DOJ to upend midterms: 'You have no idea'
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…