Giants QB J.J. McCarthy wins first start in OT; analysts debate his future beside Jaxson Dart
J.J. McCarthy led the New York Giants to a 27-21 overtime win over the Houston Texans in his first start for the team. Commentators are already asking whether he or the injured Jaxson Dart should be the long-term quarterback.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2J.J. McCarthy made his first start for the New York Giants on Sunday 25 October 2026, completing 20 of 28 passes for 252 yards in a 27-21 overtime win over the Houston Texans. NewsweekN “J.J. McCarthy made his first start for the New York Giants on Sunday against the Houston Texans, leading his new team to a 27-21 overtime win.” Read at Newsweek ↗ Fox NewsR “completing 20 of 28 passes for 252 yards” Read at Fox News ↗ Right · 1Fox News noted that he threw no touchdown, no interception and had no fumble. Harbaugh said, "He sure didn't play perfect but he played a heck of a football game." Fox NewsR “He didn't throw a touchdown pass, but didn't throw an interception and didn't fumble, either.”“He sure didn't play perfect but he played a heck of a football game.” Read at Fox News ↗ Centre · 1McCarthy came to New York by trade from the Minnesota Vikings. Newsweek reported the Giants gave up only a 2027 fifth-round pick for the former 10th overall pick of the 2024 draft, who is on his rookie contract with a fifth-year option. NewsweekN “The Giants sent the Minnesota Vikings only a 2027 fifth-round pick to acquire McCarthy, a former 10th overall pick in the 2024 NFL Draft” Read at Newsweek ↗
Mixed · 2He earned the start after replacing Jameis Winston early in the fourth quarter of a 34-27 Week 6 loss to the New Orleans Saints, when the Giants trailed 34-10. In that relief appearance he went 11 of 21 for 243 yards, one touchdown and one interception. NewsweekN “McCarthy immediately got the Giants back in the game. He completed 11 of 21 passes for 243 yards and one touchdown with one interception” Read at Newsweek ↗ Fox NewsR “McCarthy was officially named the starter on Wednesday, succeeding Jameis Winston who had succeeded the injured Dart.” Read at Fox News ↗ Mixed · 2Jaxson Dart, the Giants' regular starter, is out for the season. Fox News reported he tore his MCL and meniscus, which require surgery. Fox NewsR “JAXSON DART TORE HIS MCL AND MENISCUS WHICH REQUIRE SURGERY AND ENDS HIS 2026 SEASON WITH THE NEW YORK GIANTS” Read at Fox News ↗ NewsweekN “I’m not talking about this season because Jaxson Dart is out.” Read at Newsweek ↗ Centre · 1Coach John Harbaugh spoke after the game about McCarthy's setbacks in the NFL: a torn meniscus that cost him his rookie year, being benched, and being traded. He said, "Guys have scars—he has scars," and added that one heals stronger. NewsweekN “"Guys have scars—he has scars," Harbaugh said.”“But he missed his rookie season because of a torn meniscus.” Read at Newsweek ↗
Mixed · 2The win also featured running back Cam Skattebo, who rushed for a career-high 124 yards a week after Harbaugh benched him. His 42-yard run in overtime set up Devin Singletary's game-winning touchdown. Fox NewsR “Skattebo rushed for a career-high 124 yards”“Harbaugh, who benched Skattebo last week” Read at Fox News ↗ NewsweekN “a 42-yard run by Cam Skattebo, which helped set up Devin Singletary’s game-winning touchdown” Read at Newsweek ↗ Centre · 1Skattebo said he felt something in his hamstring on that final run, and Newsweek reported that Tyrone Tracy Jr. also hurt a hamstring. Skattebo noted, "Good thing we have a bye week." NewsweekN “"Good thing we have a bye week," Skattebo said after the game.” Read at Newsweek ↗ NewsweekN “Tracy hurt his hamstring before halftime, and Skattebo’s hamstring flared up as he finished his 42-yard gain.” Read at Newsweek ↗ Right · 1Fox News's Armando Salguero reported that Harbaugh opened his news conference by thanking "the Lord God in heaven" and called it "a player's win". Harbaugh said, "We're going to be in it until the end now." Fox NewsR “very grateful to my Lord, High Rock, Protector and Stronghold, the Lord God in heaven”“"We're going to be in it until the end now," Harbaugh said.” Read at Fox News ↗
Centre · 1The Giants are 4-2-1 and lead the NFC East. Harbaugh called the two games after the bye the season's most important, saying they "will set the direction for the rest of the season". Newsweek names the Philadelphia Eagles as the first opponent, with one article giving the date as Nov. 8; its articles label the bye and that game as both Week 8 and Week 9. NewsweekN “The two most important games of the season will be coming up after we come back from the bye”“Week 9 brings the Philadelphia Eagles, then the Washington Commanders on a short week.” Read at Newsweek ↗ NewsweekN “New York will face the Philadelphia Eagles on Nov. 8 after their Week 8 bye.” Read at Newsweek ↗ Centre · 1After the win, Newsweek reported that CBS Sports analyst Nate Burleson asked whether it is time to discuss who the quarterback will be beyond this season, given that Dart has not proven he can stay healthy. Fellow CBS analyst Bill Cowher replied that it is far too early, and that having two young quarterbacks with the same skill set is ideal. NewsweekN “should we start having the question in the air who is the quarterback moving forward?”“Ideally, if you can have these two young men as your quarterbacks going into next year (it’s ideal).” Read at Newsweek ↗ Centre · 1Newsweek's Michael Gallagher noted that Dart would likely bring a better trade return, while the offense is built around him. He suggested that, "in a perfect world", the Giants would trade McCarthy for a Day 2 pick in the offseason and start Dart in 2027. Before the game, former coach Rex Ryan had called the McCarthy trade a smart play that gives the Giants two young quarterbacks. NewsweekN “In a perfect world, one would think the Giants flip McCarthy for a Day 2 draft pick in the offseason and roll with Dart as their starter in 2027.” Read at Newsweek ↗ NewsweekN “Now you have two young quarterbacks that can play in your system, both under rookie contracts. That is a smart play by John Harbaugh.” Read at Newsweek ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- Newsweek ran several pieces: a pre-game look at the McCarthy decision, post-game reaction, injury notes, and a forward-looking piece on whether McCarthy or Dart is the long-term quarterback.
- Emphasis
- The McCarthy-versus-Dart quarterback question, McCarthy's career path and contract, Harbaugh's remarks, and Skattebo's possible hamstring injury.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Little on the on-field incident of the Skattebo penalty or on the NFL's officiating, which Fox covered.
- Charged language
- “Question Giants Fans Don't Want to Answer”“Has Scars”
- For example
-
“After an impressive performance by Giants QB J.J. McCarthy, the hard question is already being asked about his future in New York.” — Newsweek
“That's an incredibly low-cost, low-risk gamble to take on a young quarterback who has shown flashes in his short time in the league.” — Newsweek
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Fox News (OutKick) centres on Harbaugh's post-game news conference, crediting players and God, with a column-like voice on Skattebo's penalty.
- Emphasis
- Harbaugh's religious thanks, Skattebo's physical running and his bounce-back after being benched, and the NFL's penalties.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not discuss McCarthy's future against Dart, his contract, or the trade details.
- Charged language
- “doghouse”“steamrolled”“foreign and appalling”
What every side reports
- The Giants beat the Texans 27-21 in overtime on 25 October 2026.
- McCarthy went 20 of 28 for 252 yards in his first start for the Giants.
- Jaxson Dart is out for the season.
- Cam Skattebo ran for a career-high 124 yards a week after being benched.
- The Giants are 4-2-1 and head into a bye week.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether McCarthy's future with the Giants is already in question
- Centre
- Newsweek relays Burleson asking if it is time to discuss the long-term quarterback, and Cowher saying it is too early; the writer suggests a McCarthy trade.
- Right
- Fox News does not discuss his long-term future, only that he succeeded Winston and delivered a first win.
John Harbaugh person
Harbaugh praised McCarthy and the running backs, credited the players and God, and said the team will be in the race until the end.
“"We're going to be in it until the end now," Harbaugh said.” — Fox News
“"Guys have scars—he has scars," Harbaugh said.” — Newsweek
J.J. McCarthy person
McCarthy is presented as a resilient young quarterback coming off a good first start. The coverage quotes no direct comment from him.
“McCarthy is expected to remain the 4-2-1 Giants' starting quarterback for the foreseeable future.” — Newsweek
Cam Skattebo person
Skattebo said the performance showed the team that the running backs can deliver, and he flagged a possible hamstring problem.
“It was awesome to be able to show Coach and show the team that we have running backs in the backfield that can do it,” — Newsweek
New York Giants organisation
The Giants moved to 4-2-1, with a two-game NFC East lead heading into the bye.
“At 4-2-1, the Giants carry a two-game NFC East lead into the bye” — Newsweek
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre7 articles
-
Giants' JJ McCarthy Decision Draws Strong Reaction Ahead of First Start
Mixed Pre-game piece that presents the McCarthy trade as a low-risk gamble and flags a possible two-quarterback dilemma once Dart returns.
-
Cam Skattebo Fires Off Incredible Performance After Recent Struggles
Neutral Short item on Skattebo's season-high rushing day after he had no touches the previous week.
-
Giants RB Cam Skattebo Reveals Possible Injury on Final Play of OT
Neutral Injury note on Skattebo's possible hamstring problem after the final overtime play.
-
Giants HC John Harbaugh Says JJ McCarthy 'Has Scars' From Vikings Trade
Sympathetic Highlights Harbaugh's comments on McCarthy's setbacks and resilience.
Show 3 moreShow fewer
-
NFL Analyst Asks the JJ McCarthy Question Giants Fans Don't Want to Answer
Mixed Frames McCarthy's play as raising a future-planning question, relaying Burleson and Cowher and adding the writer's own trade suggestion.
-
Giants HC John Harbaugh Names 2 Most Important Games After OT Win
Neutral Post-game recap of the upset, Harbaugh's view of the two key games after the bye, and the running backs' production.
-
Right2 articles
-
Sympathetic Opinionated recap built on Harbaugh's thanks to God and players, with approving, vivid description of Skattebo's running.
-
- 25 Oct 16:23 First NewsweekN Giants' JJ McCarthy Decision Draws Strong Reaction Ahead of First Start
- 25 Oct 21:38 +5h 15m NewsweekN Cam Skattebo Fires Off Incredible Performance After Recent Struggles
- 25 Oct 21:48 +5h 26m NewsweekN Giants RB Cam Skattebo Reveals Possible Injury on Final Play of OT
- 25 Oct 22:30 +6h 7m Fox NewsR Harbaugh credits players, including J.J. McCarthy and Cam Skattebo, and 'Lord God in heaven' for Giants OT win
- 25 Oct 23:36 +7h 14m NewsweekN Giants HC John Harbaugh Says JJ McCarthy 'Has Scars' From Vikings Trade
- 26 Oct 03:21 +10h 58m NewsweekN NFL Analyst Asks the JJ McCarthy Question Giants Fans Don't Want to Answer
- 26 Oct 14:28 +22h 5m NewsweekN Giants HC John Harbaugh Names 2 Most Important Games After OT Win
- 26 Oct 16:57 +24h 34m Fox NewsR JJ McCarthy opting not to wear eyeblack in Giants win over Texans likely linked to his hatred for Ohio State
- 26 Oct 17:00 +24h 37m NewsweekN Giants Praised After 'Hallmark Win' Over Texans in Week 7
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…