Green member behind Zionism motion named as close friend of jailed al-Qaeda supporter
Lubna Speitan, who proposed the Green Party's "Zionism is racism" motion, was described in 2015 US court documents as a "close friend" of Minh Quang Pham, jailed for 40 years over support for al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula. The Green Party says she holds no party position and that it takes such allegations seriously.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Centre · 2Lubna Speitan, the Green Party member who proposed the party's conference motion on Zionism, was named in 2015 US court documents as a "close friend" of Minh Quang Pham, who was jailed for 40 years in the US for supporting al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula (AQAP). BBC NewsN “In US court documents from 2015, Speitan was listed as a "close friend" of Pham who would provide "critical testimony regarding Pham's mental state".” Read at BBC News ↗ Evening StandardN “Lubna Speitan was referred to in US court documents as a “close friend” of Minh Quang Pham” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Centre · 2The documents said she was willing to testify for the defence, including on Pham's mental state and cognitive limitations, but that a medical condition prevented her from travelling by air or giving evidence in person. BBC NewsN “Speitan had a medical condition that prevented her from giving evidence in person, the documents add.” Read at BBC News ↗ Evening StandardN “she would testify “regarding [her] observations of Pham’s cognitive limitations”” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Centre · 1The BBC reported that Speitan also wrote a 2016 letter to the New York judge calling Pham "one of the kindest, honest, most sincere" people she had known; the Jewish Chronicle first reported the letter, and the BBC has seen it. BBC NewsN “it emerged she wrote a letter in 2016 to the New York judge in the Pham case describing him as "one of the kindest, honest, most sincere" people she had known.”“The existence of the letter was first reported by the Jewish Chronicle, external and it has been seen by BBC News.” Read at BBC News ↗
Centre · 2Asked by the Telegraph whether she was still friends with Pham, Speitan reportedly said "Yes, it's still the case" and that she believed he had been "targeted" by "the system". BBC NewsN “The Telegraph reported that when it asked her if she remained friends with Pham, she replied: "Yes, it's still the case."” Read at BBC News ↗ Evening StandardN “adding that she believed he had been “targeted” by “the system”.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Centre · 2Pham, a Vietnamese-born British national, was extradited to the US in 2015 and admitted three counts based on his support for AQAP; he was sentenced to 40 years in 2016. He denied intending to carry out an attack, and no attack occurred. BBC NewsN “In 2015 he was extradited to the US and in 2016 sentenced to 40 years in prison after he admitted three counts” Read at BBC News ↗ Evening StandardN “though he denied intending to carry out his plot or harm anyone. No attack occurred.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Centre · 2US prosecutors said Pham was directed by Anwar al-Awlaki to detonate explosives in Heathrow's arrivals area after training in Yemen. The BBC says he was arrested at Heathrow in July 2011 with a live round of ammunition, while the Evening Standard says he was first arrested in the UK in June 2012. BBC NewsN “US prosecutors said Pham was directed by al-Qaeda leader Anwar al-Awlaki to detonate explosives in Heathrow's arrivals area”“was arrested at Heathrow Airport in July 2011 after spending seven months in Yemen.” Read at BBC News ↗ Evening StandardN “was first arrested in the UK in June 2012 and was extradited to the US in early 2015.” Read at Evening Standard ↗
Centre · 1The BBC notes there is no suggestion in the documents that Speitan knew of Pham's criminal activities when they knew each other. BBC NewsN “There is no suggestion in the documents that Speitan knew of Pham's criminal activities at the time they knew each other.” Read at BBC News ↗ Centre · 2A Green Party spokesperson said Speitan holds no party positions other than membership, that the party takes "all allegations of this nature seriously", and that it has internal processes to investigate members' views that do not fit its values. Evening StandardN ““Lubna Speitan holds no party positions other than being a member.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ BBC NewsN “"Where members have expressed views that do not fit in with the party's values, we have internal processes to investigate."” Read at BBC News ↗ Centre · 2The motion, passed at the party's Brighton conference on Sunday, makes policy that Zionism be treated like any other form of racism and backs a "single democratic Palestinian state in all of historic Palestine". Evening StandardN “will be “treated as any other form of racism”.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ BBC NewsN “called for a "single democratic Palestinian state in all of historic Palestine"” Read at BBC News ↗
Centre · 1Israel banned Green leader Zack Polanski from entering the country, Jewish groups called the motion an "attack" on their community, and some Labour and Lib Dem MPs reported the party to the equality watchdog, according to the BBC. BBC NewsN “Israel banned Green leader Zack Polanski from entering the country. while Jewish groups described it as an "attack" on their community” Read at BBC News ↗ Centre · 2Polanski, who is Jewish, abstained from the vote after leaving the conference to campaign in the Holborn and St Pancras by-election; he said he would not accept anyone being excluded "because of the religious or communal body they are part of". Evening StandardN “Mr Polanski abstained from the vote, having already left the conference to return to campaigning” Read at Evening Standard ↗ BBC NewsN “he would not accept anyone being excluded from the party "because of the religious or communal body they are part of"” Read at BBC News ↗ Centre · 2Some Green councillors have resigned since the vote, and Phil Davies, deputy leader of the Wales Green Party, quit on Tuesday, calling the motion "the final nail in the coffin" in the BBC's account and "imperialistic" and "idiotic" in the Standard's. BBC NewsN “describing the motion as "the final nail in the coffin".” Read at BBC News ↗ Evening StandardN “He branded the motion “imperialistic” and “idiotic”” Read at Evening Standard ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre2 outlets
- Framing
- Both outlets lead on Speitan's link to Pham as a development in the row over the Green Party's Zionism motion, relying on US court documents and the Telegraph's reporting. The BBC adds that the documents do not suggest she knew of his criminal activity and gives more space to the wider party fallout. The Standard gives more space to Phil Davies's resignation.
- Emphasis
- Court-document wording ("close friend"), Speitan's own comments, the Green Party's response, and resignations and divisions inside the party.
- Leaves out or plays down
- The Standard omits the 2016 letter, Israel's ban on Polanski and the complaints to the equality watchdog. The BBC does not mention the by-election. The two differ on when Pham was arrested.
- Charged language
- “close friend”“Zionism is racism”“imperialistic”“idiotic”
- For example
-
“There is no suggestion in the documents that Speitan knew of Pham's criminal activities at the time they knew each other.” — BBC News
“The “Zionism is racism” vote came just days before the Holborn and St Pancras by-election” — Evening Standard
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Speitan proposed the Green motion and was named in US court documents as a close friend of Minh Quang Pham.
- Pham was jailed for 40 years in the US after admitting counts based on support for AQAP.
- Speitan told the Telegraph she is still friends with Pham.
- The Green Party says Speitan holds no party position beyond membership.
- Phil Davies, Wales Green Party deputy leader, resigned on Tuesday.
Where accounts differ
-
When Pham was arrested
- Centre
- The BBC says he was arrested at Heathrow in July 2011 after seven months in Yemen; the Evening Standard says he was first arrested in the UK in June 2012.
Lubna Speitan person
Reportedly says she is still friends with Pham and believes he was "targeted" by "the system"; earlier described him as kind and trustworthy. She did not respond to the BBC's request for comment.
“Yes, it’s still the case,” adding that she believed he had been “targeted” by “the system”.” — Evening Standard
“Speitan has not responded to the BBC's request for comment.” — BBC News
Green Party party
Says Speitan holds no party positions beyond membership, takes such allegations seriously and has internal processes to investigate members' views.
““Lubna Speitan holds no party positions other than being a member.” — Evening Standard
Minh Quang Pham person
Pham pleaded guilty to three counts based on his support for AQAP but denied intending to carry out an attack or harm anyone.
“though he denied intending to carry out his plot or harm anyone.” — Evening Standard
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre2 articles
-
Green member behind Zionism motion named as 'close friend' of jailed al-Qaeda supporter in court
Neutral Reports the court-document link and Speitan's letter with caveats, noting she was contacted for comment and that nothing suggests she knew of his crimes, alongside the party's internal divisions.

-
Green activist behind anti-Zionism motion was ‘close friend’ of Heathrow terror plotter
Mixed Headline and opening stress her friendship with a "terror plotter", then moves to the motion's fallout and a resignation.

Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 6 Oct 22:41 First BBC NewsN Green member behind Zionism motion named as 'close friend' of jailed al-Qaeda supporter in court
- 7 Oct 08:15 +9h 33m Evening StandardN Green activist behind anti-Zionism motion was ‘close friend’ of Heathrow terror plotter
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.