Greene King chief warns guaranteed-hours reforms could raise pub staffing costs
Nick Mackenzie, chief executive of Greene King, has warned that guaranteed-hours contracts under the Employment Rights Act could raise pubs' costs and reduce staffing flexibility, citing Tube and rail strikes and Christmas hiring. Both outlets covering the story are right-leaning.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Right · 2Nick Mackenzie, chief executive of Greene King, has warned that guaranteed-hours contracts under the Employment Rights Act could raise costs for pubs and leave them unable to respond to sudden changes in demand. Daily MailR “said Ms Rayner's guaranteed hours contracts will make pubs 'hostage to factors beyond their control'” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Daily ExpressR “risks leaving hospitality businesses unable to respond to sudden changes in customer demand” Read at Daily Express ↗ Right · 1Greene King runs about 2,600 pubs, restaurants and hotels across England, Wales and Scotland, and the Daily Mail describes it as Britain's second largest pub group. Daily MailR “which has 2,600 pubs, restaurants and hotels across England, Wales and Scotland”“Boss of Britain's second largest pub group” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Right · 2Under the reforms, staff including those on zero-hours contracts would be entitled to contracts reflecting the hours they have worked over a reference period, expected to be around 12 weeks, and employers could have to pay compensation if shifts are cancelled at short notice. Daily ExpressR “Workers would then be entitled to contracts reflecting the average number of hours they have worked during a specified reference period, which is expected to be around 12 weeks.” Read at Daily Express ↗ Daily MailR “And if their pre-arranged shifts are cancelled, the employer must pay compensation.” Read at Daily Mail ↗
Right · 1Writing in The Telegraph, Mackenzie said rail and Tube strikes have cost the sector more than £4bn since 2022, according to UKHospitality estimates, and that managers currently cope by quickly adapting shift rotas, a flexibility he said the reforms would remove at substantial cost. Daily ExpressR “Since 2022, UK Hospitality estimates that rail and Tube strikes have cost the sector more than £4bn.”“will make strikes even more difficult to navigate because managers will lose this flexibility and thereby face substantial costs” Read at Daily Express ↗ Right · 1He also said hiring extra staff at Christmas could create costs pubs cannot afford, because they would have to offer similar hours in following months when demand is likely to be lower, leading to long waits for customers, lost revenue and fewer extra hours for employees. Daily ExpressR “hiring people in the busy Christmas period risks creating costs pubs cannot afford as they will have to offer similar hours across the following months”“customers facing long waits, businesses losing vital revenue, and employees missing the opportunity to work additional hours” Read at Daily Express ↗ Right · 1The Daily Mail reports that Mackenzie also said the reforms would disincentivise hiring young people and could be 'a final roadblock in supporting people into work', referring to comments by Alan Milburn. Daily MailR “he said the burden of Labour's reforms 'could be a final roadblock in supporting people into work'”“also disincentivise them from hiring young people” Read at Daily Mail ↗
Right · 1The Daily Mail says the reforms are expected to cost employers up to £3billion, and that Mackenzie has joined other bosses in calling for the rules to be adapted for the industry, for example by taking seasonal fluctuations into account when calculating guaranteed hours. Daily MailR “Ms Rayner's reforms are expected to cost employers up to £3billion”“Measures such as taking into account seasonal fluctuations while calculating guaranteed hours have been called for.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Right · 1Emma McClarkin, chief executive of the British Beer and Pub Association, said pubs want to treat staff fairly, but that many employees also want flexibility and that restricting it 'might end up backfiring on the people it's meant to benefit'. Daily MailR “any changes that restrict that flexibility might end up backfiring on the people it's meant to benefit” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Right · 2The Daily Mail says the Act has received Royal Assent but could still be amended in Parliament, while the Express calls the reforms 'proposed'; both credit Angela Rayner with the policy, and the Mail says she championed it as deputy PM. Neither article carries a response from Rayner or the Government. Daily MailR “The new Bill has received Royal Assent but could still be amended in Parliament before it passes into legislation.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Daily ExpressR “Angela Rayner’s proposed employment reforms may “cripple” the pubs” Read at Daily Express ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right2 outlets
- Framing
- Both outlets lead with the Greene King chief's warning that the reforms threaten pubs' flexibility and finances; the Mail uses sharper language about Rayner's plans, and the Express leans on 'experts have warned' and the 'cripple the industry' quote.
- Emphasis
- Staffing costs, loss of flexibility during strikes and Christmas, and the £4bn strike cost; the Mail adds the £3bn employer cost, youth employment and industry calls for changes.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Neither carries a response from Rayner or the Government, nor the case for guaranteed hours as income security beyond a brief mention in the Express; Express quotes only Mackenzie.
- Charged language
- “Savaging Ms Rayner's plans”“ludicrous situation”“desperate pubs”“cripple the industry”
- For example
-
“Savaging Ms Rayner's plans, Mr Mackenzie says they will heap even higher staffing costs on desperate pubs” — Daily Mail
“Pubs could therefore face the ludicrous situation” — Daily Mail
“Such measures are designed to provide greater income security for workers” — Daily Express
What every side reports
- Nick Mackenzie, chief executive of Greene King, which runs about 2,600 pubs, restaurants and hotels, criticised the guaranteed-hours reforms.
- Workers would be entitled to contracts reflecting hours worked over a reference period expected to be around 12 weeks.
- Employers could have to pay compensation for short-notice shift cancellations.
- UKHospitality estimates rail and Tube strikes have cost the sector more than £4bn since 2022.
Where accounts differ
-
Status of the reforms
- Right
- The Daily Mail says the Act has received Royal Assent but could still be amended; the Daily Express calls the reforms 'proposed'.
Greene King organisation
Through chief executive Nick Mackenzie, Greene King says guaranteed-hours contracts remove the flexibility pubs rely on during strikes and seasonal peaks and would raise costs.
“Without flexibility to adapt, pubs will be hostage to factors beyond their control and future strikes could cripple the industry” — Daily Mail
“Our concern is, in the future, the Government’s reforms to zero-hours contracts will make strikes even more difficult to navigate” — Daily Express
Angela Rayner person
Rayner is presented as the author of the reforms, which the Express says are designed to give workers greater income security; no comment from her is quoted.
“Such measures are designed to provide greater income security for workers” — Daily Express
“Angela Rayner championed the Employment Rights Act as deputy PM” — Daily Mail
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right2 articles
-
Critical Presents Mackenzie's warning in strongly negative terms about Rayner's reforms, adding wider business-cost context and a BBPA quote.

-
Angela Rayner warned major pub rule change will ‘cripple the industry’
Critical Reports the reforms as a threat that experts say could 'cripple' pubs, relying on Mackenzie's Telegraph article, with a brief note on their intended purpose.

- 22 Nov 10:43 First Daily MailR Boss of Britain's second largest pub group says Angela Rayner's new workers' rights reforms could increase costs for Britain's watering holes
- 22 Nov 11:22 +39m Daily ExpressR Angela Rayner warned major pub rule change will ‘cripple the industry’
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…