Kushner disputes CNN report on Israeli defence-linked stake; Grisham questions his volunteer status
CNN reported that Jared Kushner's Affinity Partners is the largest shareholder in Israel's Phoenix Financial, which holds stakes in Israeli defence firms. Kushner called the story "deeply misleading", while ex-Trump press secretary Stephanie Grisham said his "volunteer" status lets him avoid disclosing income.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2CNN reported on Thursday 1 October that Jared Kushner's investment firm, Affinity Partners, is the largest shareholder in Phoenix Financial, a Tel Aviv-based Israeli financial institution. Raw StoryL “Kushner's investment firm, Affinity Partners, is the largest shareholder in Phoenix Financial” Read at Raw Story ↗ Fox NewsR “a Tel Aviv-based firm that Kushner’s investment group doubled its stake in last year” Read at Fox News ↗ Mixed · 2According to CNN, Phoenix holds stakes worth more than $456 million in Israeli defence companies. Using Israeli financial transparency laws, CNN found that Phoenix has invested hundreds of millions of dollars in Elbit Systems and holds stakes in at least eight other firms supplying the Israeli military, and that all nine saw their stock value rise last year. Raw StoryL “which holds stakes worth more than $456 million in Israeli defense companies” Read at Raw Story ↗ Fox NewsR “All nine companies identified by CNN saw their stock value climb last year” Read at Fox News ↗ Mixed · 2CNN also reported that Affinity does not directly hold a stake in those nine companies but stands to gain when Phoenix profits, and that Kushner acted as a key negotiator on the Gaza war while Affinity held the stake. The report said it found no indication that Kushner's actions as a diplomat directly affected the investments reviewed. Fox NewsR “Affinity doesn’t directly hold a stake in the nine companies CNN identified — but it does stand to reap rewards when Phoenix makes a profit.” Read at Fox News ↗ Raw StoryL “The network’s report noted it found no indication Kushner’s diplomatic actions directly affected those investments.” Read at Raw Story ↗
Mixed · 2On Friday 2 October Kushner, President Donald Trump's son-in-law, posted on X that CNN had published a "deeply misleading story and headline" suggesting his diplomatic work benefited investments in Israeli defence companies. Raw StoryL “CNN published a deeply misleading story and headline suggesting that my diplomatic work in the Middle East somehow benefited investments in Israeli defense companies” Read at Raw Story ↗ Fox NewsR “accused CNN of publishing a "deeply misleading story and headline"” Read at Fox News ↗ Right · 1Kushner said Phoenix is not a defence company but one of Israel's largest publicly traded financial institutions, managing about $220 billion, which he compared to Vanguard or Fidelity. He said he has no role in deciding what Phoenix buys or sells, that Affinity does not own the defence companies, and that Affinity's investment is public and predates Trump's re-election. He added that the stake is up more than five times since the initial investment. Fox NewsR “I have no role in deciding what Phoenix buys or sells. It has performed very well for Affinity and our investors, up more than five times since our initial investment.”“Think of Phoenix as the Israeli equivalent of Vanguard or Fidelity.” Read at Fox News ↗ Mixed · 2Kushner said CNN's own finding of no direct effect contradicted its headline, and that the facts made "a less provocative headline, but a much more accurate story". Fox News reported that the finding appeared ten paragraphs into CNN's report. Fox NewsR “that point was buried 10 paragraphs deep” Read at Fox News ↗ Raw StoryL “Those facts make for a less provocative headline, but a much more accurate story” Read at Raw Story ↗
Left · 1Kushner said he had ignored "false and misleading stories" for ten years but that "the cycle has gotten out of control", and he promised to put out facts publicly when the truth matters. Raw StoryL “For the last 10 years, I have ignored false and misleading stories about me and focused on the work” Read at Raw Story ↗ Right · 1A CNN spokesperson told Fox News Digital "we stand by our reporting". CNN's report included a statement from Kushner's attorney that any suggestion his diplomatic work influenced Phoenix's investments, or vice versa, is incorrect. A White House spokesperson told CNN that linking his business activity to his diplomacy is a "tired narrative that Democrats have pushed". Fox NewsR “A CNN spokesperson told Fox News Digital that "we stand by our reporting."”“Any suggestion that Jared’s diplomatic work influenced Phoenix’s investments in the companies you identify, or vice versa, is incorrect” Read at Fox News ↗ Left · 1On Thursday, Stephanie Grisham, a former Trump White House press secretary, told CNN's Erin Burnett that Kushner's "volunteer" role in the current administration means he does not have to show much of the money he makes while serving as a temporary public worker. Raw StoryL “the reason he's a volunteer is because you don't have to then claim and show a lot of the money that you make during the time as a temporary public worker” Read at Raw Story ↗
Left · 1Grisham said Affinity was committed $2 billion from Saudi Arabia after the first Trump administration and that she believes its assets are now around $6 billion. She said the arrangement did not fit Kushner's earlier line that "what people call conflicts of interest, I call experience and trusted relationships". This is her account; the coverage does not include a response to it from Kushner. Raw StoryL “Affinity Partners was committed $2 billion from Saudi Arabia. And now I believe its assets are around $6 billion”“Asked whether the arrangement fit Kushner's past claim that "what people call conflicts of interest, I call experience and trusted relationships," Grisham said it didn't.” Read at Raw Story ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Raw Story ran two pieces: one amplifying Grisham's criticism of Kushner's 'volunteer' status as a way to avoid income disclosure, and one reporting Kushner's attack on CNN as an 'unusual public rant'.
- Emphasis
- Grisham's claims about Kushner's finances and access, and Kushner's reaction to CNN, including that CNN found no direct effect on investments.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Gives little of Kushner's detailed rebuttal about Phoenix's size and his lack of role, and nothing from CNN, his attorney or the White House.
- Charged language
- “disturbing aspect”“lashes out”“Out of control”
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Fox News presents the story as Kushner pushing back on a misleading CNN report, with emphasis on where CNN placed its own caveat.
- Emphasis
- Kushner's point-by-point rebuttal, CNN's no-direct-effect line, and the attorney and White House statements.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention Grisham's criticism or the volunteer-status income disclosure question.
- Charged language
- “scolds”“fiery social media post”
What every side reports
- CNN reported on 1 October that Affinity Partners is the largest shareholder in Phoenix Financial.
- CNN found no indication that Kushner's diplomatic actions directly affected the investments it reviewed.
- Kushner called the CNN report 'deeply misleading' in posts on X on 2 October.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether the CNN report was misleading
- Left
- Raw Story relays Kushner's accusation and CNN's no-direct-effect finding without ruling on it.
- Right
- Fox News presents Kushner's view that the headline contradicts the report's own text, and notes CNN stands by its reporting.
-
Whether Kushner's volunteer status shields his income from disclosure
- Left
- Raw Story relays Grisham's claim that it does.
- Right
- Fox News does not address it.
Jared Kushner person
Says the CNN story is misleading, that Phoenix is a regulated financial institution he does not direct, and that the investment predates Trump's re-election.
“I have no role in deciding what Phoenix buys or sells.” — Fox News
CNN organisation
Says it stands by its reporting, while its report noted no indication of direct effect on the investments.
“A CNN spokesperson told Fox News Digital that "we stand by our reporting."” — Fox News
Stephanie Grisham person
Says Kushner's volunteer status lets him avoid showing income and that his conflicts of interest are a problem.
“he's calling himself a volunteer. I mean, that's great volunteer work if you can get it, I guess.” — Raw Story
Affinity Partners organisation
Described by Kushner as an SEC-registered investment firm that does not own the defence companies named by CNN.
“Kushner added that Affinity is an SEC-registered investment firm.” — Fox News
Left2 articles
-
Ex-Trump official flags disturbing aspect of Jared Kushner's 'volunteer' status
Critical Relays Grisham's claim that Kushner's volunteer status shields his income from disclosure, with little counterpoint.

-
‘Out of control’: Jared Kushner lashes out at ‘deeply misleading’ CNN report
Mixed Reports Kushner's attack on CNN while noting CNN found no direct effect, and calls it an unusual rant.

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right1 article
-
Jared Kushner scolds CNN over 'deeply misleading’ report, says key info buried behind paywall
Sympathetic Leads with Kushner's rebuttal and the placement of CNN's caveat, and includes CNN's response and the White House statement.

- 2 Oct 01:26 First Raw StoryL Ex-Trump official flags disturbing aspect of Jared Kushner's 'volunteer' status
- 2 Oct 19:36 +18h 11m Raw StoryL ‘Out of control’: Jared Kushner lashes out at ‘deeply misleading’ CNN report
- 2 Oct 23:21 +21h 56m Fox NewsR Jared Kushner scolds CNN over 'deeply misleading’ report, says key info buried behind paywall
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.