Greenville police rule Hayden Panettiere's death accidental, closing investigation
Greenville, South Carolina police said on 28 October that Hayden Panettiere's death on 16 August was ruled accidental, closing their investigation. A coroner had earlier attributed it to an accidental overdose including fentanyl.
Updated (version 2). New coverage since the last version from BBC News, Daily Mail, Deadline, IJR, NBC News, The Independent, Variety.
1 / 8
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Greenville Police Department announced on Wednesday 28 October that Hayden Panettiere's death has been ruled accidental. CBS NewsLC “The death of Hayden Panettiere has been ruled accidental, South Caroline police announced Wednesday.” Read at CBS News ↗ Fox NewsR “Police announced on Wednesday that actress Hayden Panettiere’s death has been ruled accidental.” Read at Fox News ↗ Mixed · 2In its statement, the department said the ruling was "based on the Medical Examiner’s determination and the findings of the investigation", and that it brings the police investigation to a close. Fox NewsR “The ruling brings the police investigation into her death to a close, the statement said.” Read at Fox News ↗ CBS NewsLC “based on the Medical Examiner's determination and the findings of the investigation” Read at CBS News ↗ Right · 1Panettiere died on 16 August at age 36; Fox News says she was found unresponsive at an apartment in Greenville. Fox NewsR “Panettiere died on Aug. 16 at age 36. She was found unresponsive at an apartment in Greenville, South Carolina.” Read at Fox News ↗
Left · 1According to CBS News, emergency responders were called on the afternoon of 16 August to a residence where she had been staying, and she was pronounced dead there despite "advanced cardiac life support measures", the Greenville County Coroner's Office said. CBS NewsLC “Despite "advanced cardiac life support measures," she was pronounced dead there, the Greenville County Coroner's Office said.” Read at CBS News ↗ Left · 1CBS News reports that last month a South Carolina coroner confirmed she died from an accidental drug overdose that included fentanyl, with no signs of trauma. CBS NewsLC “Last month, a South Carolina coroner confirmed Panettiere died from an accidental drug overdose that included fentanyl. There were no signs of trauma, the coroner's office said.” Read at CBS News ↗ Mixed · 2The coroner's office said in September that the cause of death was the toxic effects of fentanyl, 4-ANPP, alprazolam, methocarbamol and quetiapine, and that the manner of death was accident. Daily MailR “The cause of death has been ruled as toxic effects of fentanyl, 4-ANPP, Alprazolam, Methocarbamol, and Quetiapine. The manner of death has been ruled accident.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ NBC NewsLC “Last month, the Greenville County Coroner’s Office ruled her death an accident caused by the toxic effects of multiple drugs” Read at NBC News ↗
Mixed · 2Deadline reports that investigators had been looking into whether she obtained illicit and possibly counterfeit drugs from a dealer in Southern California; the Daily Mail cites TMZ sources, unverified, who said authorities believed she consumed a single fentanyl-laced oxycodone pill. DeadlineN “Investigators had been looking into whether the actress obtained illicit and possibly counterfeit drugs from a dealer in Southern California.” Read at Deadline ↗ Daily MailR “Last week, insiders told TMZ authorities believed Panettiere had fatally consumed a single oxycodone pill laced with fentanyl.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Left · 1A police report obtained by CBS News says her on-again, off-again boyfriend Brian Hickerson and his brother Zach were at the scene and made the 911 call. CBS NewsLC “Panettiere's on-again, off-again boyfriend Brian Hickerson and his brother Zach were at the scene of her death, according to a police report obtained by CBS News.” Read at CBS News ↗ Left · 2The police report, as described by The Independent and NBC News, says Hickerson handed investigators a "bag of medication" she was taking; NBC adds that the coroner's report said she had been in rehab weeks earlier. The IndependentLC “The report also stated that Brian turned over a “bag of medication” belonging to Panettiere to investigators.” Read at The Independent ↗ NBC NewsLC “had been in rehab just weeks before, according to the coroner’s report” Read at NBC News ↗
Left · 1The Drug Enforcement Administration was among the authorities that had investigated the circumstances, and police earlier said a preliminary investigation had not indicated any signs of foul play or suspicious circumstances. CBS NewsLC “Police previously said that a preliminary investigation "has not indicated any signs of foul play or suspicious circumstances."” Read at CBS News ↗ Centre · 1The BBC says it is unclear whether the DEA's involvement has also concluded, and that Greenville police could not say what the DEA was investigating. BBC NewsN “It is unclear if that investigation has also concluded. The BBC has contacted the DEA for comment.”“could not comment on what the DEA was investigating when contacted by the BBC” Read at BBC News ↗ Mixed · 2Panettiere's mother, Lesley Vogel, said after the coroner's report that her daughter was a "fighter" and that she had "never heard Hayden speak of fentanyl"; Panettiere's representative had earlier called unsourced reports "unverified hearsay". NBC NewsLC “Vogel also said at the time that she had “never heard Hayden speak of fentanyl.”” Read at NBC News ↗ Daily MailR “Recent reports attributed to unnamed sources are unverified hearsay” Read at Daily Mail ↗
Left · 1Separately, her former fiancé Wladimir Klitschko was appointed on 8 October as temporary guardian of the estate of their 11-year-old daughter, Kaya, and has raised concerns that some of Panettiere's belongings were sold to a pawn shop. The IndependentLC “On October 8, Klitschko was appointed temporary guardian of Kaya's estate until a long-term administrator can be appointed.” Read at The Independent ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left4 outlets
- Framing
- CBS, NBC, Variety and The Independent report the closure with the coroner's findings, police-report details about the boyfriend and his brother, and family background.
- Emphasis
- Drug list from the coroner, Hickerson at the scene and the 'bag of medication', Vogel's reaction, Klitschko's guardianship filing.
- Leaves out or plays down
- CBS gives only 'fentanyl' rather than the full list of drugs; none mention the TMZ dealer reports.
- Charged language
- “Overdose Death Investigation Closed”
- For example
-
“Vogel also said at the time that she had “never heard Hayden speak of fentanyl.”” — NBC News
“Klitschko, 50, said that the pawn shop has refused to disclose specific information” — The Independent
Centre2 outlets
- Framing
- Deadline and the BBC report the closure in a measured way, with the cause of death and the open question over the DEA.
- Emphasis
- Investigators' look at a Southern California dealer (Deadline); DEA status unclear (BBC); addiction struggles and career background.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Deadline omits the DEA and the people at the scene; the BBC omits the dealer line.
Right3 outlets
- Framing
- Fox News and IJR run short reports on the police statement; the Daily Mail's long report leads with the 'drug death' and adds tabloid-style detail.
- Emphasis
- Police statement (Fox, IJR); fentanyl potency, TMZ sources on a laced pill and a Los Angeles dealer, and the boyfriend at the scene (Daily Mail).
- Leaves out or plays down
- Fox gives no cause of death or coroner findings; the Daily Mail relays the TMZ claims without police confirmation.
- Charged language
- “drug death”“shock passing”
- For example
-
“The ruling brings the police investigation into her death to a close, the statement said.” — Fox News
“Just a few grains of powerful opioid fentanyl, which is 50 times stronger than heroin, can cause a fatal overdose.” — Daily Mail
What every side reports
- Greenville Police Department announced on 28 October that Panettiere's death was ruled accidental.
- The ruling was based on the Medical Examiner's determination and the investigation's findings.
- Panettiere died on 16 August at age 36 in Greenville, South Carolina.
Where accounts differ
-
How she obtained the drugs
- Left
- The Independent notes only that Hickerson gave investigators a bag of medication; Variety says he spoke to investigators about who may have sold her the drugs.
- Centre
- Deadline says investigators looked into a possible Southern California dealer and counterfeit drugs.
- Right
- The Daily Mail relays TMZ sources, unverified, who said she took a fentanyl-laced oxycodone pill from a long-time Los Angeles dealer; her rep called such reports 'unverified hearsay' earlier.
-
Greenville police ruled Hayden Panettiere's death accidental and concluded their investigation.
Supported- Supports 8
- CBS News, NBC News, The Independent, Variety, BBC News, Deadline, Daily Mail, Fox News
-
The coroner found Panettiere died from the toxic effects of fentanyl, 4-ANPP, alprazolam, methocarbamol and quetiapine.
Reported- Reports 6
- NBC News, The Independent, Variety, BBC News, Deadline, Daily Mail
Left5 articles
-
Hayden Panettiere's death ruled accidental by South Carolina police
Neutral Factual report of the ruling with detailed background on cause of death and circumstances.

-
Hayden Panettiere: Police reveal findings from death investigation
Neutral Reports the closure with police-report details and the Klitschko guardianship and pawn shop filings.

-
Hayden Panettiere’s death is ruled accidental, and police investigation is closed
Sympathetic Reports the closure with her addiction history, her mother's response and her memoir.

-
Hayden Panettiere’s Overdose Death Investigation Closed by Police
Neutral Brief trade report of the closure with the coroner's September findings.

Centre2 articles
-
Hayden Panettiere Death Investigation Closed By Police In South Carolina
Neutral Reports the closure with the coroner's findings, the dealer line of inquiry and a career recap.

-
Death of US actress Hayden Panettiere ruled accidental, ending local police probe
Neutral Reports the closure and stresses that the DEA's role remains unclear.

Right3 articles
-
IJRRC ·
Police Close Panettiere Death Probe After Overdose Ruling
Neutral Short report that police closed the probe in line with the medical examiner's findings, attributing the death to an overdose.
-
Hayden Panettiere’s death ruled accidental, police say
Neutral Brief wire-style report of the police statement, flagged as developing.

-
Mixed Long tabloid-style report leading with the 'drug death', adding unverified TMZ claims alongside official statements.

- 28 Oct 17:53 First IJRRC Police Close Panettiere Death Probe After Overdose Ruling
- 28 Oct 19:43 +1h 50m CBS NewsLC Hayden Panettiere's death ruled accidental by South Carolina police
- 28 Oct 20:06 +2h 13m Fox NewsR Hayden Panettiere’s death ruled accidental, police say
- 28 Oct 20:32 +2h 39m Daily MailR Hayden Panettiere's drug death at 36 ruled accidental as police close investigation into star's overdose
- 28 Oct 21:07 +3h 14m The IndependentLC Hayden Panettiere: Police reveal findings from death investigation
- 28 Oct 21:08 +3h 15m NBC NewsLC Hayden Panettiere’s death is ruled accidental, and police investigation is closed
- 28 Oct 21:10 +3h 17m DeadlineN Hayden Panettiere Death Investigation Closed By Police In South Carolina
- 28 Oct 21:16 +3h 23m BBC NewsN Death of US actress Hayden Panettiere ruled accidental, ending local police probe
- 28 Oct 21:31 +3h 38m VarietyLC Hayden Panettiere’s Overdose Death Investigation Closed by Police
- 28 Oct 21:41 +3h 48m The IndependentLC South Carolina police close investigation into Hayden Panettiere's death after coroner's ruling
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…
