Hershey, Angel Studios' Milton Hershey biopic, gets critical reviews ahead of 25 November release
Two reviews of "Hershey", a biopic of chocolatier Milton S. Hershey directed by Mark Waters, find it bland; IndieWire is far harsher than Screen Rant. It opens in US theaters on 25 November.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2"Hershey", a biopic of chocolatier Milton S. Hershey directed by Mark Waters, opens in US theaters on Wednesday, 25 November, with Angel Studios releasing it. Screen RantN “Hershey releases in theaters nationwide on Wednesday, November 25.” Read at Screen Rant ↗ IndieWireLC “Angel Studios will release “Hershey” in theaters on Wednesday, November 25.” Read at IndieWire ↗ Centre · 1The film follows Hershey from his Pennsylvania Dutch childhood through the growth of his confectionery business, his marriage to Kitty and the founding of the company town of Hershey, Pennsylvania. James Kelly and Finn Wittrock play him as a boy and a young man; Alexandra Daddario plays Kitty, Alan Ruck his father and Richard Kind the confectioner Mr. Royer. Screen RantN “young Milton Hershey (James Kelly)”“a pretty standard biopic of Milton S. Hershey that surveys nearly 50 years of his life, from his humble beginnings in Pennsylvania Dutch country through the establishment and growth of his confectionery empire.” Read at Screen Rant ↗ Left · 1IndieWire notes that Angel Studios did not technically make the film. Dandelion Media produced it in partnership with Hershey Entities as a fully authorized feature. IndieWireLC “Angel Studios didn’t technically make this movie — that distinction belongs to the spiritually aligned production company Dandelion Media, who partnered with Hershey Entities” Read at IndieWire ↗
Centre · 1Screen Rant's Alex Harrison calls the film "inoffensively bland" and "tame". He credits its pleasant tone, period recreation and Daddario's performance, but says the script runs through events as a straight chain with little tension. Screen RantN “Hershey is an all too tame experience, weighed down by its frictionless storytelling.”“The movie benefits from a general pleasantness of tone, which its target audience will surely appreciate, as well as its recreation of the period setting.” Read at Screen Rant ↗ Centre · 1Harrison says The Hershey Company helped shape the film and that it includes "blatant acts of brand maintenance", but he does not see the reluctance to portray its subject critically as the main problem. He puts the runtime at 110 minutes and likens its appeal to Kevin Costner's Horizon films. Screen RantN “It should come as no surprise that The Hershey Company was involved in shaping this movie from the ground up.”“the 110-minute Hershey sticks around long enough to underwhelm.” Read at Screen Rant ↗ Left · 1IndieWire's David Ehrlich calls it an "unbelievably flavorless" film and "unrepentant godslop". He says it reads like an AI-generated adaptation of Hershey's Wikipedia page, and that the script treats each setback as followed at once by divine providence. IndieWireLC “this godforsaken affront to good storytelling”“Every stumbling block is immediately followed by a burst of divine providence” Read at IndieWire ↗
Left · 1Ehrlich also criticises what the film leaves out, namely the Milton Hershey School's history of racial and social discrimination and the labour disputes at the factory in the late 1930s. He singles out a scene in which Milton and Kitty dance for joy after escaping the Titanic as possibly the most deranged of the year. IndieWireLC “expecting this movie to acknowledge the Milton Hershey School’s history of racial and social discrimination would be as delusional”“In what might be the single most deranged movie scene of the year” Read at IndieWire ↗ Left · 1Ehrlich's review spends much of its length on Angel Studios, referring to its origins in a film-filtering service, to "Sound of Freedom" and its ticketing model, and to the political conduct of a co-founder. He says the film is the secular end of Angel's output, with limited overt religion. IndieWireLC ““Hershey” is as secular as Angel Studios’ output gets, its overt religiosity limited to a brief scene” Read at IndieWire ↗ Mixed · 2Both critics describe Angel Studios as a "values-based" outfit. Harrison ties the label to patriotism, Christian faith and the Hays Code. Screen RantN “whose "values-based" output seems to represent the intersection of patriotism, Christian faith, and the Hays Code” Read at Screen Rant ↗ IndieWireLC “Milton S. Hershey gets the Angel Studios treatment in a deranged and decidedly vanilla piece of "values-based entertainment."” Read at IndieWire ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- A scathing, jokey takedown that treats the film as the logical endpoint of Angel Studios' 'values-based' model and as a corporate-authorised commercial.
- Emphasis
- Angel Studios' history and politics, the film's lack of human texture, its omissions on discrimination and labour, and the Titanic scene.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Offers little that is positive about performances or production design beyond passing remarks on Richard Kind.
- Charged language
- “unrepentant godslop”“godforsaken affront to good storytelling”“deranged”“carob powder”
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- A measured, mildly negative review that calls the film pleasant but too conventional and bland.
- Emphasis
- Script structure and storytelling, with some credit for tone, setting and Daddario's performance.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not discuss the history of discrimination at the Hershey School, the labour disputes, or Angel Studios' controversies.
- Charged language
- “inoffensively bland”“kiddie coaster”
- For example
-
“Hershey's problem is that its story is just not very well told.” — Screen Rant
“It takes a potentially inspirational success story and suffocates it with mild storytelling” — Screen Rant
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- The film is a conventional biopic of Milton S. Hershey directed by Mark Waters.
- Angel Studios releases it in US theaters on 25 November.
- Both reviewers find it bland and lacking in tension or friction.
- The Hershey Company was involved in the project.
Where accounts differ
-
How serious a failing the film's flattering, uncritical portrait is
- Left
- IndieWire treats the omission of the school's discrimination history and the labour disputes as a major failing, and calls the film a commercial-like exercise.
- Centre
- Screen Rant says the brand-friendly approach 'isn't really the problem'; the weakness is the flat storytelling.
-
Whether the film has any redeeming qualities
- Left
- IndieWire finds almost nothing to praise.
- Centre
- Screen Rant praises its pleasant tone, period design and Daddario's performance.
Left1 article
-
IndieWireLC · · Opinion
‘Hershey’ Review: An Unbelievably Flavorless Biopic About America’s Most Famous Chocolatier
Critical A furious, humorous pan that treats the film as sanitised faith-based branding and a critique of Angel Studios itself.

Centre1 article
-
Screen RantN · · Opinion
Hershey Review: Chocolatier Biopic Is Inoffensively Bland
Mixed A moderate review that finds the film pleasant and well dressed but dull and overly conventional.

Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 17 Nov 00:00 First Screen RantN Hershey Review: Chocolatier Biopic Is Inoffensively Bland Opinion
- 17 Nov 00:10 +10m IndieWireLC ‘Hershey’ Review: An Unbelievably Flavorless Biopic About America’s Most Famous Chocolatier Opinion
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…