Mahmood says nearly all women reaching northern France for small boats have been raped
In a podcast interview, Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood said nearly all women trying to reach the UK by small boat from northern France have been raped on the journey, arguing criminal gangs should not decide who comes to Britain. She also discussed far-right protesters and the Palestine Action ban.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood said in an interview with The Rest Is Politics podcast that nearly all women who try to reach the UK in small boats from northern France have been raped on their journey. The GuardianLC “Nearly all women who try to reach the UK in small boats from northern France have been raped on their journey, Shabana Mahmood has claimed.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Daily MailR “In an interview with The Rest Is Politics podcast, Shabana Mahmood said sexual abusers would exploit most asylum seekers” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Mixed · 2Speaking to the former Tory minister Rory Stewart and Tony Blair's former adviser Alastair Campbell, she said: "You can almost guarantee that every woman that's in the north of France has probably been raped along the journey." She added that some of the men had also been abused and threatened. The GuardianLC “You can almost guarantee that every woman that’s in the north of France has probably been raped along the journey.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Daily MailR “Some of the men too, they’ve certainly been abused and threatened.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Mixed · 2Her argument was that the UK is "not in control of this border" because criminal gangs who are also people traffickers decide who ends up in northern France and gets on a dinghy, and that this is not the model that should decide who gets to come to the UK. The GuardianLC “We’re not in control of this border. The sifting of the people that end up in the north of France and are about to get on a dinghy is done by criminal gangs” Read at The Guardian ↗ Daily MailR “That is not the model that should decide whether somebody gets to come to the UK” Read at Daily Mail ↗
Mixed · 2In the same interview she said balaclava-wearing protesters who shut down ports and praise her policies should "sod off", calling them "troublemakers" who she said would "kill" her and "kick me out of my own country" because they do not think she is a true Brit and hate that she is a Muslim. The GuardianLC “They’re just troublemakers. You know, they’d kill me in a minute if they could, and they’d definitely kick me out of my own country.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Daily MailR “the balaclava-wearing protesters shutting down ports and praising her policies should 'sod off'.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Mixed · 2Mahmood also said she considers herself part of the pro-Palestinian cause and felt "very uncomfortable" about arrests of activists under section 13 of the Terrorism Act over the Palestine Action ban, but defended enforcing it, saying principles must be applied even when uncomfortable. The GuardianLC “it feels very uncomfortable to see them falling foul of section 13 of the Terrorism Act.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Daily MailR “You’ve got to be able to apply your principles, even when it’s uncomfortable for you” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Mixed · 2Both outlets note that Merseyside police arrested 82 people at the Labour conference in Liverpool on suspicion of wearing or carrying articles supporting a proscribed organisation, at a protest organised by Defend Our Juries. The Daily Mail adds a Merseyside police statement that not everyone present had committed an offence and that the force aims to apply the law consistently, fairly and proportionately. The GuardianLC “Merseyside police arrested 82 people on Monday at the Labour party conference” Read at The Guardian ↗ Daily MailR “The spokesperson said not everyone present at the demonstration had been committing a criminal offence.” Read at Daily Mail ↗
Left · 1The Guardian carries a response from Imran Hussain of the Refugee Council, who welcomed her acknowledgment of widespread sexual violence but questioned why the government closed safe and legal routes, including family reunion last year, and said new safe routes should not be limited to a few hundred people. The GuardianLC “Imran Hussain, a director at the Refugee Council, welcomed the home secretary’s acknowledgment of widespread sexual violence”“Protecting women means more safe routes, not fewer.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Left · 1A government spokesperson said the Border Security Command works around the clock to monitor the Channel and that it is vital to detain, check and process every small boat arrival. The GuardianLC “The Border Security Command works around the clock to monitor the Channel and protect our border.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Mixed · 2The Daily Mail pairs the interview with a report that about 300 anti-migrant protesters clashed with police in Gosport on Sunday night as migrants arrived at Haslar Marina, with the Home Office confirming 149 migrants were picked up in a mid-Channel rescue by the RNLI and a French coastguard vessel and taken by coach to a processing centre in Kent. The Guardian reported that authorities were preparing for a dinghy heading for the south coast, and Conservative MP Caroline Dinenage said police were making preparations. Daily MailR “The Home Office confirmed that 149 migrants were picked up in a mid-Channel rescue operation by the RNLI alongside a French coastguard vessel.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ The GuardianLC “Authorities were preparing on Sunday for the arrival of a migrant dinghy heading for the south coast.” Read at The Guardian ↗
Left · 1Neither article cites data or evidence for the scale of sexual violence beyond Mahmood's own remarks, and the Guardian describes the statement as something she "claimed". The GuardianLC “Shabana Mahmood has claimed.” Read at The Guardian ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Interview story framed around Mahmood's remarks on traffickers and the far right, with a refugee charity challenging government policy on safe routes.
- Emphasis
- Her description of far-right protesters and her Muslim identity, the Palestine Action ban, and the Refugee Council's call for more safe routes.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not report the Gosport protest clash or the 149 migrants rescued.
- Charged language
- “far-right, balaclava-wearing activists”“has claimed”
- For example
-
“Nearly all women who try to reach the UK in small boats from northern France have been raped on their journey, Shabana Mahmood has claimed.” — The Guardian
“Protecting women means more safe routes, not fewer.” — The Guardian
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Interview story combined with a border-security incident: anti-migrant protesters clash with police in Gosport as migrants land by a 'new route'.
- Emphasis
- Scenes at Gosport marina, the numbers rescued, and Mahmood's quotes; includes the Merseyside police statement.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Omits the Refugee Council's criticism of closed safe routes and the government spokesperson's statement; does not describe the protesters in the interview as 'far-right'.
- Charged language
- “new route”“send them back”
- For example
-
“About 300 anti-migrant protesters clashed with police on Sunday after dozens of migrants arrived at a historic naval port via small boat using a 'new route' to evade detection.” — Daily Mail
What every side reports
- Mahmood made the remarks on The Rest Is Politics podcast with Rory Stewart and Alastair Campbell.
- She said she would tell balaclava-wearing protesters to 'sod off'.
- She said she felt very uncomfortable about arrests over the Palestine Action ban but defended enforcing it.
- Merseyside police arrested 82 people at the Labour conference in Liverpool.
Where accounts differ
-
Which part of the interview is the story
- Left
- Leads with the rape claim, followed by Mahmood's attacks on far-right protesters, her Muslim identity and the Palestine Action ban, plus a refugee charity reply on safe routes.
- Right
- Leads with the same claim, then pairs it with a report of anti-migrant protesters clashing with police in Gosport as 149 migrants landed.
-
Whether the claim is attributed or presented as fact
- Left
- Says Mahmood 'has claimed' it.
- Right
- Headline and lede say women 'are raped' 'according to the home secretary'.
Shabana Mahmood person
Says the UK is not in control of its border because criminal gangs choose who reaches northern France, and that women on the route are almost certainly raped; dismisses balaclava-wearing protesters and says she is uncomfortable with Palestine Action arrests but will enforce the ban.
“We’re not in control of this border.” — The Guardian
“You’ve got to be able to apply your principles, even when it’s uncomfortable for you” — Daily Mail
Left1 article
-
Nearly all women arriving on small boats have been raped, says Shabana Mahmood
Neutral Reports the remarks as a claim and adds the Refugee Council's response on safe routes and a government spokesperson's statement.

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right1 article
-
Neutral Reports the remarks as the home secretary's account and links them to the Gosport landing and protest.

- 4 Oct 19:00 First The GuardianLC Nearly all women arriving on small boats have been raped, says Shabana Mahmood
- 5 Oct 09:04 +14h 4m Daily MailR Nearly all women who try to reach UK in small boats are raped during their journey, home secretary says
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.