HRW says eastern Libya authorities executed at least 31 people after military trials
Human Rights Watch says forces under Khalifa Haftar in eastern Libya executed at least 31 people from late August, the first known executions in Libya since 2010. HRW and Amnesty International say trials were unfair and 50 more detainees are at imminent risk.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Human Rights Watch (HRW) said on Wednesday 14 October that military authorities in eastern Libya had executed at least 31 people, the first reported death sentences carried out in the country since 2010. Arab NewsRC “executed at least 31 people earlier this year, the first reported death sentences to be carried out in the country since 2010” Read at Arab News ↗ The IndependentLC “The killings are the first known executions since 2010” Read at The Independent ↗ Right · 1HRW said forces under the control of military leader Khalifa Haftar and his clan carried out the executions between late August and 10 September, following what it called "grossly unfair military trials". Arab NewsRC “executed the people between late August and September 10 “following grossly unfair military trials,” HRW said in a statement” Read at Arab News ↗ Right · 1HRW said another 50 people held in detention were at imminent risk of execution, in a prison about 100 kilometres east of Benghazi that is largely under military control and outside the jurisdiction of the judicial authorities. Arab NewsRC “HRW said the detainees were being held in a prison about 100 kilometers east of Benghazi.”“another 50 people in detention were “at imminent risk of execution.”” Read at Arab News ↗
Mixed · 2Bassam Khawaja, HRW's deputy Middle East and North Africa director, said the east had gone more than 15 years without an execution and had "shattered that moratorium in a matter of weeks", and he called on the international community and governments backing Haftar's forces to press for a halt. Arab NewsRC “the eastern authorities “shattered that moratorium in a matter of weeks.”” Read at Arab News ↗ The IndependentLC “called on all governments with links to the LAAF to be “pressing hard to stop the next one”” Read at The Independent ↗ Right · 1He also said the trials were secret, built on confessions allegedly extracted through torture, and held in courts that Libya's own Supreme Court has said should not try civilians. Arab NewsRC “after secret trials built on confessions allegedly extracted through torture, in courts that Libya’s own Supreme Court has said should not be trying civilians” Read at Arab News ↗ Left · 1The Independent, citing Amnesty International researcher Mahmoud Shalaby, reported that the Libyan Arab Armed Forces (LAAF) put people to death by firing squad after secret military trials, and that in at least two cases those executed had had their death sentences reduced to life imprisonment on appeal. The IndependentLC “the LAAF has started putting people to death by firing squad after secret military trials”“the people executed had had their death sentence reduced to live imprisonment on appeal” Read at The Independent ↗
Left · 1According to the Independent, the executions began about two weeks after Major-General Fawzi al-Mansouri, a LAAF military intelligence chief, was killed in a car bombing in Benghazi, and on 23 August the military prosecutor's office announced the executions of 10 people convicted of terrorism-related offences. The IndependentLC “The killings began in August, when Major-General Fawzi al-Mansouri, one of the LAAF’s military intelligence chiefs, was killed in a car bombing on Benghazi.”“On 23 August, the military prosecutor's office announced the executions of 10 people convicted of terrorism-related offences” Read at The Independent ↗ Left · 1Amnesty said military courts in eastern Libya have convicted hundreds of civilians, that confessions were extracted under torture by the LAAF-affiliated Internal Security agency, and that detainees were forcibly disappeared for up to two years; HRW said families, journalists and lawyers of choice were barred from the trials and no written judgments were given. The IndependentLC “Amnesty says military courts have convicted hundreds of civilians in eastern Libya in the “grossly unfair” trials”“Lawyers of choice were refused” Read at The Independent ↗ Left · 1HRW said many of the 31 were arrested in Derna and Benghazi during the 2014–2018 conflict between the LAAF and its opponents and were convicted by 2021. The IndependentLC “were arrested in the eastern cities of Derna and Benghazi during a conflict between the LAAF and its opponents between 2014 and 2018” Read at The Independent ↗
Mixed · 2Libya remains divided between a UN-recognised government in the west and the Haftar-aligned east, which the Independent says has Russian, Egyptian and Emirati backing; the death penalty remains in law for murder, terrorism and offences against state security, though sentences had not recently been carried out. Arab NewsRC “The death penalty is still in force in Libya for the crimes of murder, terrorism and offenses against state security” Read at Arab News ↗ The IndependentLC “has received backing from Russia, Egypt and the UAE” Read at The Independent ↗ Left · 1The coverage does not include a response from the eastern authorities to the allegations beyond the military prosecutor's August announcement of executions. The IndependentLC “the military prosecutor's office announced the executions of 10 people” Read at The Independent ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- The Independent presents the executions as a human rights outcry, adding Amnesty International's findings on torture, forced disappearance and the killing of people whose sentences were reduced on appeal.
- Emphasis
- Amnesty's investigation, the trigger of the car bombing of a LAAF intelligence chief, trial conditions and foreign backers of the east.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not give HRW's 10 September end date or the prison location; includes no response from eastern authorities.
- Charged language
- “Outcry”“public executions”“shattered that moratorium”
- For example
-
“Outcry as Libya carries out public executions for first time since fall of Gaddafi” — The Independent
“Amnesty’s investigation found that confessions had been extracted under torture” — The Independent
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Arab News gives a short report of the HRW statement, built around Khawaja's quotes.
- Emphasis
- HRW's figures, the 10 September date, the 50 at risk and the prison east of Benghazi, plus Libya's division and the death penalty in law.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention Amnesty's findings, the August bombing, the prosecutor's announcement or foreign backers of the east; includes no response from Haftar's forces.
- Charged language
- “grossly unfair military trials”“shattered that moratorium”
- For example
-
“Haftar’s forces “are putting people to death after secret trials built on confessions allegedly extracted through torture” — Arab News
What every side reports
- At least 31 people have been executed by eastern Libyan authorities since late August.
- These are the first known executions in Libya since 2010.
- About 50 more detainees are said to be at imminent risk of execution.
- Rights groups say the military trials were unfair and relied on confessions allegedly extracted under torture.
- Bassam Khawaja of HRW said Libya had gone more than 15 years without an execution.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether the executions were public
- Left
- The Independent's headline says Libya carried out "public executions", though its body text describes firing-squad executions after secret trials.
- Right
- Arab News does not describe the executions as public; it stresses secret trials.
Human Rights Watch organisation
HRW says at least 31 people were executed after grossly unfair military trials and urges the international community and Haftar's backers to stop further executions.
““The lives of at least 50 more people now depend on whether Haftar’s forces, and the governments that back them, choose to stop this,”” — Arab News
Libyan National Army organisation
The military prosecutor's office announced the executions of 10 people convicted of terrorism-related offences; the coverage records no other response.
“On 23 August, the military prosecutor's office announced the executions of 10 people convicted of terrorism-related offences” — The Independent
Middle East1 outlet
Arab News reports the HRW statement briefly and straightforwardly.
“HRW said in a statement, adding another 50 people in detention were “at imminent risk of execution.”” — Arab News
Arab News
UK and Ireland1 outlet
The Independent frames it as an international outcry with detail from Amnesty and HRW.
“Rights groups tell Alex Croft the legal pro” — The Independent
The Independent
Left1 article
-
Outcry as Libya carries out public executions for first time since fall of Gaddafi
Critical Rights-focused feature adding Amnesty's evidence of torture and unlawful executions, under a headline stressing outcry and public executions.

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right1 article
-
HRW says 31 executed by eastern Libya authorities
Neutral Concise report relaying HRW's statement and Khawaja's quotes with brief background.

- 14 Oct 16:57 First Arab NewsRC HRW says 31 executed by eastern Libya authorities
- 17 Oct 14:19 +69h 22m The IndependentLC Outcry as Libya carries out public executions for first time since fall of Gaddafi
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…