Skip to content
Bramble

US

Incoming House Democrats split over whether to pursue a third Trump impeachment

Democrats who won the House in the November midterms have no agreed position on impeaching President Trump a third time, according to a Politico survey relayed by The Independent. A Washington Examiner opinion column argues the party is driven by revenge rather than the affordability agenda it campaigned on.

2 outlets · 1L · 0C · 1R First reported Account updated
Image: The Independent
Image: Washington Examiner

1 / 2

The story, neutrally told

Left · 1House Democrats will take the majority in January and will have the power to impeach President Donald Trump a third time, but they have no agreement on whether to try. Left · 1Politico interviewed 14 House Democrats across the party's ideological range. It found a growing number open to moving against Trump, and many warning that a rushed effort would backfire. Left · 1Democrats accuse Trump of misconduct in his second term, including self-enrichment, accepting foreign gifts, pay-for-play pardons, abuse of power against enemies and what they call an illegal war in Iran. There is no consensus on which issue would become articles of impeachment, or which investigation would come first.

Left · 1Jamie Raskin, who is poised to chair the Judiciary Committee and managed the 2021 trial, said Trump would welcome an impeachment campaign because he sees it as a last hope of rallying his base. Trump told reporters a day after the midterms that he would welcome a third impeachment, saying it would be "impeachment for no reason". Left · 1Other senior Democrats urge caution. Bennie Thompson said impeachment "is not a priority for me" but that he would vote for a resolution if one reached the floor. Zoe Lofgren said the Senate's chance of convicting must be weighed, and Gregory Meeks answered "No" when asked whether the House should impeach. Left · 1Conviction requires 67 senators. The Independent says the 56 Democratic senators would need at least 11 Republicans, a bar they failed to clear even after the Capitol riot.

Left · 1Incoming Speaker Hakeem Jeffries has kept his distance. He said no caucus member had talked to him about impeachment, that the caucus was focused on "affordability and on accountability", and, asked whether Trump had committed impeachable offences, "We haven't ruled anything in. We haven't ruled anything out." Left · 1Some members want to move sooner. Rashida Tlaib said treating the matter as a distraction "is setting a dangerous precedent". Suhas Subramanyam said Democrats should act "even if it's bad politics", and Becca Balint said she would vote for a resolution. Jason Crow, a manager in Trump's first trial, called impeachment "a tool" and said he would do it again if appropriate but that the party must first see what coalition it can build. Mixed · 2Both articles refer to a failed effort to impeach Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, which collapsed when 11 Democrats missed the vote. The Independent describes it as a measure that would have subjected him to a Senate trial. The Washington Examiner, which calls him "Secretary of War", attributes the absences to traffic issues and says it is unclear why he was being impeached beyond disagreement over the Iran war and strikes on alleged drug boats.

Right · 1In the Washington Examiner opinion column, Joe Concha argues that impeachment has been watered down since Clinton and that Trump's first two impeachments were unwarranted. He says the midterms turned on affordability, and that Democrats are pursuing "lawfare" and retribution instead. He cites Robert Garcia's "lawyer up" warning to Trump officials and Elizabeth Warren's promise of investigations. He also cites Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez keeping options open on the Supreme Court and James Carville saying the base wants to humiliate Trump. Right · 1The column also says calling Trump a twice-impeached president had no effect on the 2024 campaign, and that Congress's Gallup approval is 14%.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left1 outlet

Framing
News report on a Democratic caucus divided and cautious about a third impeachment, built on a Politico survey of 14 members. It leads with fears that a rush job would backfire and strengthen Trump's base.
Emphasis
Senate conviction arithmetic (67 votes), restraint from Raskin, Thompson, Lofgren and Meeks, Jeffries' noncommittal line, and Trump saying he would welcome a fight.
Leaves out or plays down
Gives little space to Republican arguments that impeachment is unjustified, and does not explain why 11 Democrats missed the Hegseth vote.
Charged language
“rush job”“MAGA base”
For example
“Members who won back the chamber are split over a third impeachment, wary of a Senate math problem and a president who says he would welcome the fight” — The Independent
“a president badly weakened by this month's midterm rout” — The Independent

Centre0 outlets

No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Right1 outlet

Framing
Opinion column arguing that impeachment has lost meaning and that incoming Democrats are set on revenge and "lawfare" instead of affordability.
Emphasis
Statements by Garcia, Galloway, Ocasio-Cortez, Warren and Carville, the failed Hegseth vote, low congressional approval, and the claim that earlier Trump impeachments helped him.
Leaves out or plays down
Does not report the cautious views of Raskin, Jeffries, Thompson, Lofgren or Meeks. It gives Trump's own claim that Democrats would be punished little weight beyond its own argument, and does not mention the Senate conviction threshold.
Charged language
“lawfare”“Revenge. Retribution. Flashy show trials”“sophomoric”“What a joke”
For example
“Revenge. Retribution. Flashy show trials, low on substance and high on cheesy performance.” — Washington Examiner
“the taunting over a return to lawfare began in earnest” — Washington Examiner

Ask about this story

Loading…