India calls Vance's 'indentured servants' remark deeply offensive after PERM suspensions
India's External Affairs Ministry criticised US Vice President JD Vance for calling foreign workers "indentured servants" as the US suspended several firms from the PERM green card process.
1 / 3
The story, neutrally told
Centre · 2India's External Affairs Ministry on Friday 9 October criticised US Vice President JD Vance for describing foreign workers as "foreign indentured servants", calling the terminology "deeply offensive". Anadolu AgencyN “calling the terminology "deeply offensive" and defending the contributions of Indian professionals to the US economy.” Read at Anadolu Agency ↗ Gulf NewsN “calling the remark deeply offensive and insensitive to the historical and colonial associations of the term” Read at Gulf News ↗ Centre · 1Vance used the phrase on Thursday while announcing the suspension of Microsoft's participation in the US Permanent Labor Certification (PERM) program. Anadolu AgencyN “Vance used the phrase Thursday while announcing the suspension of Microsoft's participation in the US Permanent Labor Certification (PERM) program.” Read at Anadolu Agency ↗ Centre · 1Vance said Microsoft laid off 6,000 American workers while benefiting from 6,300 H-1B visas and almost 3,000 green cards, replacing each laid-off worker with "one and a half foreign indentured servants". Anadolu AgencyN “Microsoft laid off 6,000 American workers. At the same time, the company benefited from 6,300 H-1B visas and almost 3,000 green cards.” Read at Anadolu Agency ↗
Centre · 1According to Gulf News, he also claimed H-1B holders earned $20,000 less than Americans in similar roles, and that workers brought in by foreign outsourcing firms earned $48,000 less. Gulf NewsN “Vance claimed that H-1B visa holders earned $20,000 less than American citizens hired for similar positions.” Read at Gulf News ↗ Centre · 1US Labor Secretary Keith Sonderling said Cognizant, Infosys, Tata, Wipro, HCL, Capgemini and Adobe had also been suspended from the program, which is generally the first step for employers sponsoring foreign workers for permanent residency. Anadolu AgencyN “US Labor Secretary Keith Sonderling also announced Thursday that Cognizant, Infosys, Tata, Wipro, HCL, Capgemini and Adobe had been suspended from the program.” Read at Anadolu Agency ↗ Centre · 1The ministry said such descriptions were "unwarranted" and ignored that Indian professionals in the US are highly educated, skilled contributors to its economy and innovation, and that US history was shaped by immigrants' labour and enterprise. Anadolu AgencyN “such descriptions are unwarranted and ignore the fact that Indian professionals in the United States are highly educated and skilled contributors” Read at Anadolu Agency ↗
Centre · 2It said language carrying painful historical and colonial connotations was offensive, and that talent mobility benefits both countries. Anadolu AgencyN “resorting to terminology that carries painful historical and colonial legacy connotations is deeply offensive.” Read at Anadolu Agency ↗ Gulf NewsN “talent mobility was an area of mutual benefit for India and the US” Read at Gulf News ↗ Centre · 2The ministry stressed PERM is distinct from the H-1B programme; according to Gulf News it said the suspension would not automatically affect existing H-1B visas or visa holders' legal status, but could affect green card processes for eligible employees of the companies. Anadolu AgencyN “PERM is "distinct from the H-1B visa programme."” Read at Anadolu Agency ↗ Gulf NewsN “the suspension of PERM applications would not automatically affect existing H-1B visas or the legal status of visa holders and their dependants.” Read at Gulf News ↗ Centre · 1Nasscom, India's IT industry association, said few employees move from H-1B to permanent residency through PERM and that Indian tech firms have reduced their reliance on H-1B visas while expanding local hiring in the US. Anadolu AgencyN “Indian technology companies have significantly reduced their dependence on H-1B visas” Read at Anadolu Agency ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre3 outlets
- Framing
- Both outlets lead with India's rebuke of Vance and relay the ministry's statement closely, alongside the PERM suspensions that prompted it.
- Emphasis
- Anadolu adds Nasscom's reaction; Gulf News adds Vance's wage-gap claims and the practical effect on green cards.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Neither carries a US response to India's criticism or independent checks of Vance's figures.
- Charged language
- “deeply offensive”“foreign indentured servants”
- For example
-
“New Delhi calls JD Vance's description 'deeply offensive,' defends contributions of Indian professionals to US economy” — Anadolu Agency
“India on Friday strongly criticised US Vice President JD Vance” — Gulf News
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- India's External Affairs Ministry called Vance's terminology deeply offensive.
- Vance's remarks came Thursday amid the suspension of firms from the PERM program.
- The ministry said PERM is separate from the H-1B visa programme.
India place
The Indian government says the description is unwarranted and offensive, defends Indian professionals' contributions and says skilled mobility benefits both countries.
“such descriptions are unwarranted and ignore the fact that Indian professionals in the United States are highly educated” — Anadolu Agency
JD Vance person
Vance says companies cannot lay off American workers and replace them with foreign workers, accusing firms of undercutting American wages.
“You cannot lay off American workers and then replace them with foreign indentured servants,” — Anadolu Agency
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre3 articles
-
India slams US vice president's 'foreign indentured servants' remarks
Neutral Reports India's rebuke and the PERM suspensions, adding Nasscom's reaction.
-
India calls JD Vance’s ‘indentured servants’ remark on H-1B workers deeply offensive
Neutral Reports the MEA statement with Vance's wage claims and practical effects of the PERM suspension.
-
Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 9 Oct 10:58 First Anadolu AgencyN India slams US vice president's 'foreign indentured servants' remarks
- 9 Oct 12:19 +1h 21m Gulf NewsN India calls JD Vance’s ‘indentured servants’ remark on H-1B workers deeply offensive
- 9 Oct 13:18 +2h 20m The Times of IndiaN 'When Amazon hired me on H-1B...': Indian university co-founder wishes good luck to US without 'indentured servants'
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.