Indonesia suspends five officials over luxury inmate compound at Cibinong prison
Five officials, including the prison chief, were suspended after the Ombudsman found apartment-style units allegedly used by inmates at Cibinong prison near Jakarta. BBC News reports the compound has been demolished or ordered demolished after public outcry.
Updated (version 2). New coverage since the last version from Anadolu Agency, BBC News. Previously: “Indonesia suspends five officials after luxury units found for inmates at Cibinong prison”.
1 / 4
The story, neutrally told
Five officials, including the chief of Cibinong prison near Jakarta, have been suspended after investigators found an apartment-style compound allegedly used by inmates. Al JazeeraLC “We have suspended five structural officials, including the Cibinong prison chief, who are suspected of being responsible for the incident uncovered by the Ombudsman,” Read at Al Jazeera ↗ The GuardianLC “Five Indonesian prison officials have been suspended after investigators found an apartment-style compound” Read at The Guardian ↗ Rudi Setiawan, inspector general of the Ministry of Immigration and Corrections, announced the suspensions and said dozens of inmates and staff had been questioned. Al JazeeraLC “Dozens of inmates and prison employees have been questioned, he said.” Read at Al Jazeera ↗ The GuardianLC “said dozens of prisoners and prison employees had been questioned as part of the inquiry” Read at The Guardian ↗ The Ombudsman found more than 10 residential units separate from regular cells during a surprise inspection on 23 September. The GuardianLC “found more than 10 residential units separate from regular prison cells during a surprise inspection on 23 September” Read at The Guardian ↗ BBC NewsN “during a surprise inspection on 23 September” Read at BBC News ↗
Investigators reported air-conditioners, big-screen televisions, sofas, dining areas, a gym and a golf simulator under construction; Al Jazeera and BBC News also mention refrigerators and luxury vehicles. Al JazeeraLC “They also reported finding a gym, a golf simulator under construction, and luxury vehicles on the grounds.” Read at Al Jazeera ↗ BBC NewsN “air conditioners, big-screen televisions, refrigerators, sofas and dining areas” Read at BBC News ↗ Ombudsman member Syafrida Rachmawati Rasahan said inmates were found inside the compound, in facilities resembling homestays, apartments and villas. Al JazeeraLC “We encountered inmates inside the residential compound and discovered facilities resembling homestays, apartments and villas rather than prison housing,” Read at Al Jazeera ↗ The GuardianLC “We encountered prisoners inside the residential compound” Read at The Guardian ↗ The buildings were meant as staff housing, and investigators are examining whether they were converted for inmates; BBC News says prison officials claim the units were for staff. The GuardianLC “The buildings were originally intended as official housing for prison personnel” Read at The Guardian ↗ BBC NewsN “although prison officials claim they were for staff.” Read at BBC News ↗
The identities of the inmates have not been officially disclosed, and lawmakers, activists and watchdogs want to know who they were and whether officials took payments. The GuardianLC “The identities of prisoners allegedly living in the compound have not been officially disclosed.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Al JazeeraLC “whether prison officials accepted payments in exchange for the privileges” Read at Al Jazeera ↗ BBC News reports the compound was demolished after public outcry, though its lede says lawmakers on Wednesday ordered the demolition; the other outlets do not mention this. BBC NewsN “A prison compound in Indonesia has been demolished after public outcry” Read at BBC News ↗ The case adds to long-standing allegations that wealthy inmates can buy privileges; Al Jazeera notes a 2010 investigation found similar luxury. Al JazeeraLC “An investigation into Indonesia’s prisons in 2010 already found that some inmates live a life of luxury behind bars.” Read at Al Jazeera ↗ BBC NewsN “long faced allegations that wealthy or well-connected inmates can obtain preferential treatment through bribery” Read at BBC News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on.
Left2 outlets
- Framing
- Wire-style reports leading on the suspensions, with quotes from the inspector general and Ombudsman and context on corrupt prison privilege.
- Emphasis
- Official statements, questioning of inmates and staff, calls to identify the occupants and check for payments, and the system's history of corruption.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Do not mention demolition or the prison officials' claim that the units were for staff.
- Charged language
- “luxury prison cells”“latest embarrassment”
- For example
-
“The case is the latest embarrassment for the corrections system in Indonesia” — The Guardian
“The incident has drawn widespread public attention and renewed scrutiny of Indonesia’s prisons” — Al Jazeera
Centre2 outlets
- Framing
- Short piece leading on the aftermath: demolition after public outcry.
- Emphasis
- Public outcry, demolition, and the officials' staff-housing claim.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the suspensions, the officials' names or the Ombudsman quotes.
- Charged language
- “Luxury prison”“favoured inmates”
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Five officials including the Cibinong prison chief were suspended.
- The Ombudsman's surprise inspection on 23 September found the units near Jakarta.
- Investigators reported air-conditioners, big-screen TVs, sofas, dining areas, a gym and a golf simulator under construction.
- The buildings were meant as staff housing.
- The inmates' identities have not been officially disclosed.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether the compound was housing inmates or staff
- Left
- Ombudsman said inmates were found inside; investigators are examining whether staff housing was converted.
- Centre
- Officials said the residences appeared to house inmates, although prison officials claim they were for staff.
-
Status of the compound
- Left
- Not reported; coverage focuses on suspensions and the inquiry.
- Centre
- Headline says it was demolished; the lede says lawmakers ordered demolition.
-
The buildings were meant as staff housing and investigators are examining whether they were converted for inmates.
Reported- Reports 3
- Al Jazeera, The Guardian, BBC News
Cibinong Prison place
Investigators say inmates had special facilities; prison officials, per BBC News, claim the units were for staff.
“although prison officials claim they were for staff.” — BBC News
“We found strong indications that certain inmates had access to special facilities unavailable to ordinary prisoners,” — Al Jazeera
Left2 articles
-
Indonesia suspends five officials over luxury apartments for inmates
Neutral Straight account of the suspensions and inspection, with historical context on prison corruption.
-
The GuardianLC · · via AP
Double beds, aircon and big-screen TVs: Indonesia suspends officials over luxury prison cells
Mixed AP-sourced account with a vivid headline on cells' comforts, otherwise a factual report on suspensions.
Centre2 articles
-
Luxury prison in Indonesia demolished after public outcry
Neutral Brief report stressing demolition after public outcry and the staff-housing counterclaim.
-
Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 30 Sep 01:58 First Al JazeeraLC Indonesia suspends five officials over luxury apartments for inmates
- 30 Sep 06:27 +4h 29m The GuardianLC Double beds, aircon and big-screen TVs: Indonesia suspends officials over luxury prison cells via AP
- 30 Sep 11:41 +9h 42m BBC NewsN Luxury prison in Indonesia demolished after public outcry
- 30 Sep 18:48 +16h 50m Anadolu AgencyN Indonesia demolishes 10 'apartment' units inside prison
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.