Skip to content
Bramble

UK

Inquest hears Army officer Max George was killed by reversing Warrior in 2022

An inquest heard Second Lt Max George, 26, died on Salisbury Plain in June 2022 when a Warrior with a broken rear-door alarm reversed over him. The three-day inquest continues.

2 outlets · 0L · 1C · 1R First reported Account updated
Image: Daily Mail
Image: BBC News

1 / 2

The story, neutrally told

Mixed · 2An inquest has heard that Second Lieutenant Max George, 26, of Durham, died on 21 June 2022 during a training exercise on Salisbury Plain, Wiltshire, when a Warrior armoured vehicle reversed over him. Mixed · 2Lt Col Graham Watson, who led the service inquiry, told the court George had left the vehicle by a rear door to coordinate two sections on the ground, was seen briefly struggling with a day sack or a radio antenna, then went back for his weapon inside the vehicle as it reversed. Mixed · 2The inquest heard an alarm designed to warn the driver when the rear doors were open while the vehicle was in gear had been faulty since 2018 because of a broken wire or snapped cable, and that a door-open light on the driver's panel also did not work.

Mixed · 2Col Watson said the driver "would have almost certainly stopped" had the alarm sounded, and that anyone up to 4.8 metres from the vehicle would be in its blind spot. Mixed · 2The Daily Mail reported that the vehicle had nine known faults: six were "limited role" faults that barred live firing, and three, all concerning the rear doors, were "fully fit" faults that did not affect use, including a rear door locking plunger that was stuck. Col Watson said there was no requirement to take the vehicle out of service over the alarm fault, and the BBC reported he said the known faults did not mean it should have been withdrawn. Mixed · 2The court heard the vehicle was an FV511, which differs from the more common FV510 platoon variant, is harder to exit and is not ordinarily used for disembarking troops; the student commander had trained mainly on the FV510 and 5 Rifles crews were not very familiar with the FV511.

Mixed · 2According to the BBC, George's exit made a "clunking noise" that may have led the commander to assume he was clear and the doors shut; the vehicle then stayed stationary for 38 to 43 seconds as soldiers shouted "wait" and horns sounded, and a stop call was sent at 10:25. The Mail said safety supervisors arrived within seconds and judged resuscitation impossible. Mixed · 2George's mother, Vivienne George, read a pen portrait describing him as having "effortless leadership qualities" and "enormous" potential. He had won the Queen's Medal for best cadet on passing out from Sandhurst in December 2021 and had attended Durham School. Mixed · 2The inquest is expected to last three days and continues.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left0 outlets

No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Centre1 outlet

Framing
Sober court report led by the faulty alarm and Col Watson's evidence on the exercise, the FV511/FV510 difference and the sequence of events.
Emphasis
Technical evidence: alarm broken since 2018, 'Combat Spirit' exercise, timings of the stop call, crew unfamiliarity with the FV511.
Leaves out or plays down
Does not give a count of nine faults or the blind-spot distance.
For example
“Army officer killed by reversing Warrior with faulty alarm - inquest” — BBC News
“"In general, the crew and service personnel within 5 Rifles were not that familiar with the FV-511 and its differences with the FV-510."” — BBC News

Right1 outlet

Framing
Emotive account centred on the tragedy of a 'star' officer and the tank's nine known faults left unfixed.
Emphasis
Number of faults, their classification as not top priority, the blind spot, and tributes to George's character and career.
Leaves out or plays down
Does not mention the 38-43 second pause, the stop call time, or the 'Combat Spirit' course.
Charged language
“'Star'”“tragically struck down and crushed”“'Utterly exceptional'”
For example
“'Star' Army officer was killed when a tank with nine faults reversed over him in army training exercise, inquest hears” — Daily Mail
“'Utterly exceptional' Second Lieutenant Max George was tragically struck down and crushed by a reversing Warrior FV511” — Daily Mail

Ask about this story

Loading…