Iraqi anti-corruption court jails MPs Muthana Al Samarrai and Ziad Al Janabi
Iraq's Central Anti-Corruption Criminal Court sentenced Azm Alliance head Muthana Al Samarrai to six years and MP Ziad Al Janabi to five, with large fines or repayments. Both were arrested in June in a government anti-corruption sweep.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Iraq's Central Anti-Corruption Criminal Court on Thursday 29 October sentenced two prominent Sunni politicians to prison, a court official told The National. The NationalN “Iraq's Central Anti-Corruption Criminal Court on Thursday sentenced two prominent politicians to prison” Read at The National ↗ Arab NewsRC “An Iraqi court sentenced two prominent politicians and the head of a state-run enterprise” Read at Arab News ↗ Mixed · 2Muthana Al Samarrai, head of the Azm Alliance, received six years and was ordered to pay 30 billion Iraqi dinars; lawmaker Ziad Al Janabi received five years and was ordered to pay 4 billion dinars. The NationalN “to six years in prison and ordered him to pay 30 billion Iraqi dinars” Read at The National ↗ Arab NewsRC “Al-Janabi to repay 4 billion Iraqi dinars” Read at Arab News ↗ Mixed · 2The National gives the dollar equivalents as about $22 million and $3 million, while AP, carried by Arab News, gives $19.8 million and $2.6 million; The National calls the payments fines and AP describes them as sums to be repaid. The NationalN “about $22 million” Read at The National ↗ Arab NewsRC “($19.8 million)” Read at Arab News ↗
Right · 1According to the state-run Iraqi News Agency, as relayed by AP, the sentences were based on the politicians benefiting from contracts with the North Refineries Company and South Refineries Company, and they allegedly received commissions for facilitating contracts to companies linked to them. Arab NewsRC “The lawmakers allegedly received commissions in exchange for facilitating the awarding of contracts to companies linked to them.” Read at Arab News ↗ Right · 1Al Samarrai's Azm Alliance holds 15 of parliament's 329 seats; Al Janabi is from the smaller Sunni party Tashree. Their parties did not immediately comment. Arab NewsRC “an influential Sunni party that holds 15 seats in Iraq’s 329-seat parliament”“Their respective political parties did not immediately comment on the sentences.” Read at Arab News ↗ Mixed · 2Hussein Talib, former director-general of the Oil Products Distribution Company, was sentenced to eight years and ordered to pay 55 billion dinars in a related case; The National says this was on Tuesday, while AP says Wednesday, with the sentence announced Thursday. The NationalN “was sentenced to eight years and a fine of 55 billion Iraqi dinars on Tuesday” Read at The National ↗ Arab NewsRC “was sentenced Wednesday to eight years in prison in a related case” Read at Arab News ↗
Centre · 1The National says both politicians were arrested in June in Operation Dawn Crackdown, launched by Prime Minister Ali Al Zaidi's government, which says it targeted current and former lawmakers and senior officials and seized billions of dinars, US dollars and gold. The NationalN “arrested in June as part of Operation Dawn Crackdown”“security forces seized billions of dinars, millions of US dollars, and gold jewellery and bars” Read at The National ↗ Right · 1AP says dozens of political officials were arrested in June, including members of former Prime Minister Mohammed Shia Al-Sudani's Shiite bloc and others from the Azm Alliance. Arab NewsRC “dozens of political officials were arrested on corruption charges, including members of former Prime Minister Mohammed Shia Al-Sudani’s Shiite political bloc” Read at Arab News ↗ Centre · 1Under Iraqi law the verdicts can be appealed within 30 days before the Court of Cassation. The National reports critics say the campaign disproportionately targeted Sunni politicians and rival Shiite ones, which the government denies. The NationalN “the verdicts can be appealed within 30 days before the Court of Cassation”“an accusation the government denies” Read at The National ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- Presents the verdicts as products of the government's sweeping anti-corruption campaign, with context on Operation Dawn Crackdown and sectarian-targeting criticism.
- Emphasis
- The campaign, seizures, the appeal route and critics' claim of targeting.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not give the refinery-contract allegations or the parties' lack of comment.
- Charged language
- “sweeping anti-corruption campaign”“Dawn Crackdown”
- For example
-
“verdicts stemming from the government's sweeping” — The National
“Critics, however, say the campaign has disproportionately targeted Sunni politicians” — The National
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- AP copy carried by Arab News: a straight court report on the corruption case, including the alleged commissions on refinery contracts and an unrelated Daesh sentencing.
- Emphasis
- The refinery contract allegations, Iraqi News Agency sourcing, and the prime minister's pledge to combat corruption.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Omits the appeal route, seizures, and the criticism that the campaign targets Sunni politicians.
- Charged language
- “graft”
What every side reports
- Al Samarrai was sentenced to six years and Al Janabi to five.
- Al Samarrai was ordered to pay 30 billion dinars and Al Janabi 4 billion.
- Hussein Talib received eight years and 55 billion dinars in a related case.
- The cases follow June arrests under Prime Minister Ali Al Zaidi's anti-corruption drive.
Where accounts differ
-
When Hussein Talib was sentenced
- Centre
- The National: Tuesday.
- Right
- Arab News (AP): Wednesday, announced Thursday.
-
Nature and dollar value of the payments
- Centre
- The National: fines; about $22m and $3m.
- Right
- Arab News (AP): repayments; $19.8m and $2.6m.
Ali Al Zaidi person
Prime Minister Ali Al Zaidi has promised to fight corruption; his government frames the Dawn Crackdown as proof of that commitment and denies targeting Sunni or Shiite rivals.
“The government has framed the Dawn Crackdown as evidence of its commitment to fighting entrenched corruption” — The National
“Prime Minister Ali Al-Zaidi has promised to combat corruption since taking office earlier this year.” — Arab News
Muthana Al Samarrai person
Al Samarrai, head of the Azm Alliance, was convicted and sentenced; his party had not commented at the time of AP's report.
“Their respective political parties did not immediately comment on the sentences.” — Arab News
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre1 article
-
Iraqi court sentences two prominent politicians to prison in corruption case
Neutral Reports verdicts within the wider government campaign, noting critics' sectarian-targeting charge and the government's denial.
Right1 article
-
Arab NewsRC · · via AP
Iraqi court hands down prison terms to 2 politicians and an oil official in graft case
Neutral AP wire report focused on the contract-commission allegations and related sentences.
- 29 Oct 09:21 First The NationalN Iraqi court sentences two prominent politicians to prison in corruption case
- 29 Oct 14:19 +4h 58m Arab NewsRC Iraqi court hands down prison terms to 2 politicians and an oil official in graft case via AP
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…