Israeli surgeons perform first robot-assisted lung transplant at Beilinson Hospital
Surgeons at Beilinson Hospital (Rabin Medical Center) in Petah Tikva completed Israel's first robot-assisted lung transplant using the da Vinci system through small incisions, without opening the chest. The team aims to make the technique standard within five years.
1 / 3
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Surgeons at Beilinson Hospital (Rabin Medical Center) in Petah Tikva completed Israel's first robot-assisted lung transplant, without opening the patient's chest or spreading the ribs. The Media LineN “Israel’s first robot-assisted lung transplant was completed at Beilinson Hospital (Rabin Medical Center) in Petah Tikva, where doctors avoided opening the patient’s chest and spreading the ribs” Read at The Media Line ↗ JNSR “surgeons at Beilinson Hospital in Petach Tikvah have performed a lung transplant using a surgical robot, without cutting through the breastbone or spreading the ribs” Read at JNS ↗ Mixed · 2The team used the da Vinci surgical system and a few small chest incisions to connect the donated lung to the recipient's airways and blood vessels. The Media LineN “Doctors were able to attach the donated lung to the recipient’s airways and blood vessels through the keyhole openings.” Read at The Media Line ↗ JNSR “Using the da Vinci robotic system and a few small chest incisions, the surgical team connected the new lung to the recipient’s blood vessels and airways.” Read at JNS ↗ Mixed · 2The operation was led by Dr. Yuri Peischowicz (spelled Peysakhovich by JNS), head of the hospital's thoracic surgery department; JNS reports it took place last month. The Media LineN “The operation was led by Dr. Yuri Peischowicz, head of Beilinson’s Department of Thoracic Surgery.” Read at The Media Line ↗ JNSR “The operation took place last month.” Read at JNS ↗
Mixed · 2Both outlets say about 20 robotic lung transplants have been carried out worldwide; JNS adds that the first was three years ago in Spain. The Media LineN “Approximately 20 robotic lung transplants have been carried out worldwide” Read at The Media Line ↗ JNSR “Only about 20 robotic lung transplants have been performed worldwide, with the first just three years ago in Spain.” Read at JNS ↗ Mixed · 2A conventional lung transplant generally takes eight to 10 hours and can cause severe pain because the chest is opened and the ribs spread, which can make deep breathing and coughing harder and raise the risk of infection and a longer recovery. The Media LineN “Such operations generally take between eight and 10 hours, and patients may experience severe pain afterward because the chest has been opened and the ribs spread.” Read at The Media Line ↗ JNSR “The traditional approach causes severe pain and shallow breathing, and makes it hard for patients to clear secretions.” Read at JNS ↗ Centre · 1Peischowicz said the team aims to make robotic surgery without opening the chest the accepted standard for lung transplantation within five years, and called it a turning point for lung transplants in Israel. The Media LineN ““We aspire to make robotic surgery without opening the chest the accepted standard for lung transplantation within five years,” Peischowicz said.”““Robotic lung transplantation is a turning point for lung transplants in Israel,”” Read at The Media Line ↗
Right · 1JNS, in text credited to TPS-IL, reports that dozens of staff took part, that the anesthesia team planned for the robotic arms limiting direct access to the patient (including a dedicated simulation), and that the patient was connected to a heart-lung machine in advance as a precaution. JNSR “Dozens of staff took part, including surgeons, anesthesiologists, heart-lung machine operators”“As a precaution, the patient was connected to a heart-lung machine in advance, allowing an immediate response if needed.” Read at JNS ↗ Right · 1JNS also reports that about a month earlier the hospital performed a preparatory transplant without opening the chest, using two small incisions, which paved the way for the robotic operation. JNSR “About a month earlier, the hospital performed a preparatory operation, a lung transplant without opening the chest, using just two small incisions” Read at JNS ↗ Mixed · 2The Media Line says doctors hope smaller incisions will mean less pain and fewer complications, while JNS states that the technique significantly improves the chances of success and shortens recovery; neither article gives patient outcomes or data. The Media LineN “Doctors hope smaller incisions will mean less postoperative pain and fewer complications” Read at The Media Line ↗ JNSR “The new technique significantly improves the chances of success and shortens recovery.” Read at JNS ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- Measured report on the first procedure, with benefits framed as potential.
- Emphasis
- Patient recovery, pain and complications; the surgeon's quotes.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not give the date of the operation, the earlier preparatory transplant, or the team and safety preparations.
- Charged language
- “turning point”
- For example
-
“Israel’s First Robotic Lung Transplant Could Cut Pain, Recovery Time” — The Media Line
““Robotic lung transplantation is a turning point for lung transplants in Israel,”” — The Media Line
Right2 outlets
- Framing
- Celebratory account of a medical breakthrough, with benefits stated as established.
- Emphasis
- The scale of the team effort, safety precautions, the preparatory operation and Israel's place among a few centres worldwide.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Offers no patient outcome data or evidence for the claimed improvement in success rates.
- Charged language
- “Revolutionary procedure”“significantly improves the chances of success”
What every side reports
- Beilinson Hospital in Petah Tikva performed Israel's first robot-assisted lung transplant.
- The da Vinci system and small incisions were used, without opening the chest or spreading the ribs.
- About 20 robotic lung transplants have been done worldwide.
- The surgeon leading the operation aims for this to be the standard within five years.
Where accounts differ
-
How firmly the benefits are stated
- Centre
- Describes the benefits as hopes and intentions: the approach could cut pain and recovery time.
- Right
- States as fact that the technique significantly improves the chances of success and shortens recovery.
Israel place
Israeli surgeons present the operation as a national first and a step towards making robotic, chest-sparing lung transplants standard within five years.
““Robotic lung transplantation is a turning point for lung transplants in Israel,”” — The Media Line
“In an Israeli first, surgeons at Beilinson Hospital in Petach Tikvah” — JNS
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre1 article
-
Israel’s First Robotic Lung Transplant Could Cut Pain, Recovery Time
Neutral Explains the procedure and its potential to reduce pain and recovery time, with cautious wording.
Right2 articles
-
JNSR ·
Revolutionary procedure: Robotic lung transplant without fully opening chest
Celebratory Presents the operation as a revolutionary first and states its benefits as fact.
-
- 2 Nov 13:54 First The Media LineN Israel’s First Robotic Lung Transplant Could Cut Pain, Recovery Time
- 3 Nov 06:08 +16h 13m JNSR Revolutionary procedure: Robotic lung transplant without fully opening chest
- 4 Nov 15:52 +49h 57m The Jerusalem PostRC Israeli surgeons complete robotic lung transplant without fully opening chest, spreading ribs
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…