Hundreds of Israelis march between rebuilt West Bank settlements during Sukkot
Hundreds of Israelis marched on Wednesday between Ganim and Kadim, northern West Bank settlements dismantled in 2005 and rebuilt this year. Both outlets carry the same AFP report, which calls it a symbolic return.
Updated (version 2). Rewritten with the latest reporting.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Hundreds of Israelis marched on Wednesday between newly rebuilt settlements in the northern West Bank to celebrate Sukkot, in what AFP called a symbolic show of return to an area until recently almost fully Palestinian. Arab NewsRC “Hundreds of Israelis marched Wednesday between newly rebuilt settlements in the northern West Bank to celebrate a Jewish holiday” Read at Arab News ↗ Gulf NewsN “a symbolic show of their return to an area until recently almost fully Palestinian” Read at Gulf News ↗ They walked between Ganim and Kadim, which the Israeli government dismantled in 2005 and which were rebuilt this year under Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Arab NewsRC “The Israeli government dismantled them in 2005 under a policy meant to disengage from Palestinian population centres” Read at Arab News ↗ Settlers of all ages carried traditional bundles of fruit and branches, and the hilltop had inflatable castles and clowns. Gulf NewsN “inflatable castles and clowns bringing a holiday atmosphere” Read at Gulf News ↗
Settler leader Yossi Dagan told the crowd that Israelis had "defeated Oslo" and promised to bring hundreds of thousands of Jews to the area, using its biblical name, Samaria. Arab NewsRC ““Together we will bring hundreds of thousands of Jews to our northern Samaria,”” Read at Arab News ↗ Participant Yishai Gerstle, 35, who grew up in a northern West Bank settlement, said it was amazing to return with his children. Arab NewsRC ““It’s amazing to come back with my kids and show them what we left and where we’re going back,”” Read at Arab News ↗ The army was deployed to protect the settlers, and the dirt road between the settlements was flanked by dozens of uprooted olive trees, which AFP described as a reminder of the Palestinian presence forced out. Prefabricated homes were waiting to be installed to expand the settlements. Arab NewsRC “a reminder of the Palestinian presence forced out to make way for the settlements” Read at Arab News ↗ Gulf NewsN “dozens of prefabricated homes were waiting to be installed to expand the settlements” Read at Gulf News ↗
AFP said 104 new settlements have been approved since Netanyahu returned to power in 2023, that more than 500,000 settlers live among three million Palestinians, and that settlements are illegal under international law; approvals have picked up ahead of elections on October 27. Arab NewsRC “104 new settlements have been approved in the West Bank” Read at Arab News ↗ Gulf NewsN “close-fought elections on October 27” Read at Gulf News ↗ AFP added that violence has soared in recent months, with near-daily settler attacks on Palestinians or their property and a recent fatal shooting of a settler by a Palestinian. Arab NewsRC “settlers attacking Palestinians or their property on a nearly daily basis” Read at Arab News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- Runs the AFP report in full, presenting the march as a symbolic return set against Palestinian displacement and rising violence.
- Emphasis
- Symbolism of the return, uprooted olive trees, army protection, settlement expansion.
- Leaves out or plays down
- No Palestinian voices; no separate reporting beyond the wire.
- For example
-
“a reminder of the Palestinian presence forced out to make way for the settlements” — Gulf News
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Carries the same AFP text under the same headline, with no differences in framing from the centre outlet.
- Emphasis
- Same as AFP: symbolic return, Dagan's remarks, context of settlement approvals and elections.
- Leaves out or plays down
- No Palestinian voices; no separate reporting beyond the wire.
- For example
-
“Hundreds of Israelis celebrated the holiday of Sukkot by marching between recently rebuilt West Bank settlements.” — Arab News
What every side reports
- Hundreds of Israelis marched between Ganim and Kadim in the northern West Bank on Wednesday for Sukkot.
- The settlements were dismantled in 2005 and rebuilt this year under Netanyahu.
- 104 new settlements have been approved since 2023, and settlements are illegal under international law.
Israeli settlers person
Settler leader Yossi Dagan and participants present the march as a victory over the Oslo process and a return to the land.
““Our wonderful people of Israel defeated Oslo,”” — Arab News
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre1 article
-
Gulf NewsN · · via AFP
Israelis march between once-closed West Bank settlements
Neutral The same AFP copy, with embedded links to related stories on Netanyahu's settlement pledges and settler attacks.

Right1 article
-
Arab NewsRC · · via AFP
Israelis march between once-closed West Bank settlements
Neutral AFP wire copy describing the march as a symbolic return, with settlement and violence context.

- 30 Sep 16:33 First Arab NewsRC Israelis march between once-closed West Bank settlements via AFP
- 30 Sep 17:18 +45m Gulf NewsN Israelis march between once-closed West Bank settlements via AFP
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.