Japan's Fair Trade Commission raids four major beer makers over suspected price cartel
Japan's Fair Trade Commission searched the premises of the country's four biggest beer makers on 7 October over suspected price coordination in sales to wholesalers. The companies confirmed the raids and said they would cooperate, and shares of the listed firms fell.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Centre · 2Japan's Fair Trade Commission (JFTC) raided the country's four major beer makers on Wednesday 7 October on suspicion of cartelisation in sales of beer and other products to wholesalers, the companies said. CNAN “Japan's Fair Trade Commission raided the country's four major beer makers on Wednesday on suspicion of cartelisation in sales of beer and other products to wholesalers, the companies said.” Read at CNA ↗ BBC NewsN “Japanese officials have raided the country's biggest beer makers over allegations they worked together to raise the price of their beverages.” Read at BBC News ↗ Centre · 2The firms are Kirin Holdings, Asahi Group Holdings, Sapporo and Suntory; Suntory is not publicly listed. Together they are reported to control more than 90 per cent of Japan's domestic beer market. CNAN “which together control more than 90 per cent of Japan's domestic beer market” Read at CNA ↗ BBC NewsN “Suntory is not publicly-listed.” Read at BBC News ↗ Centre · 2The companies are suspected of coordinating prices over several years. NHK reported that the JFTC is examining whether they formed a cartel when they raised prices in April last year and October 2022, and the Japan Times, cited by the BBC, also said the investigation centres on those increases. CNAN “Public broadcaster NHK said the Fair Trade Commission was probing whether the companies formed a cartel when they raised prices in April last year and October 2022” Read at CNA ↗ BBC NewsN “According to the Japan Times, the investigation centres on the companies raising their prices in April last year and in October 2022.” Read at BBC News ↗
Centre · 2All four companies cited rising costs of raw materials, as well as factors such as energy and transportation, for their price rises. BBC NewsN “All four companies announced increases, citing the rising cost of raw materials as well as other factors such as energy and transportation.” Read at BBC News ↗ CNAN “Recent years have seen these firms raise beer prices on multiple occasions, citing the rising costs of raw material and logistics, local media said.” Read at CNA ↗ Centre · 1An anonymous source told AFP that representatives of the four companies are believed to have met periodically to discuss pricing and the timing of increases, and that this was the first time the JFTC had conducted on-site inspections over a wholesale beer pricing cartel. CNAN “representatives from the four companies are believed to have met up periodically to discuss pricing and the timing of the hike, the source said.”“In a first, the Japan Fair Trade Commission (JFTC) conducted on-site inspections to probe "the allegations regarding a wholesale beer pricing cartel"” Read at CNA ↗ Centre · 2The companies confirmed the searches and said they would cooperate. Kirin said its subsidiary Kirin Brewery was searched on suspicion of violating the Antimonopoly Act, that it takes the matter "very seriously", and that the financial impact has not been determined. Asahi said it was subject to an investigation under the Act on Prohibition of Private Monopolization and Maintenance of Fair Trade, and Suntory said it was undergoing an on-site inspection. BBC NewsN “It said it takes the matter "very seriously", adding it would "fully cooperate with the Japan Fair Trade Commission's investigation and any requests for cooperation".”“"At present, the impact of this matter on the company's financial results has not been determined.” Read at BBC News ↗ CNAN “"undergoing an on-site inspection by the Fair Trade Commission on suspicion of breaching the anti-monopoly act in relation to its alcohol trading activities."” Read at CNA ↗
Centre · 2Shares of the listed makers fell, by nearly 4 per cent at the worst point according to CNA. Sapporo fell as much as 3.73 per cent, Kirin briefly dropped a little over 3 per cent to its lowest level in more than three months, and Asahi fell nearly 2.5 per cent before recouping some losses. CNAN “Shares in Sapporo fell as much as 3.73 per cent, while Kirin briefly shed a little over 3 per cent to hit its lowest level in more than three months.” Read at CNA ↗ BBC NewsN “Asahi, Kirin and Sapporo all saw their share price fall after news of the investigation broke on Wednesday.” Read at BBC News ↗ Centre · 1The JFTC declined to elaborate. NHK and a source said it is expected to continue the investigation and could file a criminal complaint. CNAN “The anti-trust watchdog is expected to continue its investigation and could file a criminal complaint, a source familiar with the matter said”“The Commission declined to elaborate on the investigation.” Read at CNA ↗ Centre · 1The raids follow a JFTC cartel probe earlier this year, in June, into six ice-cream makers including Morinaga Milk Industry and Meiji Holdings, which allegedly coordinated price rises beyond what higher raw material costs justified. CNAN “In June, it raided six Japanese ice-cream makers, including Morinaga Milk Industry and Meiji Holdings, over allegations of operating a cartel.” Read at CNA ↗ CNAN “They allegedly coordinated price hikes for years beyond what was justified by a spike in raw ingredient costs.” Read at CNA ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre2 outlets
- Framing
- Straight business and news reporting: the raids, company confirmations and cooperation pledges, and share-price reaction, with allegations attributed to NHK, the Japan Times or an anonymous source.
- Emphasis
- Market impact (CNA), the companies' statements (BBC), and the precedent of the ice-cream cartel probe (CNA).
- Leaves out or plays down
- No outlet has a JFTC statement on the substance of the allegations, or company responses to the cartel claims beyond pledges to cooperate. The BBC says Sapporo and Suntory had not yet commented, while CNA reports all four confirmed.
- Charged language
- “price-fixing cartel”“giants”
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- The JFTC searched the four biggest Japanese beer makers on 7 October over suspected price coordination.
- Kirin and Asahi confirmed the searches and pledged to cooperate.
- Shares of the listed makers fell; Suntory is unlisted.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether all four companies had confirmed the raids
- Centre
- CNA says all four confirmed separately; the BBC says Asahi and Kirin confirmed while Sapporo and Suntory were reportedly raided and awaiting comment.
Japan Fair Trade Commission organisation
Conducted the on-site inspections but declined to elaborate on the investigation.
“The Commission declined to elaborate on the investigation.” — CNA
Kirin Holdings organisation
Confirmed Kirin Brewery was searched, says it takes the matter very seriously and will fully cooperate; financial impact not yet determined.
“It said it takes the matter "very seriously", adding it would "fully cooperate with the Japan Fair Trade Commission's investigation and any requests for cooperation".” — BBC News
Asahi Group Holdings organisation
Confirmed it is subject to a JFTC investigation and will fully cooperate.
“"We will fully cooperate with the commission."” — BBC News
Sapporo Holdings organisation
Said with the other makers to intend to cooperate, per CNA; the BBC had not yet received comment.
“All four companies separately confirmed the raids and said they intend to cooperate with the investigation.” — CNA
Suntory Holdings organisation
Said it is undergoing an on-site inspection on suspicion of breaching the anti-monopoly act.
“"undergoing an on-site inspection by the Fair Trade Commission on suspicion of breaching the anti-monopoly act in relation to its alcohol trading activities."” — CNA
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre4 articles
-
CNAN ·
Major Japanese beer companies raided over accusations of cartelisation
Neutral Short bulleted breaking item on the raids, company confirmations and morning-session share moves.
-
CNAN ·
Shares of Japan beer makers fall after raids over cartel suspicion
Neutral Market-focused report on share falls after the raids, with NHK and source attributions and the ice-cream probe as context.
-
CNAN ·
Japan raids beer giants over alleged price cartel
Neutral AFP-sourced account stressing an anonymous source's claim that executives met to discuss prices and that this is a first on-site inspection.
-
Japan beer giants raided over alleged price-fixing cartel
Neutral Leads with Asahi and Kirin confirming to the BBC, quotes company statements and says Sapporo and Suntory raids are reported but awaiting comment.
Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 7 Oct 04:29 First CNAN Major Japanese beer companies raided over accusations of cartelisation
- 7 Oct 04:29 First CNAN Shares of Japan beer makers fall after raids over cartel suspicion
- 7 Oct 08:28 +3h 59m CNAN Japan raids beer giants over alleged price cartel
- 7 Oct 10:45 +6h 16m BBC NewsN Japan beer giants raided over alleged price-fixing cartel
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.