Skip to content
Bramble

Politics

Healey's first Labour conference speech as Chancellor draws on New Labour past

John Healey's first conference speech as Chancellor mixed talk of hope with references to Gordon Brown and the 1990s. The left-leaning New Statesman stresses the New Labour ties; the Daily Mail's Andrew Neil criticises the speech for lacking economic substance.

2 outlets · 1L · 0C · 1R First reported Account updated
Image: New Statesman
Image: Daily Mail

1 / 2

The story, neutrally told

John Healey gave his first Labour conference speech as Chancellor, in Liverpool. The New Statesman reports that Healey, who was a parliamentary private secretary to Gordon Brown between 1999 and 2001, referred to Brown frequently. The New Statesman describes the speech as caught between hope for the future and nostalgia for the 1990s fiscal climate.

Andrew Neil, in a Daily Mail opinion column, quotes Healey saying that the money New Labour had in the Nineties is 'simply not there', which he says was aimed at the party's soft left and met with silence. Neil says Healey also stated that 'Fiscal discipline underwrites everything we do' and called getting people off welfare and into work a 'moral duty'; he says applause for the welfare line came only after a pause. Neil calls the speech 'a pretty dismal affair' lacking substance, and argues that talk of a 'new age of industrialisation' ignores high industrial energy costs.

He also says Healey offered no detail on the Budget, which is a month away, and expects tax rises to follow. Neil notes Healey praised Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves, whom he describes as respectively brought down partly by Healey's resignation and sacked to make way for Healey; these are his characterisations.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on.

Left1 outlet

Framing
A short analysis of the speech through Healey's links to Gordon Brown and New Labour.
Emphasis
Healey's past as Brown's parliamentary private secretary and the nostalgia in the speech.
Leaves out or plays down
Says nothing in the coverage seen about fiscal detail, the Budget, or reaction in the hall.
For example
“The Chancellor, who was a parliamentary private secretary to Gordon Brown between 1999 and 2001, referenced his former boss frequently in his speech.” — New Statesman

Centre0 outlets

No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Right1 outlet

Framing
A critical opinion column judging the speech on economic substance and the Chancellor's duty to reassure markets.
Emphasis
Lack of Budget detail, energy costs, borrowing, likely tax rises, and hypocrisy over Starmer and Reeves.
Leaves out or plays down
Brown is not mentioned; the New Labour reference appears only through the line on 1990s money.
Charged language
“dismal affair”“Vacuous talk”“multiple dollops of hypocrisy”“meaningless nonsense”
For example
“Plus multiple dollops of hypocrisy.” — Daily Mail
“probably because it’s a meaningless nonsense” — Daily Mail