Jordan arrests three suspects over deadly Karak Greek Orthodox church attack
Jordanian security forces arrested three suspects on 26 October after a shootout, three days after gunmen killed nine people at a funeral in a Greek Orthodox church in Karak governorate. No group has claimed responsibility.
1 / 8
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Jordanian security forces arrested three suspects on Monday 26 October over an attack on a Greek Orthodox church that killed nine people, state television and the Petra news agency reported. The Straits TimesRC “Jordanian security forces have arrested three suspects in connection with an attack on a church in the US-allied country that killed nine people, state television reported on Monday.” Read at The Straits Times ↗ The NationalN “state-run Petra news agency said on Monday” Read at The National ↗ Mixed · 2The attack took place on Friday 23 October, when gunmen opened fire during a funeral at the church in the village of Hamoud (also spelt Hammoud) in Karak governorate, about 120 km southwest of Amman; witnesses said the shooting lasted several minutes. CNAN “in the village of Hamoud in Karak governorate, about 120 km southwest of the capital Amman, also wounded 40 others. The shooting lasted several minutes, witnesses said.” Read at CNA ↗ The HinduLC “Gunmen stormed the compound of a Greek Orthodox church in the village of Hammoud in Karak governorate during a funeral procession on October 23” Read at The Hindu ↗ Mixed · 3Reports differ on the number wounded: Reuters-based reports and The National say 40, Arab News says 25, and the AP report in The Hindu says more than two dozen. CNAN “killing nine people and wounding 40 others” Read at CNA ↗ Arab NewsRC “killed nine people and wounded 25 others” Read at Arab News ↗ The HinduLC “killed nine people and wounded more than two dozen” Read at The Hindu ↗
Centre · 1Jordan's Public Security Directorate said forces found the suspects early on Monday hiding in an abandoned house in Karak; they refused to surrender and opened fire, and security forces returned fire and arrested all three after they were wounded. CNAN “security forces located the three suspects early on Monday hiding in an abandoned house in Karak. The suspects refused to surrender and opened fire on security forces, who returned fire and arrested all three after they were wounded” Read at CNA ↗ Centre · 1No security personnel were hurt, and firearms and ammunition were found with the suspects. CNAN “No security personnel were injured, and a number of firearms and ammunition were found in the suspects' possession after their arrest.” Read at CNA ↗ Right · 1The directorate said "Terrorism has no place among us" and that the suspects had met their "just fate". The Jerusalem PostRC “"Terrorism has no place among us," the directorate said, adding that the suspects had met their "just fate."” Read at The Jerusalem Post ↗
Mixed · 2It did not identify their affiliation or say whether they belonged to a militant group, and no group has claimed responsibility. CNAN “The Public Security Directorate did not identify the suspects' affiliation or say whether they belonged to any militant group.” Read at CNA ↗ The HinduLC “There was still no claim of responsibility, and no armed group has been accused of the attack.” Read at The Hindu ↗ Mixed · 2Interior Minister Mazen al-Faraya said authorities were examining the circumstances that lead young people toward extremism and would hold accountable everyone found to have been involved; he earlier said the attackers were extremists but that it was too early to say whether they had links to known groups. Arab NewsRC “we are examining all the circumstances that lead young people toward extremism, and we will hold accountable everyone found to have been involved” Read at Arab News ↗ CNAN “it was too early to determine whether they had links to known groups inside or outside Jordan” Read at CNA ↗ Mixed · 2King Abdullah II ordered security forces to respond with an "iron fist"; Arab News also quotes him saying "the hand of justice will reach every terrorist", and Prime Minister Jafar Hassan declared three days of national mourning. The HinduLC “King Abdullah II directed authorities to respond with “an iron fist”” Read at The Hindu ↗ Arab NewsRC “the hand of justice will reach every terrorist.”“Prime Minister Jafar Hassan ordered a three-day period of national mourning from Friday” Read at Arab News ↗
Mixed · 2On Sunday eight of the nine victims were buried beside the church in a funeral attended by a large crowd; Queen Rania and Crown Prince Hussein attended and offered condolences on behalf of the King. Arab NewsRC “On Sunday, eight of the nine victims were laid to rest next to the church, in a funeral that drew a huge crowd.” Read at Arab News ↗ The NationalN “During the visit, Crown Prince Hussein expressed the sympathies and condolences of King Abdullah II to the families.” Read at The National ↗ Centre · 2The National described it as the biggest attack on Jordan's Christian minority since the 1950s, with most of the dead from the Halasah clan; Reuters-based reports call such violence highly unusual in Jordan, though authorities say they have foiled several Islamist plots. The NationalN “It was the biggest attack against Jordan's Christian minority since the 1950s.” Read at The National ↗ CNAN “authorities say they have foiled several Islamist militant plots over the years” Read at CNA ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left3 outlets
- Framing
- The Hindu runs AP copy centred on the dawn shootout and the interior minister's statement, with links to related India and US embassy items.
- Emphasis
- Suspects' wounds, no security injuries, absence of any claim or accused group, the minister's quote that they put up 'fierce resistance'.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not give the abandoned-house detail or the wider context of rarity.
- Charged language
- “terrorist act”“an iron fist”
- For example
-
“There was still no claim of responsibility, and no armed group has been accused of the attack.” — The Hindu
Centre6 outlets
- Framing
- Straight arrests report from CNA (Reuters text) and The National, plus a National piece on the royal family at the funeral.
- Emphasis
- Police account of the arrest, unidentified affiliation, the funeral and the historic scale of the attack on Christians.
- Leaves out or plays down
- CNA and The National give little on the King's statements beyond the 'iron fist' and 'terrorism' labels.
- Charged language
- “extremist terrorists”“just fate”“unprecedented attack”
- For example
-
“King Abdullah, a US partner in the fight against Islamist militant groups, has ordered security forces to respond with an "iron fist"” — CNA
“It was the biggest attack against Jordan's Christian minority since the 1950s.” — The National
Right4 outlets
- Framing
- Reuters copy via the Straits Times and Jerusalem Post, and Arab News's own report, all lead with the arrests citing state media.
- Emphasis
- Arab News adds the king's 'red line' remarks, mourning and the Christian share of the population; the Jerusalem Post and Straits Times stress the 'US-allied' country and Islamist militant plots.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Arab News's 25 wounded differs from the 40 elsewhere; Jerusalem Post's headline and text do not note the figure discrepancy.
- Charged language
- “cowardly terrorist attack”“Islamist terror groups”“terrorists”
- For example
-
“apprehended the three terrorists responsible for the cowardly terrorist attack” — Arab News
“King Abdullah, a US partner in the fight against Islamist terror groups” — The Jerusalem Post
What every side reports
- Three suspects were arrested on 26 October after a shootout.
- Nine people were killed at a Greek Orthodox church funeral in Hamoud, Karak governorate, on 23 October.
- No group has claimed responsibility.
Where accounts differ
-
Number wounded in the attack
- Left
- The Hindu (AP): more than two dozen.
- Centre
- CNA and The National: 40 wounded.
- Right
- Straits Times and Jerusalem Post (Reuters): 40; Arab News: 25.
-
Jordanian security forces arrested three suspects over the Karak church attack.
Reported- Reports 6
- The Hindu, CNA, The National, Arab News, The Jerusalem Post, The Straits Times
-
The suspects resisted arrest and opened fire, and all three were wounded in a shootout.
Reported- Reports 6
- The Hindu, CNA, The National, Arab News, The Jerusalem Post, The Straits Times
-
The suspects' links to any militant group are unestablished and the Karak church attack remains unclaimed.
Reported- Reports 3
- CNA, The National, The Straits Times
Jordan (country) place
Jordanian authorities present the arrests as a successful security operation against 'terrorists', promise accountability and say the country's unity will not be undermined.
““The security services have fulfilled their duties, resulting in the capture of those who carried out this terrorist act,”” — The Hindu
Queen Rania person
Queen Rania attended the funeral with Crown Prince Hussein, prayed for the victims and comforted families.
“Queen Rania prayed for the victims and was seen comforting their family members.” — The National
Left5 articles
-
-
-
The HinduLC · · via AP
Jordanian security forces arrest 3 men for deadly attack on church
Neutral AP copy in The Hindu stressing shootout, minister's quotes and no accused group.
-
Show 1 moreShow fewer
Centre9 articles
-
-
The Media LineN · · Opinion
‘Wake Up From the Illusion’: Jordanian Analyst Warns of Deepening Radicalization After Church Attack
-
CNAN ·
Singapore leaders condemn deadly church attack in Jordan, convey condolences to victims' families
-
Jordan arrests three over deadly Karak church attack
Neutral Arrests report citing Petra, with funeral and king's statements.
Show 5 moreShow fewer
-
Queen Rania attends funeral of victims killed in Jordan church attack
Sympathetic Focuses on the royal family at the victims' funeral and the attack's historic scale.
-
CNAN ·
Jordan arrests three suspects in deadly church attack
Neutral CNA runs the Reuters arrests story with context on rarity of such violence.
-
-
Right10 articles
-
-
The Straits TimesRC · · via Reuters
Jordan church attack survivor says her cousin died before her eyes
-
-
Show 6 moreShow fewer
-
The Straits TimesRC · · via Reuters
Jordan arrests three over Karak church attack, state TV says
Neutral Short Reuters flash on the arrests carried by the Straits Times.
-
The Straits TimesRC · · via Reuters
Jordan arrests three suspects in deadly church attack, state media says
Neutral Reuters report via the Straits Times: arrests, police account, king's 'iron fist'.
-
Jordan arrests 3 over church attack: state TV
Mixed Arab News relays official language such as 'cowardly terrorist attack' and the king's vows, with funeral detail.
-
Arab NewsRC · · via AFP
-
Jordan’s Crown Prince offers condolences to families of Karak church attack victims
Sympathetic Headline frames the Crown Prince's condolences to victims' families.
-
Jordan arrests three suspects in deadly church attack, state media says
Neutral Reuters copy in the Jerusalem Post, with a subhead on terrorists and Islamist-group context.
- 25 Oct 08:28 First JNSR Israeli envoy condemns ‘horrific’ attack on Christians in Jordan
- 25 Oct 09:50 +1h 23m The Straits TimesRC Jordan church attack survivor says her cousin died before her eyes via Reuters
- 25 Oct 09:52 +1h 24m The NationalN Funeral to be held for victims of Jordan church attack
- 25 Oct 15:07 +6h 40m The Media LineN ‘Wake Up From the Illusion’: Jordanian Analyst Warns of Deepening Radicalization After Church Attack Opinion
- 25 Oct 15:21 +6h 53m Al JazeeraLC Thousands mourn victims of deadly Jordan church attack
- 25 Oct 16:16 +7h 49m Al JazeeraLC Jordanians mourn victims of deadly church attack
- 25 Oct 18:03 +9h 35m Arab NewsRC Jordan’s Queen Rania, Crown Prince Hussein mourn 9 killed in church attack
- 25 Oct 19:19 +10h 52m Arab NewsRC Jordanians reject attempts to sow division in society
- 26 Oct 03:47 +19h 19m The Straits TimesRC Jordan arrests three over Karak church attack, state TV says via Reuters
- 26 Oct 03:58 +19h 31m CNAN Singapore leaders condemn deadly church attack in Jordan, convey condolences to victims' families
- 26 Oct 04:20 +19h 53m The Straits TimesRC Jordan arrests three suspects in deadly church attack, state media says via Reuters
- 26 Oct 04:30 +20h 3m The NationalN Jordan arrests three over deadly Karak church attack
- 26 Oct 04:37 +20h 9m Arab NewsRC Jordan arrests 3 over church attack: state TV
- 26 Oct 04:37 +20h 9m Arab NewsRC Jordan arrests 3 over church attack via AFP
- 26 Oct 04:42 +20h 14m The Jerusalem PostRC Jordan arrests three suspects in deadly church attack, state media says
- 26 Oct 04:52 +20h 24m The NationalN Queen Rania attends funeral of victims killed in Jordan church attack
- 26 Oct 05:44 +21h 17m Arab NewsRC Jordan’s Crown Prince offers condolences to families of Karak church attack victims
- 26 Oct 06:14 +21h 46m CNAN Jordan arrests three suspects in deadly church attack
- 26 Oct 06:21 +21h 53m The HinduLC Jordanian security forces arrest 3 men for deadly attack on church via AP
- 26 Oct 06:40 +22h 13m Hindustan TimesN Jordanian forces arrest 3 suspects in Karak church attack that killed 9 via Reuters
- 26 Oct 07:03 +22h 35m Al JazeeraLC Jordan arrests three suspects in deadly church attack
- 26 Oct 07:06 +22h 38m Anadolu AgencyN Jordan arrests 3 suspects over church attack that killed 9
- 26 Oct 07:10 +22h 42m CBS NewsLC Jordan says 3 arrested in deadly attack on Greek Orthodox church
- 26 Oct 08:14 +23h 47m Gulf NewsN Jordan arrests three suspects in Karak church attack after three-hour gun battle
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…