Karaganov says Russia would 'go nuclear' against Europe if it keeps backing Ukraine
Russian foreign policy strategist Sergei Karaganov said in interviews that Russia would escalate to nuclear weapons if Europe keeps backing Ukraine or NATO acts against Kaliningrad. The warnings came a day after Russia sent NATO a note threatening nuclear use over Kaliningrad.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Sergei Karaganov, a prominent Russian foreign policy strategist, warned that Russia would 'go nuclear' against European countries if they continue to back Ukraine. Daily MailR “A prominent Russian foreign policy strategist has warned Moscow will 'go nuclear' and leave 'little left' of some European countries if they continue backing Ukraine.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ According to the Daily Mail, he told the BBC that the first series of blows would be conventional, but that if Europe did not surrender Russia would have to use nuclear weapons, leaving 'little left of some European countries'. Daily MailR “'According to my scenarios, the first series of blows will be conventional. But if Europe does not surrender, unfortunately, we will have to go nuclear. There will be little left of some European countries.'” Read at Daily Mail ↗ He dismissed the idea of a nuclear response from Britain or the United States, saying 'there will be no response from Europe'. Daily MailR “'No, there will be no response from Europe,' he said. 'What, Britain will attack Russia with nuclear weapons? I hope you're not that crazy.” Read at Daily Mail ↗
The Daily Mirror reports a separate interview in which he said Russia would be forced to launch a nuclear strike if NATO countries deployed troops to Ukraine or if there were a direct threat to Russian territory, including Kaliningrad. Daily MirrorL “Russia would be forced to launch a nuclear strike if NATO countries deployed troops to Ukrainian territory or if there were a direct threat to Russian territory.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ In that interview he said he hoped it would not come to that and was working to prevent it, but also said a nuclear war in Europe 'could easily be won' although millions of innocent people would die. Daily MirrorL “"A nuclear war in Europe could easily be won. But it would inflict terrible moral damage on us, and millions of innocent people would perish."” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Asked about his earlier call for a pre-emptive nuclear strike, he replied 'It's not too late. It's never too late.' Daily MirrorL “"It’s not too late. It’s never too late."” Read at Daily Mirror ↗
The Mirror describes him as a former Putin adviser for 12 years and a distinguished professor at Moscow's Higher School of Economics, while the Mail calls him honorary chairman of Russia's Council for Foreign and Defence Policy. Daily MirrorL “Karaganov was an adviser to the Kremlin for 12 years” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Daily MailR “The honorary chairman of Russia's Council for Foreign and Defence Policy” Read at Daily Mail ↗ The remarks followed a diplomatic note, seen by Reuters, in which Russia warned NATO on Wednesday it was ready to use its entire arsenal, including nuclear weapons, if NATO tried to isolate Kaliningrad. Daily MailR “'Russia will be ready to use the entire arsenal of forces and capabilities at its disposal, including nuclear weapons, in order to defend its territory should NATO countries undertake any attempt aimed at isolating the Kaliningrad Region from the rest of the country,'” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Daily MirrorL “Russia has once again warned NATO of a "very short" nuclear war” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte replied that NATO is a defensive alliance and told Russia to 'stop the nuclear threats'. Daily MailR “'We are a defensive alliance. And stop the nuclear threats. This is absolutely not called for and not helpful.'” Read at Daily Mail ↗
The Mail adds that Western officials accuse Moscow of cyber-attacks, sabotage and drone incursions in Europe, and that Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov told the BBC Europe is waging war against Russia by arming Ukraine. Daily MailR “Russia's foreign minister Sergei Lavrov, meanwhile, accused Europe of waging war against his country when questioned by the BBC” Read at Daily Mail ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Personality-led alarm piece built around the 'Professor Doomsday' label and Karaganov's remarks about millions dying.
- Emphasis
- His nuclear war quotes, his 'chilling smile', and his credentials.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not include NATO's response, the Reuters-reported Russian note details, or wider context of hybrid attacks.
- Charged language
- “Professor Doomsday”“chilling smile”“chilling claims”
- For example
-
“Vladimir Putin's 'Professor Doomsday' warns 'millions will die' in Europe nuclear strike” — Daily Mirror
“He gave a chilling smile as he said” — Daily Mirror
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Frames the remarks as the 'latest WW3 threat', set within Russian hybrid attacks and the Kaliningrad note.
- Emphasis
- Europe's exposure, NATO and Rutte's reply, drone and sabotage incidents, and Putin's lack of willingness to halt the war.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Gives less on Karaganov's statement that he is working to prevent nuclear war or his trigger conditions about NATO troops.
- Charged language
- “latest WW3 threat”“grey zone”
- For example
-
“in latest WW3 threat” — Daily Mail
“The claim reflects the Kremlin's longstanding portrayal of the conflict as a European war against Russia” — Daily Mail
What every side reports
- Karaganov warned Russia could use nuclear weapons against Europe.
- Both outlets link the warning to Russian threats over Kaliningrad.
- Karaganov did not address a possible NATO nuclear reprisal in a way that treated it as likely.
Where accounts differ
-
What triggers a Russian nuclear strike
- Left
- The Mirror says the triggers are NATO troops in Ukraine or action against Kaliningrad or other Russian territory.
- Right
- The Mail says the trigger is Europe continuing to back Ukraine and refusing to surrender, after initial conventional strikes.
Sergei Karaganov person
Says Russia would escalate to nuclear weapons if Europe keeps fighting or NATO acts on Russian soil, while saying he hopes to avoid it and expects no Western nuclear reply.
“'No, there will be no response from Europe,' he said.” — Daily Mail
“"I do not want that, and I am actively working to prevent such a scenario."” — Daily Mirror
Russia place
Moscow, per the Mail, told NATO it would use its full arsenal to defend Kaliningrad and presents the conflict as a European war against Russia.
“Moscow accused the alliance of a 'dangerous and reckless course'” — Daily Mail
Left1 article
-
Vladimir Putin's 'Professor Doomsday' warns 'millions will die' in Europe nuclear strike
Alarmist Centres on the 'Professor Doomsday' nickname and his claim a nuclear war could be won, with a focus on his demeanour.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right1 article
-
Alarmist Presents Karaganov's BBC remarks as an escalating threat alongside the Kaliningrad note and hybrid attacks, and includes NATO's rebuttal.
- 1 Oct 14:32 First Daily MailR Russian official warns country will eventually 'go nuclear' and there will be 'little left' of some European countries if they continue to back Ukraine in latest WW3 threat
- 1 Oct 18:05 +3h 34m Daily MirrorL Vladimir Putin's 'Professor Doomsday' warns 'millions will die' in Europe nuclear strike
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.