US · RFK Jr's Make America Healthy Again initiative
Kennedy tells sponsor-backed MAHA summit AI will be better informed than doctors
Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. told the Make America Healthy Again summit that AI could soon be better informed than any doctor. The event had corporate and AI-company sponsors, and a physician interviewed by CBS News called the advice a bad idea.
Updated (version 2). New coverage since the last version from Breitbart. Previously: “Kennedy says AI is "better informed" than doctors at sponsor-backed MAHA summit”.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. told the Make America Healthy Again (MAHA) Summit in Washington on Tuesday that AI could soon give patients "a second opinion that is much better informed than any doctor in the country," according to Breitbart. BreitbartR “AI could soon give patients “a second opinion that is much better informed than any doctor in the country,”” Read at Breitbart ↗ The New York Times headline frames the remark as AI being "better informed" than doctors, and CBS News reports Kennedy says Americans should consult AI rather than a doctor. The New York TimesLC “A.I. Is ‘Better Informed’ Than Doctors, Kennedy Tells Industry-Backed MAHA Summit” Read at The New York Times ↗ CBS NewsLC “says that Americans should consult artificial intelligence rather than a doctor” Read at CBS News ↗ Vice President JD Vance and other top officials addressed the conference, which the New York Times says was sponsored by corporations including AI companies and others with business before the government. The New York TimesLC “a conference sponsored by corporations, including A.I. companies and others with business before the government” Read at The New York Times ↗
Breitbart, citing Politico, says sponsors included Walmart, the cancer-screening firm Grail, Anthropic and OpenAI, and that the event was held at the Waldorf Astoria. BreitbartR “sponsored by companies including Walmart, the cancer-screening firm Grail, and AI kingpins Anthropic and OpenAI” Read at Breitbart ↗ In an onstage chat with Vance, Kennedy said AI would "free us from medical tyranny" and that the public would no longer be "dominated by public officials who tell us, 'Trust the experts.'" BreitbartR ““One of the things that is going to change is that we’re never ever again going to be able to be dominated by public officials who tell us, ‘Trust the experts,'” he said.” Read at Breitbart ↗ He suggested AI might contradict official guidance on masks, social distancing and vaccine transmission, and said OpenAI chief executive Sam Altman told him it would be "malpractice" for a doctor to diagnose or prescribe without checking AI. BreitbartR ““If somebody tells you, ‘Masks work, trust the experts,’ AI may tell you otherwise,”” Read at Breitbart ↗
Vance joked, "I guess I'm in the wrong summit. I thought this was about weight loss and acid, not A.I." BreitbartR ““I guess I’m in the wrong summit. I thought this was about weight loss and acid, not A.I.,”” Read at Breitbart ↗ CBS News interviewed Dr. Céline Gounder, who said relying on AI instead of a doctor is a bad idea. CBS NewsLC “Dr. Céline Gounder says this is a bad idea.” Read at CBS News ↗ Breitbart also reported that Dr. Robert Malone, a former vice chair of a vaccine advisory committee Kennedy appointed, dismissed the event: "It's all a grift." BreitbartR ““It’s all a grift.”” Read at Breitbart ↗
The summit came five weeks before the midterm elections; none of the coverage gives a response from Kennedy, the Department of Health and Human Services or the sponsors to the criticism. BreitbartR “The summit came five weeks before the midterm elections” Read at Breitbart ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on.
Left2 outlets
- Framing
- The New York Times and CBS News lead with Kennedy's remark. The Times highlights the corporate sponsorship, and CBS pairs the remark with a physician's rebuttal.
- Emphasis
- Sponsors with business before the government (NYT); a doctor's warning against replacing doctors with AI (CBS).
- Leaves out or plays down
- The available coverage gives little of Kennedy's full remarks, such as his comments on masks and vaccines, or any response from Kennedy, HHS or sponsors.
- Charged language
- “Industry-Backed”
- For example
-
“a conference sponsored by corporations, including A.I. companies and others with business before the government” — The New York Times
“Dr. Céline Gounder says this is a bad idea.” — CBS News
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Breitbart reports Kennedy's pitch for medical AI at length, in his own words. It then argues AI carries its own bias, drawing on a book by a Breitbart editor.
- Emphasis
- Kennedy's challenge to 'trust the experts' messaging, Vance's joke, and bias in AI models.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not quote a medical professional rebutting the claim that AI is better informed than doctors, and does not discuss the sponsorship as a conflict of interest.
- Charged language
- “AI kingpins”“medical tyranny”“extreme leftist positions”
What every side reports
- Kennedy said AI is or will soon be better informed than doctors.
- The remarks were made at the MAHA summit, which had corporate sponsors including AI companies.
- Vice President JD Vance took part in the event.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether Americans should turn to AI instead of doctors
- Left
- CBS News presents Kennedy's advice as something a physician, Dr. Céline Gounder, says is a bad idea.
- Right
- Breitbart relays Kennedy's case that AI can counter official guidance, and questions AI bias rather than the idea of using it.
-
Americans should consult AI rather than doctors, because AI is better informed than doctors
Reported- Disputes 1
- CBS News
- Reports 2
- The New York Times, Breitbart
-
AI is or will soon be better informed than doctors
Reported- Supports 1
- Breitbart
- Reports 2
- CBS News, The New York Times
Robert F. Kennedy Jr. person
Presents AI as a tool that can give patients better-informed second opinions and challenge officials who say 'trust the experts'.
“AI would “free us from medical tyranny.”” — Breitbart
Left2 articles
-
A.I. Is ‘Better Informed’ Than Doctors, Kennedy Tells Industry-Backed MAHA Summit
Critical Highlights the corporate sponsorship of the summit, including AI companies, next to Kennedy's claim.
-
Doctor reacts to RFK Jr.'s claim that AI is "better informed" than doctors
Critical Presents Kennedy's advice and then a doctor's view that it is a bad idea.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right1 article
-
RFK Jr.: Medical AI Will Soon Be 'Better Informed than any Doctor in the Country'
Mixed Relays Kennedy's remarks in detail and includes a critic from the movement, then pivots to arguing that AI carries political bias.
- 30 Sep 01:10 First The New York TimesLC A.I. Is ‘Better Informed’ Than Doctors, Kennedy Tells Industry-Backed MAHA Summit
- 30 Sep 16:21 +15h 11m BreitbartR RFK Jr.: Medical AI Will Soon Be 'Better Informed than any Doctor in the Country'
- 30 Sep 16:40 +15h 30m CBS NewsLC Doctor reacts to RFK Jr.'s claim that AI is "better informed" than doctors
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.