Last "grandmother" cottonwood felled for border wall in Lochiel, Arizona; protesters arrested
Border Patrol agents raided a protest camp in Lochiel, Arizona, on Monday 5 October, and contractors cut down the last of the cottonwood trees activists had occupied for over 70 days. Activists say at least 12 people were arrested; CBP says all four marked trees are now removed.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Border Patrol agents raided a protest camp in Lochiel, in southeast Arizona, on Monday 5 October, and contractors then cut down the last standing cottonwood tree for a double border wall. Inside Climate NewsLC “Armed Border Patrol agents raided a protest camp in Lochiel, in southeast Arizona, making way for contractors to cut down the last standing cottonwood tree Monday morning for a double border wall” Read at Inside Climate News ↗ NewsweekN “Border Patrol agents raided a camp in southern Arizona and crews cut down a centuries-old cottonwood tree activists had been occupying” Read at Newsweek ↗ Mixed · 2Protesters called it the "grandmother tree". It was hundreds of years old and stood in the San Rafael Valley, about 25 miles east of Nogales, on the edge of private property along Border Road, a dirt road running along the U.S.-Mexico border. Inside Climate NewsLC “Dubbed the “grandmother tree,” the cottonwood cut down Monday was hundreds of years old.” Read at Inside Climate News ↗ NewsweekN “The tree, known by protesters as the “grandmother tree,” stood near Lochiel in the San Rafael Valley” Read at Newsweek ↗ Mixed · 2Activists said at least 12 people had been arrested as of 8 a.m. during the raid, and that agents ignored demands for a warrant, entered private property and destroyed tents, according to activist groups' news releases cited by Inside Climate News. Newsweek, citing the Washington Post, reported only that activist groups said multiple people were arrested. Inside Climate NewsLC “Activists in Lochiel said at least 12 people had been arrested as of 8 a.m. during the ongoing raid.” Read at Inside Climate News ↗ NewsweekN “According to the Washington Post, activist groups said multiple people were arrested during the operation on Monday.” Read at Newsweek ↗
Left · 1Videos posted on Instagram show Border Patrol agents with their faces covered beginning arrests around 6:30 a.m. In the footage, people can be heard warning agents they were pushing protesters into barbed wire. Another video shows the tree falling as onlookers scream and cry. Inside Climate NewsLC “Border Patrol agents with their faces covered began to arrest protesters, videos posted on Instagram show.”“Another video shot from a distance shows the giant tree falling over as people scream and cry.” Read at Inside Climate News ↗ Mixed · 2U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) told Arizona Luminaria that it has now removed all four cottonwood trees on federal land in Lochiel that were marked for removal. It said it recognizes the importance of protecting the environment, wildlife and cultural resources, but that illegal immigration itself poses significant environmental challenges, including trash, pollution and habitat damage. Inside Climate NewsLC “it has now removed all four cottonwood trees on federal land in Lochiel that were marked for removal.” Read at Inside Climate News ↗ NewsweekN “illegal immigration itself poses significant environmental challenges.” Read at Newsweek ↗ Left · 1CBP did not answer questions about how many protesters were arrested or what charges they face. Inside Climate NewsLC “CBP did not answer additional questions from Arizona Luminaria about how many protesters were arrested or what charges they face.” Read at Inside Climate News ↗
Left · 1Three other cottonwoods had been cut down in June. Activists then set up a tree-sit, with at least one person in the tree at all times, and camped on private property just north of it for 71 days. Kate Scott, co-founder of the Madrean Archipelago Wildlife Center, said she first noticed contractors cutting the trees this summer and organised support. With Indigenous activists, the group held a sunrise prayer each morning, and the raid happened during that ceremony, Scott said. Inside Climate NewsLC “After three cottonwoods were cut down in June, activists set up a tree-sit in an attempt to protect the last remaining grandmother tree.”“It was during that prayer ceremony that Border Patrol agents raided the camp on Monday.” Read at Inside Climate News ↗ Left · 1Earlier, on 14 September, three protesters in bird and jaguar costumes, representing endangered local species, were arrested after entering the construction site. Scott said this drew more people from across the country to the camp. Activists in Mexico also held a solidarity tree-sit for about a week. Inside Climate NewsLC “On Sept. 14, three protesters wearing bird and jaguar costumes, representing the endangered species in the area, were arrested after entering the construction site.”“For about a week, activists in Mexico held their own tree sit in solidarity with U.S. protesters.” Read at Inside Climate News ↗ Mixed · 2Newsweek described the protest as against President Donald Trump's border wall and noted that footage shows the tree stood just metres from the incomplete wall. Inside Climate News reported that two rows of 30-foot border panels end about a quarter mile east of where the tree stood. Newsweek labelled its report a developing story. NewsweekN “A months-long protest against President Donald Trump’s border wall ended Monday”“It shows the tree was just meters away from the incomplete border wall.” Read at Newsweek ↗ Inside Climate NewsLC “About a quarter mile east of where the tree once stood, two rows of 30-foot tall border panels on either side of the road came to a sudden stop.” Read at Inside Climate News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Detailed, sympathetic on-the-ground account (AZ Luminaria republished by Inside Climate News) of a long protest ending in a raid, told through activists' accounts, videos and the camp's history.
- Emphasis
- Armed, masked agents, alleged ignoring of warrant demands, barbed wire, Indigenous prayer ritual, ecological and cultural loss, camp life and the fallen trees.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Offers little from authorities beyond CBP's statement; CBP's lack of answers is noted.
- Charged language
- “Armed Border Patrol agents”“raided”“grandmother tree”“graveyard of grandmothers”
- For example
-
“Armed Border Patrol agents raided a protest camp in Lochiel, in southeast Arizona” — Inside Climate News
“Border Patrol agents ignored demands for a warrant as they entered the private property and destroyed tents” — Inside Climate News
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- Short, quickly published report framing the event as the end of a protest against President Trump's border wall and a clash between activists and agents.
- Emphasis
- The scale of the protest (70+ days), the tree's age, and the CBP statement.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Omits the number of arrests, the warrant and tent allegations, the arrest videos and background such as the September costume arrests.
- Charged language
- “Clash With Agents”“raided”
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Border Patrol agents raided a protest camp in Lochiel, Arizona, on Monday 5 October.
- Contractors cut down the last 'grandmother' cottonwood, which activists had occupied for more than 70 days.
- Three nearby cottonwoods had been removed earlier, in June.
- CBP says all four marked cottonwoods in Lochiel are now removed.
- Activist groups say people were arrested.
Where accounts differ
-
Number of arrests and charges
- Left
- Activists said at least 12 people were arrested as of 8 a.m.; CBP did not say how many or what charges.
- Centre
- Reports only that activist groups said multiple people were arrested, citing the Washington Post.
-
Conduct of the raid
- Left
- Activist news releases say agents ignored demands for a warrant, entered private property and destroyed tents; videos show protesters saying they were pushed into barbed wire. CBP did not answer questions beyond its statement.
- Centre
- Says activists 'clash' with agents and that footage shows agents standing close to the tree; does not report the warrant or tent allegations.
U.S. Border Patrol organisation
Through CBP, says it removed all four marked cottonwoods on federal land in Lochiel, says it recognizes the importance of protecting the environment, and argues illegal immigration itself harms the environment. It did not say how many were arrested or on what charges.
“CBP recognizes the importance of protecting the environment, wildlife, and cultural resources during border wall construction” — Inside Climate News
“CBP did not answer additional questions from Arizona Luminaria about how many protesters were arrested or what charges they face.” — Inside Climate News
Lochiel, Arizona place
Lochiel, a remote ranching town, is the site of the protest camp, the felled trees and the double border wall construction.
“It’s a remote ranching town between Nogales and Bisbee, south of Sonoita.” — Inside Climate News
Left1 article
-
Final “Grandmother” Cottonwood Toppled, Protesters Arrested in Arizona
Sympathetic Detailed account foregrounding activists' testimony and the tree's ecological and cultural significance, with CBP's statement and non-response included.

Centre1 article
-
'Grandmother Tree' Toppled for Border Wall as Activists Clash With Agents
Neutral Brief developing-story report presenting the felling as the end of a protest against Trump's border wall, relaying activist and CBP statements.

Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 5 Oct 22:14 First Inside Climate NewsLC Final “Grandmother” Cottonwood Toppled, Protesters Arrested in Arizona
- 6 Oct 11:56 +13h 41m NewsweekN 'Grandmother Tree' Toppled for Border Wall as Activists Clash With Agents
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.