Lundy island, down to record-low water supplies, weighs evacuation unless rain comes
Lundy, the Bristol Channel island off north Devon, is shipping in water and pumping from wildlife ponds after reservoirs fell to 13%. Its managers say they are close to deciding whether to evacuate people and animals.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Lundy, a puffin-rich island in the Bristol Channel off the north Devon coast, is close to being evacuated because its water supplies have dropped to the lowest levels ever recorded. BBC NewsN “the island is on the cusp of being evacuated as water levels drop to the lowest levels ever” Read at BBC News ↗ Daily MirrorL “Lundy Island may have to be evacuated after its water supplies dropped to their lowest ever level.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Centre · 1Derek Green, Lundy's managing director, said there had been no significant rainfall since April and that the island had seen barely 20% of the typical 1.5m (4.92ft) of rain expected by this time of year. BBC NewsN “there had been no significant rainfall since April and it had barely seen 20% of the typical 1.5m (4.92ft) rain” Read at BBC News ↗ Mixed · 2Reservoir levels fell to 13% at their lowest, forcing emergency shipments of water from the mainland to the 28 people who live on the island. BBC NewsN “Reservoir levels dropped to 13% at their lowest, forcing emergency shipments of water from the mainland to the 28 people who live on the island.” Read at BBC News ↗ Daily MirrorL “reservoir levels falling to just 13 per cent” Read at Daily Mirror ↗
Mixed · 2The island, owned by the National Trust and managed by the Landmark Trust, relies on rainwater and boreholes drilled into the granite, and is now pumping water from ponds used by wildlife to a treatment works as a "last resort". That has lifted the reservoir to 23.7% full. BBC NewsN “The island, which is managed by the Landmark Trust, is now pumping water from ponds used by wildlife to a treatment works as a "last resort".” Read at BBC News ↗ Daily MirrorL “which are now at 23.7 per cent full” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Mixed · 2Green said evacuating the animals and people and cancelling all holiday bookings would be unprecedented in Lundy's history, adding: "we're on the cusp of having to make that decision." He said the island faced "real jeopardy" unless it rains very soon. BBC NewsN “we're on the cusp of having to make that decision.” Read at BBC News ↗ Daily MirrorL “We are in real jeopardy here at the moment - unless it rains very, very soon.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Mixed · 2Shipments by the passenger ferry MS Oldenburg (spelled Oldenberg by the BBC) began in August. The first delivery, of about 67,000 litres, was the biggest and cost about £7,000. Since then 4,000 litres have been shipped three times a week, while islanders use 9,000 to 11,000 litres a day. BBC NewsN “The first delivery of about 67,000 litres was the biggest and cost about £7,000, said Green.” Read at BBC News ↗ Daily MirrorL “they have shipped 4,000 litres of water three times a week, with islanders using between 9,000 and 11,000 litres of water a day” Read at Daily Mirror ↗
Centre · 1The BBC reported that the seasonal ferry is due to stop shipping water later this month, and that pond levels have started to fall. It also said BBC meteorologist David Braine expects some rain, but that it would take weeks to replenish groundwater and reservoirs. BBC NewsN “a seasonal passenger ferry that has been shipping water to the island is due to end later this month”“it would take weeks to top up the groundwater and reservoirs the island relied on” Read at BBC News ↗ Mixed · 2Restrictions apply to residents and visitors. Bath plugs have been removed so tourists are not tempted to bathe. The Tavern pub has closed its toilets, and visitors are sent to back-shed toilets that are not on the mains supply and are filled with pond water. Island manager Matt Scantlebury said people shower over buckets and reuse the water to flush toilets. BBC NewsN “People are showering with buckets to catch the water and then using that to flush the toilets” Read at BBC News ↗ Daily MirrorL “the island's pub, The Tavern, had closed its toilets and removed bath plugs to help conserve supplies” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Mixed · 2Delivery is difficult: tanks are offloaded from the ship to a staging post halfway up the hill, and water is pumped by fire hose past a section of track closed by a June landslip. Only a granite track and a handful of vehicles are available. BBC NewsN “a landslip in June closed off part of the track to the tiny village at the top of the island about 400ft above sea level” Read at BBC News ↗ Daily MirrorL “We have to offload the tanks off the ship and we have to bring them up to a staging post halfway up the hill.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗
Mixed · 2Islanders link the shortage to climate change. The BBC reported that Green has worked on Lundy since 2004, said shortages have become more frequent, and said the island also considered closing in September last year when reservoirs hit 33%. The summer followed record late-winter rainfall that had filled most reservoirs by March. Green said forecasters predict an even warmer next year and that the island must enlarge its reservoir and use less water over winter. BBC NewsN “in September last year they also considered shutting the island when reservoir levels hit 33%”“The very dry spring and summer followed record rainfall in the later part of the winter” Read at BBC News ↗ Daily MirrorL “He said the changing climate was more "pronounced on Lundy" and islanders needed to adapt.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- The Daily Mirror gives a shorter version led by the evacuation prospect and the everyday restrictions (toilets closed, baths banned). Much of its detail closely follows the BBC report.
- Emphasis
- Evacuation risk, the pond pumping and the banned baths and closed toilets.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Leaves out the ferry ending this month, the meteorologist's forecast, the earlier near-closure last September and the staff comments on climate in the BBC piece.
- Charged language
- “water crisis”“last chance saloon”
- For example
-
“UK island may be evacuated in water crisis as toilets closed, baths banned” — Daily Mirror
“"We're thinking about having to evacuate – something that hasn't happened in the history of Lundy before.” — Daily Mirror
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- BBC News runs a detailed on-the-ground feature on an island close to closure, built on interviews with Lundy's managers and staff. It puts the shortage in the context of a record hot, dry summer and of climate change.
- Emphasis
- Logistics of shipping and hauling water, the end of the ferry service this month, the weather forecast, and earlier near-closure in September last year.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not quote anyone saying the island is actively 'thinking about' evacuating, but does quote Green saying it is 'on the cusp' of deciding.
- Charged language
- “last chance saloon”“cusp of closure”
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Lundy's reservoir fell to a record-low 13% and has since recovered to 23.7% after pumping from wildlife ponds.
- Water has been shipped from north Devon on the MS Oldenburg since August, with about 28 residents on the island.
- Bath plugs have been removed and the pub's toilets closed to save water.
- Managing director Derek Green says evacuation would be unprecedented and the island is in 'real jeopardy' without rain.
Lundy place
Lundy's managers say they are in 'real jeopardy', are using pond water as a last resort, and are on the cusp of deciding whether to evacuate people and animals. They hope for rain and plan a larger reservoir.
“We're in real jeopardy right now unless it rains very, very soon.” — BBC News
“We've got to learn from this and be better prepared next year in terms of increasing the reservoir here.” — BBC News
Left1 article
-
UK island may be evacuated in water crisis as toilets closed, baths banned
Alarmist Condensed, evacuation-led account stressing the restrictions, drawing on the same quotes as the BBC.

Centre1 article
-
Puffin island on cusp of closure as it runs out of water
Sympathetic Detailed feature giving islanders' voices and the logistics, with a climate-change context.

Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 7 Oct 06:16 First BBC NewsN Puffin island on cusp of closure as it runs out of water
- 7 Oct 13:25 +7h 9m Daily MirrorL UK island may be evacuated in water crisis as toilets closed, baths banned
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.