Skip to content
Bramble

Entertainment

Majidi's 'Midday Meal' wins Best Film at Busan, opening an Oscar route

Iranian director Majid Majidi's 'Midday Meal' won the Best Film award at the Busan International Film Festival, making it eligible for the Oscars' international feature category. At the ceremony Majidi dedicated the prize to the people of Iran.

3 outlets · 2L · 1C · 0R First reported Account updated
Image: Deadline
Image: The Hollywood Reporter
Image: Variety

1 / 3

The story, neutrally told

Mixed · 2Iranian director Majid Majidi's Midday Meal won the Best Film award at the close of the Busan International Film Festival on Thursday 15 October. Centre · 1The win automatically qualifies the film for submission in the Oscars' Best International Feature category. Left · 1The Hollywood Reporter says that under Academy rules Busan's best film winner can be submitted without being selected by its country's Oscar committee. Iran has already chosen Babak Khajehpasha's Land of Angels as its official submission for the 99th Academy Awards, so Midday Meal now has an alternate route.

Left · 1The Hollywood Reporter reports that the seven-member jury, led by Zhang Yimou, called its decision unanimous. It assessed 13 competition titles. Mixed · 2The film follows a school teacher, played by Mohammad Rahimi, in a parched rural village who fights to keep his school open after the death of a benefactor. In The Hollywood Reporter's account, the teacher is Davoud Soulan, a contract teacher in southeastern Iran, and the benefactor's death ends the free lunches that keep his pupils coming. It adds that he turns to increasingly desperate measures, including cross-border fuel smuggling, and that the cast is entirely nonprofessional. Left · 1Accepting the prize, Majidi dedicated it to the people of Iran and condemned the civilian toll of the U.S.-led war on his country. According to The Hollywood Reporter, he said a school in Minab was hit on the first day of the war and 120 students were killed. This is Majidi's own statement and the coverage does not independently verify it.

Mixed · 2Majidi, known for Children of Heaven, made his first trip to Busan for the festival. He said at a press conference that he had nearly declined the invitation because he felt depressed and exhausted by the situation at home. Mixed · 2Other winners were Ibuku by Indonesia's Eddie Cahyono (Special Jury Prize), Taiwan's Lee Yun Chan for To Be Ordinary (Best Director), and Zhou Xun for The First Taste of Loneliness and Japan's Kashun Himeno for Satoko Always (Best Actor). Li Danfeng won the Artistic Contribution award for sound. Birds in the Dark by India's Shashank Walia won the New Currents Award, and Beach Fictions by Korea's Lim Hayeon received a special mention. Mixed · 2Organisers reported attendance of more than 200,000 across the festival, its highest since 2015, with another 77,000 at programme and special events. They linked the growth to a new opening date and an expanded screening programme. The Asian Contents & Film Market (10-13 October) drew 30,484 participants and 339 companies from 32 countries.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left2 outlets

Framing
The Hollywood Reporter covers the win as a political and artistic moment. It leads with Majidi's dedication to the people of Iran and gives space to his speech on the war.
Emphasis
Majidi's speech and press-conference remarks, the jury's unanimous decision, the plot, Majidi's earlier work, and the Oscar route.
Leaves out or plays down
Does not cover the festival's market deals, such as the Korea-Japan content fund, that Deadline reports.
Charged language
“still resisting oppression”
For example
“Majidi dedicated his victory to the people of Iran and used portions of his speech to condemn the civilian toll of the U.S.-led war on his country.” — The Hollywood Reporter

Centre1 outlet

Framing
Deadline gives a brisk trade-press account of the result, the Oscar qualification and the other winners, followed by festival business figures.
Emphasis
Oscar eligibility, the list of winners, attendance and market statistics, and the Korea-Japan content fund.
Leaves out or plays down
Does not mention Majidi's speech about the war, the jury's makeup or the Iranian Oscar submission.
For example
“Korean content investment firm Solaire Partners and Japanese entertainment finance company Questry Co signed a memorandum of understanding to create a joint Korea-Japan content fund worth $75m (KRW100BN).” — Deadline

Right0 outlets

No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Ask about this story

Loading…