Skip to content
Bramble

World

Malaysia begins returning Myanmar nationals despite UN and rights groups' warnings

Malaysia deported about 1,500 Myanmar nationals on 29 September, the first phase of a plan for up to 5,000. Malaysia calls it voluntary; the UN and rights groups object, and outlets differ on whether the returnees are Rohingya.

5 outlets · 2L · 3C · 0R First reported Account updated

Updated (version 3). Rewritten with the latest reporting.

Image: Deutsche Welle
Image: Al Jazeera
Image: CNA

1 / 3

The story, neutrally told

Malaysia began repatriating Myanmar nationals on 29 September, with a first group of about 1,500 people, despite objections from the UN and rights groups. Human rights groups say some 5,000 returnees could face violence, persecution and forced conscription. Malaysia says the programme is strictly voluntary and coordinated with Myanmar's government.

Critics, including human rights groups, accuse Malaysia of forcible deportation, a charge the government denies, and say it breaks international law by sending refugees where they risk prosecution or torture. The BBC and CNA report that the UN refugee agency UNHCR has been denied access to detained returnees, so it cannot assess whether they chose to return. Al Jazeera describes those being sent back as Rohingya, a Muslim minority Malaysia once sheltered, while the BBC has said it is unclear whether Rohingya were in the first batch.

DW says Malaysia faces an uptick in anti-migrant sentiment, which coverage links to the decision.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on.

Left2 outlets

Framing
Al Jazeera and the NYT frame it as a persecuted minority or vulnerable migrants being sent back to danger.
Emphasis
Rohingya experience, safety risks, accusations of forced deportation.
Leaves out or plays down
Little on doubt over whether Rohingya were in the first group or on UNHCR access.
Charged language
“The Migrants Being Shipped Back to a War Zone”
For example
“Critics say it is putting their lives at risk.” — The New York Times
“thousands of Rohingya refugees are being sent back to a nation still plagued by violence” — Al Jazeera

Centre3 outlets

Framing
DW, BBC and CNA report a contested repatriation, centred on UN warnings and whether it is voluntary.
Emphasis
UN and rights group objections, verification of consent, political pressure in Malaysia.
Leaves out or plays down
DW and CNA give less on the documentation of Rohingya.
Charged language
“controversial”
For example
“Human rights groups say some 5,000 returnees could face violence, persecution and forced conscription.” — BBC News
“despite objections from the United Nations and dozens ‌of human rights groups.” — CNA

Right0 outlets

No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.