Mamdani and Council Speaker Menin agree on bill to ban NYC horse-drawn carriages from June 2028
Mayor Zohran Mamdani and City Council Speaker Julie Menin have agreed on legislation that would make horse-drawn carriages illegal in New York City from June 2028. A Council vote is expected October 22.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Mayor Zohran Mamdani and City Council Speaker Julie Menin have struck a deal on legislation that would make operating horse-drawn carriages illegal in New York City's five boroughs from June 2028. New York PostR “which would make horse drawn carriages illegal to operate in the five boroughs beginning June 2028” Read at New York Post ↗ NewsweekN “would make it illegal to operate horse-drawn carriages beginning in June 2028, according to a report by Politico” Read at Newsweek ↗ Mixed · 2Menin told Politico on Tuesday, October 13, that the Council would vote on the bill the following week, calling the carriage tradition "a growing public safety liability" in an increasingly busy Central Park; Newsweek puts the expected vote at October 22. New York PostR “this tradition has become a growing public safety liability” Read at New York Post ↗ NewsweekN “The City Council is expected to vote on the measure October 22.” Read at Newsweek ↗ Mixed · 2Newsweek reports that Mamdani confirmed his support in a post on X, writing that "The horse carriage industry is coming to an end in New York City," and promising to protect workers and owners and keep the horses safe. The New York Post said a Mamdani spokesperson had not immediately responded to its request for comment. NewsweekN “"The horse carriage industry is coming to an end in New York City."” Read at Newsweek ↗ New York PostR “A spokesperson for Mamdani did not immediately respond to The Post’s request for comment.” Read at New York Post ↗
Centre · 1According to Politico, as relayed by Newsweek, Mamdani backed this version after added labor protections. The bill would create a workforce transition program with career counseling and job referrals, and it asks the city to consider compensation for carriage businesses, equipment, licenses and horses. NewsweekN “Mamdani agreed to support the latest version of the legislation after additional labor protections were added for carriage drivers and business owners, according to Politico.”“The legislation also calls on the city to consider compensation programs covering the value of carriage businesses, equipment, licenses and horses.” Read at Newsweek ↗ Centre · 1The bill also requires horses sold during the phaseout to be sold humanely and restricts sales for slaughter. NewsweekN “Horse owners who sell animals during the phaseout period would be required to do so in a humane manner, and the bill contains restrictions intended to prevent horses from being sold for slaughter.” Read at Newsweek ↗ Mixed · 2Safety concerns grew this summer. In June, a 16-year-old carriage horse named Deniz died in Central Park, and a Cornell necropsy found Japanese yew poisoning, though how it happened was debated. Days later, 18-year-old tourist Romanch Mahajan died after a carriage accident in Central Park; the Post says a spooked horse threw him, while Newsweek says a horse bolted and a carriage overturned. NewsweekN “a 16-year-old carriage horse named Deniz collapsed and died while pulling a carriage in Central Park”“Officials and union representatives said a horse bolted, causing a carriage to overturn.” Read at Newsweek ↗ New York PostR “was thrown to his death after a horse got spooked on his ride during a freak accident” Read at New York Post ↗
Centre · 1The legislation was later renamed "Romanch's Law" in Mahajan's honor, and it traces back to Ryder's Law, introduced after a carriage horse died in Manhattan in 2022. Earlier bans promised or backed by Mayors Bill de Blasio and Eric Adams never succeeded. NewsweekN “The legislation was later renamed "Romanch's Law" in Mahajan's honor.”“Former Mayor Bill de Blasio campaigned on ending the industry during his successful 2013 mayoral run but never succeeded in implementing a ban.” Read at Newsweek ↗ Centre · 1Julie Cappiello of Voters For Animal Rights welcomed the deal. Opponents, including drivers and labor groups, say the industry is heavily regulated and part of the city's history. Transport Workers Union Local 264, which represents drivers, has opposed past bans, and Newsweek had asked it for comment. NewsweekN “I have worked on this issue for nearly 15 years, and I am thrilled that we now have a path forward”“Transport Workers Union Local 264, which represents carriage drivers, has been among the most vocal opponents of previous efforts to ban the industry.” Read at Newsweek ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- Explainer on why the ban is advancing, covering incidents, the history of failed bans, and the bill's contents.
- Emphasis
- Animal-welfare advocates' win, worker transition and compensation provisions, and the earlier de Blasio and Adams attempts.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Union and driver views were not yet obtained; the article describes opponents only in general terms.
- Charged language
- “major victory for animal welfare advocates”“biggest breakthrough yet”
- For example
-
“The move represents a major victory for animal welfare advocates” — Newsweek
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Short breaking-news item on the deal, presented as the end of a centuries-old tradition, with Menin's public-safety rationale and the tourist's death.
- Emphasis
- Safety liability, the date of the ban and the tourist's death.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Omits labor protections, compensation provisions, the vote date, and views from drivers, unions or advocates.
- Charged language
- “centuries-old practice”“freak accident”
- For example
-
“The move would end a centuries-old practice and Central Park tradition that has recently drawn scrutiny over safety concerns.” — New York Post
What every side reports
- Mamdani and Council Speaker Julie Menin reached a deal on a bill banning horse-drawn carriages from June 2028.
- Menin gave the news to Politico on Tuesday, October 13.
- Romanch Mahajan, 18, died after a carriage accident in Central Park this summer.
Where accounts differ
-
How Mahajan died
- Centre
- Newsweek says officials and union representatives said a horse bolted and the carriage overturned.
- Right
- The Post says a horse got spooked and he was thrown to his death in a freak accident.
-
Mamdani's public position
- Centre
- Newsweek reports Mamdani confirmed support in a post on X.
- Right
- The Post relays Menin saying the bill has Mamdani's backing; his spokesperson had not responded.
Zohran Mamdani person
Mamdani is reported to support the bill and said the industry is ending while workers and owners are protected and horses kept safe.
“his administration would "make sure workers and owners are protected, and the horses are safe."” — Newsweek
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre1 article
-
Why Zohran Mamdani Aims to Ban NYC's Iconic Horse-Drawn Carriages
Sympathetic Detailed explainer leaning toward the advocates' account, while noting opponents' arguments.
Right1 article
-
NYC Central Park’s horse-drawn carriages to be banned under new Mamdani deal
Neutral Brief report centring on Menin's safety rationale and the tourist's death.
- 13 Oct 20:32 First New York PostR NYC Central Park’s horse-drawn carriages to be banned under new Mamdani deal
- 14 Oct 00:06 +3h 34m NewsweekN Why Zohran Mamdani Aims to Ban NYC's Iconic Horse-Drawn Carriages
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…