Asif Merchant sentenced to 27.5 years over Iran-linked plot to kill Trump
A Brooklyn federal judge sentenced Pakistani man Asif Merchant to 27.5 years for an Iran-linked murder-for-hire plot that could have targeted Donald Trump. Prosecutors had sought life; the defence plans to appeal.
1 / 4
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Asif Merchant, a Pakistani man, was sentenced on Tuesday to 27.5 years in federal prison for attempted terrorism and a murder-for-hire plot that, according to the coverage, was directed by Iran's Revolutionary Guard Corps. CBS NewsLC “was sentenced to 27 1/2 years in federal prison on Tuesday.” Read at CBS News ↗ South China Morning PostN “A Pakistani man was sentenced to more than 27 years in prison Tuesday for plotting to assassinate President Donald Trump” Read at South China Morning Post ↗ Mixed · 2US District Judge Eric Komitee in Brooklyn called it "an exceptionally severe crime" and cited Iran's "overlay of foreign influence" as an aggravating factor. CBS NewsLC “"This was an exceptionally severe crime, an extreme instance of terroristic violence,"” Read at CBS News ↗ New York PostR ““This was an exceptionally serious crime,” US District Judge Eric Komitee said Tuesday” Read at New York Post ↗ Right · 1Prosecutors had urged a life sentence. The judge rejected it, reportedly in part because the plot was stopped early and because of Merchant's calm, respectful conduct in court. New York PostR “The Brooklyn US Attorney’s Office had urged in vain for the judge to impose a life sentence on Merchant.”“because of how early the feds stopped the scheme” Read at New York Post ↗
Mixed · 2Merchant was convicted by a jury in March of one count of attempting an act of terrorism transcending national boundaries and one count of murder for hire. CBS NewsLC “He was charged with one count of attempting to commit an act of terrorism transcending national boundaries and one count of murder for hire.” Read at CBS News ↗ New York PostR “after a jury convicted him of trying to hire hitmen” Read at New York Post ↗ Mixed · 2At trial he testified that he came to the US in April 2024 on tasks including possibly arranging a murder, and named Trump, then-President Joe Biden and Nikki Haley as potential targets. New York PostR “His possible targets were the top three candidates for the presidency at the time — Trump, then-President Joe Biden and former South Carolina Gov. Nikki Haley” Read at New York Post ↗ CBS NewsLC “he testified that former U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley was also a potential target of the plot” Read at CBS News ↗ Mixed · 2The plan unravelled when his US contact turned out to be an FBI confidential source, who introduced him to two men who were undercover FBI agents; Merchant paid each $5,000 as a down payment. CBS NewsLC “ultimately connected Merchant with two alleged hit men who were actually undercover FBI agents. He paid them $5,000 each as down payments” Read at CBS News ↗ New York PostR “giving FBI agents posing as hitmen $5,000 each as an advance payment” Read at New York Post ↗
Mixed · 2Trial evidence included a garment business that prosecutors called a front, with clothing terms as code words, and Facebook posts including an image of Trump with a severed head. His lawyer Christopher Neff called the business real. CBS NewsLC “Merchant's lawyer Christopher Neff disputed that the garment business was a front during sentencing, calling it a real business.” Read at CBS News ↗ New York PostR “a photo of the president with a severed head” Read at New York Post ↗ Left · 1Merchant claimed he acted under duress, fearing harm to relatives in Iran; prosecutors disputed this, and the judge said family concern may have played a part but was not the sole motivation. CBS NewsLC “Merchant claimed that he carried out the plot under duress, out of fear his wife and child in Iran would be harmed”“did not accept the defense's characterization that was the sole motivation behind his actions” Read at CBS News ↗ Mixed · 2An FBI agent testified that Merchant spoke of killing Trump as revenge for the 2020 US drone strike that killed Iranian commander Qassem Soleimani; Iran has denied plotting to kill Trump or other senior US officials. New York PostR “Merchant had talked about killing Trump as revenge for the US drone strike that took out prominent Iranian military leader Qassem Soleimani in 2020” Read at New York Post ↗ CBS NewsLC “Iran has denied plotting to kill Mr. Trump or other high-ranking U.S. officials.” Read at CBS News ↗
Left · 1Neff argued the plot was never likely to succeed, saying Merchant is "an ordinary guy"; the government replied it was "straight out of the IRGC playbook." Neff said the defence will appeal. CBS NewsLC “"Mr. Merchant is simply not the monster that the government would like you to believe," said Neff. "He is an ordinary guy."”“will appeal and are disappointed with the length of the sentence” Read at CBS News ↗ Mixed · 2Merchant was arrested on July 12, 2024, the day before the Butler, Pennsylvania rally shooting; CBS reports he said what happened there was "the same thing he was sent here to do." The trial took place after the US and Israel launched an offensive on Iran. CBS NewsLC “Merchant was arrested on July 12, 2024, the day before the attempted assassination of Mr. Trump in Butler, Pennsylvania.” Read at CBS News ↗ New York PostR “the US and Israeli militaries launching an unprecedented military offensive that killed Iran’s Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei” Read at New York Post ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Straight, detailed court report led by the sentence, the judge's remarks and both sides' arguments.
- Emphasis
- Judge's reasoning on Iran's foreign influence, the defence's appeal plans, and the independence of the judiciary.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Less on Merchant's failed businesses and the strip-club sting detail.
- Charged language
- “extreme instance of terroristic violence”
- For example
-
“"No crimes are more serious than the targeted killing of a U.S. president or other U.S. officials."” — CBS News
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- Brief AFP wire report, carried by SCMP, giving the sentence and Soleimani retaliation motive, attributed to the Department of Justice.
- Emphasis
- Motive of retaliation for Soleimani's killing.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Little detail on trial evidence, the judge's reasoning or the defence's arguments.
- For example
-
“in retaliation for the US killing of Revolutionary Guards commander Qassem Soleimani, the Department of Justice said.” — South China Morning Post
Right2 outlets
- Framing
- Mocking, colourful account of a 'bumbling' failed businessman who dodged a life term.
- Emphasis
- Absurd details: banana business, crude drawing, vape, strip club, Inspector Clouseau line; judge's 'mercy'.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Omits the judge's Iran-as-aggravating-factor remarks and Neff's appeal comments.
- Charged language
- “Bumbling wannabe terrorist”“banana king”“baddie”“harebrained”“FBI rat”“dose of mercy”
- For example
-
“A bumbling wannabe terrorist and failed banana king who hatched a half-baked plot to kill President Trump” — New York Post
What every side reports
- Merchant was sentenced Tuesday to roughly 27.5 years in a Brooklyn federal court.
- Merchant is a Pakistani man tied to Iran who sought to hire hitmen to kill a US politician, including Trump.
- Judge Eric Komitee presided and prosecutors had sought life.
- The hitmen were undercover FBI agents and Merchant paid $5,000 each as an advance.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether Merchant acted under duress
- Left
- CBS: Merchant said he feared for family in Iran; prosecutors said no evidence; judge said it was possible but not the sole motive.
- Centre
- SCMP (AFP) describes only 'alleged ties to Iran'.
- Right
- NY Post: says Iranian operatives "threatened" relatives per his claim, but stresses he knew the plan was unlikely to succeed and portrays him as a vengeful schemer.
-
Whether the plot was a serious threat
- Left
- CBS gives defence argument it was unlikely to succeed and prosecution reply it was 'not farfetched'.
- Centre
- SCMP (AFP) says he plotted to assassinate Trump in retaliation for Soleimani's killing.
- Right
- NY Post portrays it as bumbling and half-baked, while quoting prosecutors that it was 'not a casual plan'.
-
Asif Merchant was sentenced to about 27.5 years in federal prison, short of the life term prosecutors sought.
Reported- Reports 3
- CBS News, South China Morning Post, New York Post
-
Merchant acted on behalf of Iran's Revolutionary Guard Corps in the plot.
Reported- Reports 3
- CBS News, South China Morning Post, New York Post
Asif Merchant person
Through his lawyer, says he is an ordinary man, the plot was unlikely to succeed, he acted under duress over family in Iran, and will appeal.
“"Mr. Merchant is simply not the monster that the government would like you to believe," said Neff.” — CBS News
Iran place
Iran has denied plotting to kill Trump or other senior US officials; the judge called Iran the largest state sponsor of terrorism.
“Iran has denied plotting to kill Mr. Trump or other high-ranking U.S. officials.” — CBS News
Donald Trump person
Named as the main target; coverage reports the plot was revenge for the Soleimani killing and mentions no statement from Trump.
“Merchant had talked about killing Trump as revenge for the US drone strike” — New York Post
Left1 article
-
Man convicted in Iran-backed plot to kill Trump gets 27.5 years in prison
Neutral Detailed courtroom report weighing prosecution and defence arguments and the judge's reasoning.

Centre1 article
-
Pakistani man gets 27 years in US prison for Trump murder plot
Neutral Short AFP wire item reporting the sentence and Soleimani-retaliation motive per the Justice Department.

Right2 articles
-
Bumbling wannabe terrorist and banana king behind NYC plot to kill Trump learns his fate
Dismissive Mocks Merchant as a bumbling failed businessman while noting the judge's leniency.

-
- 17 Nov 22:25 First CBS NewsLC Man convicted in Iran-backed plot to kill Trump gets 27.5 years in prison
- 17 Nov 23:00 +35m New York PostR Bumbling wannabe terrorist and banana king behind NYC plot to kill Trump learns his fate
- 17 Nov 23:08 +43m South China Morning PostN Pakistani man gets 27 years in US prison for Trump murder plot
- 17 Nov 23:39 +1h 14m The Straits TimesRC Pakistani man jailed for 27 years for Trump murder plot via AFP
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…