Man Utd weigh Carrick's future and replacements as side drops into relegation zone
Manchester United's Michael Carrick is under pressure after a 4-4 draw with Aston Villa left the club in the Premier League relegation zone. Reports name Eddie Howe, Julian Nagelsmann and Mauricio Pochettino as possible successors, and a meeting on his future is reportedly booked.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Centre · 1Manchester United head coach Michael Carrick has been under threat of the sack since a run of eight games without a victory, which included a 3-0 home defeat by Bournemouth on 25 October. Evening StandardN “The current United head coach was thought to be on the brink of the sack after a run of eight games without a victory.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Evening StandardN “United hierarchy held talks about Carrick’s future as head coach following the 3-0 defeat at home to Bournemouth on October 25.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Centre · 1According to the Evening Standard, citing reports, Carrick was kept in post and given two games, against Roma and Aston Villa, to save his job, with his situation to be reassessed before the international break. Evening StandardN “it was agreed that Carrick would oversee the Roma and Aston Villa games before his situation would be reassessed prior to the international break.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Evening StandardN “Under-pressure Carrick was given two games to effectively save his job” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Centre · 2United beat Roma 3-2 in the Champions League, then drew 4-4 with Aston Villa at Old Trafford on Sunday 8 November, twice coming back from two goals down, with Joshua Zirkzee and Patrick Dorgu scoring in stoppage time. Evening StandardN “a dramatic come-from-behind 3-2 win over Roma followed by an even more chaotic 4-4 draw with Aston Villa” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Gulf NewsN “Joshua Zirkzee and Patrick Dorgu struck in stoppage time to rescue a point.” Read at Gulf News ↗
Centre · 2The point left United in the bottom three. The Standard said Carrick is the first manager in 40 years to take the club there, and Gulf News said they have eight points from 10 matches, 18th place and one league win. Evening StandardN “Carrick becoming the first manager in 40 years to guide the club into the bottom three of the top flight.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Gulf NewsN “A club sitting in the Premier League relegation zone with just eight points from 10 matches.” Read at Gulf News ↗ Centre · 1Reports cited by the Standard say a meeting on Carrick's future has been booked at Carrington. TEAMtalk reported that director of football Jason Wilcox will make the final decision, but The Athletic's David Ornstein said there is no firm plan if United make a change. Evening StandardN “Director of football Jason Wilcox will now discuss Carrick’s future at the club’s Carrington training ground”“there isn’t a firm plan here at Old Trafford for what to do if they were to make a change.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Centre · 1The Standard names Eddie Howe and Julian Nagelsmann as the leading candidates, with Antonio Conte also considered and Mauricio Pochettino, now the USA manager, a late betting favourite. It reports a split, with Howe preferred by Wilcox and Nagelsmann by head of recruitment Christopher Vivell, though no appointment is confirmed. Evening StandardN “Eddie Howe and Julian Nagelsmann have been considered the leading contenders and remain there but are now joined by USA manager Mauricio Pochettino.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Evening StandardN “Howe is the current preferred candidate of Wilcox, but Nagelsmann is highly regarded by Christopher Vivell” Read at Evening Standard ↗
Centre · 1Other names reported include Unai Emery, whom pundit Richard Dunne said should be United's top target even though he would be surprised if Emery accepted, and Stuttgart's Sebastian Hoeness. The Standard also reports that Didier Deschamps turned down an approach and that Fabian Hurzeler ruled himself out. Evening StandardN “Dunne admits he would be surprised if Emery accepted an offer from Old Trafford” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Evening StandardN “Brighton boss Fabian Hurzeler has ruled himself out of the running” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Evening StandardN “Didier Deschamps, fresh from leaving the France national team setup, has reportedly dismissed an approach.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Centre · 1On 30 October the Standard, citing BBC Sport, reported that Newcastle's compensation for Howe had fallen from a reported £6m to £3m under a contract clause. A later Standard article of 8 November still gave the fee as £6million, so the figure is inconsistent across its coverage. Evening StandardN “they will only have to pay Newcastle a compensation fee of £6million.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Evening StandardN “The initial fee that clubs would need to pay Newcastle to appoint Howe was reportedly £6million, but that is now £3m.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Centre · 1Gulf News, in an opinion column, argues that United's problems go beyond the manager, citing 19 goals conceded in 10 league games, fan protests against the owners and questions over recruitment and decision-making. It says it is hard to see how Carrick can continue if performances stay this poor. Gulf NewsN “United have now conceded 19 goals in just 10 Premier League matches.”“it is becoming increasingly difficult to see how Carrick can continue if performances remain this poor.” Read at Gulf News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre2 outlets
- Framing
- Evening Standard coverage is a rolling, speculative 'will he be sacked, who replaces him' narrative built largely on other outlets' reports and betting odds. Gulf News offers an opinion column saying the problems run deeper than the manager.
- Emphasis
- Shortlists of candidates, the sack decision and its timing around the international break, and boardroom splits. Gulf News stresses defensive failings and ownership.
- Leaves out or plays down
- The Standard does not reconcile its differing figures for Howe's compensation (£3m versus £6m) or its differing names for Wilcox. Gulf News does not report the candidate detail beyond citing the Standard.
- Charged language
- “on the brink of the sack”“barmy game”“crisis has deepened”“Spiky Michael Carrick”“Man United in a coma”
- For example
-
“A new name has stormed into favouritism to become the next Manchester United manager” — Evening Standard
“Manchester United have already booked a meeting to discuss Michael Carrick's future as manager.” — Evening Standard
“There are clearly deeper problems at Manchester United.” — Gulf News
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Carrick's side drew 4-4 with Aston Villa on 8 November after beating Roma in the Champions League.
- United are in the Premier League relegation zone.
- Howe, Nagelsmann and Pochettino are named as possible replacements.
Where accounts differ
-
Compensation Newcastle would receive for Eddie Howe
- Centre
- The Standard on 30 October said it had halved from £6m to £3m; its 8 November article said United would 'only have to pay' £6million.
Michael Carrick person
Carrick is portrayed as having bought time with the Roma win and Villa draw but still on the brink; the Standard says his players are playing for him.
“the second half did prove that the players are playing for Carrick” — Evening Standard
“Neither performance could be considered remotely promising, so the pressure remains on his head.” — Evening Standard
Manchester United organisation
The club is reported (not confirmed by the club in these articles) to have held talks on Carrick, assessed alternatives and booked a decision meeting, with Wilcox said to hold the final say.
“The club have reportedly assessed several potential alternatives” — Evening Standard
Mauricio Pochettino person
Reported as a late betting favourite; he recently signed a new contract with the USMNT but is said to be open to a Premier League return.
“is known to be open to a return to the Premier League.” — Evening Standard
Unai Emery person
Emery is suggested by commentators as a first-choice target, though a move is described as unlikely as he is poised to sign a new deal at Villa.
“a move for Unai Emery appears unlikely with the Spaniard poised to sign a new deal at Villa Park.” — Evening Standard
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre17 articles
-
Manchester United get boost in pursuit of Michael Carrick replacement as 'compensation halved'
Neutral Reports the Howe compensation reportedly halving as a 'boost' for United's search.
-
Manchester United given Unai Emery approval amid new Michael Carrick sack decision
Neutral Uses pundit quotes to present Emery as the ideal target while noting wider club problems.
-
-
Show 13 moreShow fewer
-
-
-
-
-
-
Will Manchester United sack Michael Carrick and who could replace him as manager?
Mixed Live-style explainer on the sack decision, collecting reported candidates and boardroom splits.
-
-
-
-
-
Mixed Frames Pochettino's odds surge as a dramatic late twist.
-
Manchester United book Michael Carrick sack decision meeting
Neutral Reports the booked decision meeting and Ornstein's view that there is no firm plan.
-
Gulf NewsN · · Opinion
Manchester United's 4-4 comeback hides a bigger problem: Pochettino to replace Carrick?
Critical Opinion column arguing the 4-4 draw masks deep defensive and ownership problems, and that a manager change alone won't fix them.
Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 30 Oct 17:25 First Evening StandardN Manchester United get boost in pursuit of Michael Carrick replacement as 'compensation halved'
- 3 Nov 11:55 +90h 30m Evening StandardN Manchester United given Unai Emery approval amid new Michael Carrick sack decision
- 4 Nov 07:31 +110h 6m Evening StandardN Manchester United in agreement over Michael Carrick sack decision after Roma win
- 5 Nov 12:15 +138h 50m Evening StandardN Manchester United 'plan revealed' amid new Michael Carrick sack decision
- 6 Nov 09:31 +160h 6m Evening StandardN Manchester United manager search takes major twist as new Michael Carrick details emerge
- 6 Nov 18:17 +168h 52m Evening StandardN Michael Carrick replacement race takes another twist as key Manchester United figure 'set for exit'
- 7 Nov 09:51 +184h 26m Evening StandardN Manchester United have a new wildcard manager target with Michael Carrick sack decision imminent
- 8 Nov 10:22 +208h 57m Evening StandardN Will Manchester United sack Michael Carrick today and who could replace him?
- 8 Nov 10:53 +209h 28m Evening StandardN Michael Carrick reveals latest on Manchester United future as crisis hits new low
- 8 Nov 17:53 +216h 28m Evening StandardN Will Manchester United sack Michael Carrick and who could replace him as manager?
- 8 Nov 18:30 +217h 6m Evening StandardN Manchester United fans 'in agreement' over Michael Carrick sack decision
- 8 Nov 19:38 +218h 13m Evening StandardN Spiky Michael Carrick reveals latest on Manchester United future in awkward interview
- 8 Nov 19:43 +218h 18m Evening StandardN Watch: Michael Carrick in awkward Sky Sports interview over Manchester United sack decision
- 8 Nov 20:05 +218h 40m Evening StandardN Gary Neville issues Michael Carrick verdict with Manchester United sack decision imminent
- 8 Nov 20:31 +219h 6m Evening StandardN Mauricio Pochettino tipped to be next Manchester United manager ahead of Michael Carrick sack decision
- 8 Nov 21:30 +220h 5m Evening StandardN Manchester United book Michael Carrick sack decision meeting
- 9 Nov 07:10 +229h 45m Gulf NewsN Manchester United's 4-4 comeback hides a bigger problem: Pochettino to replace Carrick? Opinion
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…