Skip to content
Bramble

Sport · Manchester City Premier League financial case verdict

Man City found guilty of Premier League financial breaches; club to appeal, sanction pending

The Premier League said an independent commission found Manchester City guilty of all charges over financial rule breaches from 2009-10 to 2017-18. City say they are innocent and will appeal; sanctions are yet to be decided.

20 outlets · 5L · 9C · 6R First reported Account updated

Updated (version 11). New coverage since the last version from Anadolu Agency, Arab News, CNA, Daily Mail, IJR, Sky News, The National.

Image: Deutsche Welle
Image: Al Jazeera
Image: City A.M.
Image: Gulf News
Image: Daily Mirror
Image: GB News
Image: BBC News
Image: Irish Independent

1 / 8

The story, neutrally told

The Premier League announced on 29 September that an independent commission found Manchester City guilty of all charges relating to serious breaches of its financial rules between 2009-10 and 2017-18. The league said City arranged "sham" contracts with commercial partners, filed misstated accounts and concealed their finances from auditors and regulators, inflating revenues and cutting costs by more than £900m. The BBC, summarising the ruling, said £830.69m of £949.94m in sponsorship income was paid by City's owners rather than sponsors, and that the commission rejected City's explanation that the league misunderstood the deals as "untrue".

City were also found guilty of most charges of failing to cooperate; the BBC said all but one were upheld, and City A.M. put the total at 114 of 115 charges. Premier League chief executive Richard Masters said the club "systematically broke Premier League rules for nearly a decade". City said they are innocent, hold "irrefutable evidence" and will appeal because the opinion contains "clear material errors, of law, principle and fact"; the deadline is 2 October.

Sanctions will be set at a further hearing, and could range from a fine or points deduction to expulsion, which has never happened to a Premier League club. LaLiga president Javier Tebas said the most severe available sanction should be imposed, while acknowledging he did not know the exact regulations. The Independent Football Regulator said the decision "raises serious issues" and it may assess the suitability of owners and directors.

Former manager Pep Guardiola said he is "behind my club", and former City chairman David Bernstein called for the board to stand down. Prime Minister Andy Burnham said he would be "really concerned" if City's owners sold up, noted City contest the findings, and said he would not intervene.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on.

Left5 outlets

Framing
Leads with the verdict and the 'sham' contracts, then fallout: Guardiola's backing, calls for the board to go, Burnham's comments.
Emphasis
Scale of the scheme, City's denial, governance fallout.
Leaves out or plays down
Little on legal arguments for appeal.
Charged language
“explosive verdict”“damning”
For example
“‘Sham’ contracts helped inflate revenues by £900m” — The Guardian

Centre9 outlets

Framing
Detailed explanatory coverage of the ruling, sanctions options and political reaction.
Emphasis
Ruling's content, process, regulator's powers.
Leaves out or plays down
Less on rivals' compensation claims.
Charged language
“con the Premier League”
For example
“The 40-page document makes fascinating reading.” — BBC News
“The independent panel will hold a sanctions hearing” — BBC News

Right6 outlets

Framing
Stresses sanctions, expulsion calls and accountability of City's owners, with some sharper language.
Emphasis
Punishment, compensation claims, owner accountability.
Leaves out or plays down
Less on City's detailed rebuttal.
Charged language
“cheating scheme”“slap on the wrist”“nuclear option”
For example
“Expulsion from the Premier League is the nuclear option and would require the backing of 15 of the division’s 20 clubs” — City A.M.
“The club also received a slap on the wrist for committing multiple breaches of their duty to co-operate with the investigation.” — GB News