Nine reported dead, including two children, in Erie, Pennsylvania home shooting
A gunman killed multiple people at a home on Perry Street in Erie, Pennsylvania, on Friday evening before dying from an apparent self-inflicted gunshot wound. Local reports put the toll at nine; police have not confirmed a figure or a motive.
Updated (version 2). New coverage since the last version from Fox News, The Times of India.
1 / 6
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2A gunman opened fire at a home on the 700 block of Perry Street in Erie, Pennsylvania, at around 5 p.m. on Friday, 9 October, killing multiple people including two children and a pregnant woman. New York PostR “Police responded to reports of a shooting at around 5 p.m. on the 700 block of Perry Street in Erie, Pa.” Read at New York Post ↗ Daily MirrorL “Nine people including a pregnant woman and two young children have died” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Mixed · 2Officers found two women with fatal gunshot wounds outside the house; Newsweek reported that a neighbour told investigators a man had shot the pair before going inside. New York PostR “Two women were found lying in the road outside the house” Read at New York Post ↗ NewsweekN “A neighbor told investigators that a man had shot the pair before going into the house, Lorah said.” Read at Newsweek ↗ Mixed · 2The suspect, reportedly armed with a handgun, barricaded himself inside, prompting a SWAT standoff during which shots were heard; police later entered after securing a warrant and found more victims in different parts of the property. New York PostR “had barricaded himself inside the home and sparked a standoff between himself and a SWAT team” Read at New York Post ↗ NewsweekN “After securing a warrant, police forced their way inside.” Read at Newsweek ↗
Mixed · 2Police Chief Rick Lorah said the suspect was dead from what appeared to be a self-inflicted gunshot wound, and that there was no ongoing threat to the public. NewsweekN ““The suspect is deceased. It appears to be a self-inflicted gunshot wound,” said Lorah.” Read at Newsweek ↗ CBS NewsLC “police have said there is no longer a threat to public safety” Read at CBS News ↗ Mixed · 3Lorah did not confirm the number of dead, saying he could neither confirm nor deny it; reports citing local station Erie News Now put the toll at nine, and Newsweek said it could be at least nine including the shooter, while CBS said it was unclear whether the suspect is counted in that total. New York PostR “Lorah confirmed the shooter was dead but didn’t disclose how many people were killed in the massacre. Erie News Now reported nine people had died.” Read at New York Post ↗ NewsweekN “it could be at least nine, including the shooter” Read at Newsweek ↗ CBS NewsLC “While it remains unclear if the suspect is among those reported in the total number of deaths” Read at CBS News ↗ Mixed · 2Fox News reported that Lorah confirmed to WFXP that two women had been killed but would not confirm the exact number of victims, saying there was a "large loss of life inside that residence and outside that residence"; The Times of India stated that at least nine people died. Fox NewsR “Lorah confirmed to WFXP that two women had been killed, but would not confirm the exact number of victims.” Read at Fox News ↗ The Times of IndiaN “At least nine people, including two children and a pregnant woman, were killed after a gunman opened fire at a home in Erie, Pennsylvania” Read at The Times of India ↗
Mixed · 2Lorah called it one of the most difficult and heartbreaking scenes officers and investigators had encountered, and declined to describe details out of respect for the victims; Newsweek reported he said it was the worst crime scene he had seen in almost three decades in law enforcement. CBS NewsLC “Out of respect for the victims and their loved ones, I will not discuss the specific details of what our officers encountered today.” Read at CBS News ↗ NewsweekN “by far the worst crime scene he had seen in almost three decades of law enforcement” Read at Newsweek ↗ Mixed · 2No motive has been established, the gunman and victims have not been publicly identified, and the relationship between them is unknown; investigators were interviewing relatives and potential witnesses. New York PostR “The relationship between the gunman and victims is not known.” Read at New York Post ↗ NewsweekN “Investigators began interviewing relatives and other potential witnesses” Read at Newsweek ↗ Centre · 1Mayor Daria Devlin called the shooting a “terrible tragedy” and the city said the situation had been contained; police were expected to give an update on Saturday. NewsweekN “Mayor Daria Devlin described the shooting as a “terrible tragedy””“Police were expected to give an update Saturday as the investigation continued.” Read at Newsweek ↗
Right · 1Fox News, citing Fox8 Live, reported that police were called to the home just before 5 p.m. after witnesses saw a person firing a weapon before entering the house; it said Erie police told it the Criminal Investigations Division continues to investigate and that Lorah was expected to give an update on Saturday morning. Fox NewsR “Police responded to a home just before 5 p.m. local time after witnesses reported seeing a person firing a weapon before entering the house, according to a report from Fox8 Live.”“The department's Criminal Investigations Division continues to investigate the shooting.” Read at Fox News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left2 outlets
- Framing
- Leads with the nine-dead toll and the vulnerable victims, relaying police statements; the Mirror states the toll in its headline and as fact.
- Emphasis
- Death toll, pregnant woman and children, chief's quotes.
- Leaves out or plays down
- The Mirror does not note that police have not confirmed the toll.
- Charged language
- “'murder-suicide'”
- For example
-
“Nine people including a pregnant woman and two young children have died” — Daily Mirror
“Nine people, including two children, are reported dead after a mass shooting and an hours-long standoff in Erie.” — CBS News
Centre2 outlets
- Framing
- Cautious, detail-heavy account stressing that police have not confirmed the toll and that the scene stunned officers.
- Emphasis
- Chief's statements, neighbour's account, unconfirmed toll, officer counselling.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the pregnant woman.
- Charged language
- “devastating”
- For example
-
“Police had not publicly confirmed the death toll by late Friday, and Lorah declined to give a precise figure” — Newsweek
Right2 outlets
- Framing
- Breaking-news report framed as a suspected murder-suicide with a 'killer' and a 'massacre', attributing details to Erie News Now.
- Emphasis
- Standoff, victims including pregnant woman and children, gruesome scene.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not include the neighbour's account or the city's statement.
- Charged language
- “killer”“massacre”“gruesome scene”
- For example
-
“Lorah confirmed the shooter was dead but didn’t disclose how many people were killed in the massacre.” — New York Post
What every side reports
- The shooting happened around 5 p.m. Friday on Perry Street in Erie, Pennsylvania.
- The gunman died from an apparent self-inflicted gunshot wound.
- Police Chief Rick Lorah said there is no ongoing threat to the public.
- No motive or relationship between gunman and victims has been established.
Where accounts differ
-
Death toll
- Left
- Daily Mirror and CBS News report nine dead; CBS says it is unclear whether the suspect is included.
- Centre
- Newsweek says police did not confirm a toll and local reports suggest at least nine, including the shooter.
- Right
- New York Post says Lorah did not disclose the number and Erie News Now reported nine dead.
-
Nine people died in the Erie shooting.
Reported- Reports 5
- CBS News, Daily Mirror, Newsweek, The Times of India, New York Post
-
The gunman died from an apparent self-inflicted gunshot wound.
Reported- Reports 6
- CBS News, Daily Mirror, Newsweek, The Times of India, Fox News, New York Post
-
Police have not established a motive or the relationship between the gunman and victims.
Reported- Reports 5
- CBS News, Daily Mirror, Newsweek, The Times of India, New York Post
Daria Devlin person
Mayor of Erie; called it a terrible tragedy and said verified updates would follow.
“Mayor Daria Devlin described the shooting as a “terrible tragedy” and said officials would provide verified updates when they became available.” — Newsweek
Left2 articles
-
Pennsylvania shooting: 9 dead including pregnant woman and children in 'murder-suicide'
Sympathetic Short report stating nine dead, centred on the chief's statements.

-
Multiple people, including 2 children, killed in reported mass shooting in Erie
Neutral Straight report citing affiliate Erie News Now and official statements.

Centre2 articles
-
Multiple Killed in 'Devastating' Pennsylvania Mass Shooting
Neutral Detailed, cautious account stressing what police have and haven't confirmed.

-
Pregnant woman & 2 children among 9 killed in Pennsylvania shooting; gunman dies by suicide
Neutral Wire-style summary leading with the nine dead, pregnant woman and children, relying on Erie News Now and police quotes.

Right2 articles
-
Multiple people, including 2 children, dead in suspected murder-suicide at Pennsylvania home
Alarmist Fast report using 'killer' and 'massacre', relaying Erie News Now.

-
Multiple people killed in Pennsylvania shooting; suspected gunman found dead: report
Neutral Cautious breaking report attributing details to local stations, stressing the chief's remarks and that the toll is unconfirmed; labelled developing.

- 10 Oct 05:26 First New York PostR Multiple people, including 2 children, dead in suspected murder-suicide at Pennsylvania home
- 10 Oct 10:13 +4h 47m Daily MirrorL Pennsylvania shooting: 9 dead including pregnant woman and children in 'murder-suicide'
- 10 Oct 10:40 +5h 14m NewsweekN Multiple Killed in 'Devastating' Pennsylvania Mass Shooting
- 10 Oct 11:37 +6h 11m CBS NewsLC Multiple people, including 2 children, killed in reported mass shooting in Erie
- 10 Oct 13:43 +8h 17m The Times of IndiaN Pregnant woman & 2 children among 9 killed in Pennsylvania shooting; gunman dies by suicide
- 10 Oct 13:57 +8h 31m Fox NewsR Multiple people killed in Pennsylvania shooting; suspected gunman found dead: report
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.