Skip to content
Bramble

US

Natalie Harp's estranged brother says dispute over father's suicide split family

In a Washington Post report, Preston Harp says his family broke apart after his father Bob's 2020 suicide, over how to describe the death. Trump allies criticised the Post's article as an intrusion on a private tragedy.

2 outlets · 2L · 0C · 0R First reported Account updated
Image: Raw Story
Image: The Independent

1 / 2

The story, neutrally told

Left · 2Preston Harp, 38, the estranged brother of White House aide Natalie Harp, told The Washington Post that their family fell apart after their father, Bob Harp, died by suicide in July 2020, and that the siblings have not spoken since. Left · 1According to Preston, the Post reported, Bob Harp died at the family home in Irvine, California, on July 17, 2020, and Preston provided an autopsy report to the paper. Left · 2Preston said the rupture centred on how to describe the death: he said his mother, Jill, and Natalie preferred to keep the cause private and tell people Bob died in his sleep, while he said he would repeat what police had said.

Left · 2He said some relatives were forced to pick sides and accused him of lying, and that he has lost touch with most of his extended family. Left · 1Preston also said his father, a business professor at Biola University, was "not a fan" of Donald Trump and spoke of strain at home as Jill and Natalie grew more supportive of Trump; a family friend told the Post that pandemic isolation weighed on Bob, an extrovert. Left · 2Preston said he recalled his father telling him days before his death, "I'm not doing okay", and described him as seeming distressed the last time they met.

Left · 2Natalie Harp's political rise began in 2019 with a LinkedIn post crediting Trump with saving her life after bone cancer treatment; she later spoke at the 2020 Republican National Convention and worked at One America News before becoming one of Trump's top aides. Left · 2Preston, who moved to Nicaragua and supports the Sandinistas, said his sister found "a new father figure" in Trump; the Independent also reports he called her relationship with the president "unhealthy" after earlier press coverage of her proximity to Trump. Left · 2Natalie and Jill Harp did not respond to the Post's requests for comment, and the White House, according to the reports, did not contest Preston's account but did not make Natalie available or give a statement.

Left · 1The Independent noted that the White House had previously called Natalie "one of the most loyal and hardest-working aides on President Trump's team" and that spokesman Davis Ingle had attacked media coverage of her. Left · 1Trump allies criticised the Post article: Katie Miller, a former DOGE adviser, called it "a one-sided profile" dwelling on a private tragedy and said its implication that family turmoil explains Natalie's loyalty was "baseless"; Trump adviser Alex Bruesewitz called it "really sick"; some critics did not sympathise with Miller.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left2 outlets

Framing
Raw Story relays the Post's reporting through dramatic headlines and then covers the backlash from Trump allies; The Independent gives a longer explanatory profile placing the rift alongside Preston's politics and earlier reporting on Natalie's closeness to Trump.
Emphasis
The family rift, Bob Harp's reported dislike of Trump, Preston's Nicaragua move, and the White House's non-contest of his account.
Leaves out or plays down
Both rely almost entirely on Preston's account via the Post; neither includes a response from Natalie or Jill Harp. Raw Story gives little on Preston's own radicalisation, which the Independent includes.
Charged language
“spills gruesome details”“bombshell story”“anti-Trump family drama exposed by insider”“MAGA furious”
For example
“Natalie Harp's brother spills gruesome details of 'emergency' that 'broke' the family” — Raw Story
“​'Really sick': MAGA furious over 'painful, intimate' bombshell story on Natalie Harp” — Raw Story
“Preston Harp and his sister Natalie, Trump’s devoted White House aide, are both grieving for their father while pursuing very different political paths” — The Independent

Centre0 outlets

No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Right0 outlets

No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Ask about this story

Loading…