Nepal plans to drain four glacial lakes after August floods that killed over 1,400
Nepal will begin design and study work this fiscal year to drain four high-altitude glacial lakes, a project that could take up to six years, after an August glacier collapse and flood killed more than 1,400 people.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
LeftNepal will begin an effort this fiscal year to drain four glacial lakes high in the mountains to reduce flood risks, officials said, after a disaster that killed more than 1,400 people. The HinduLC “Nepal will kick off a high-stakes effort this fiscal year to drain four glacial lakes perched high in the mountains” Read at The Hindu ↗ ABC News (Australia)LC “after a recent disaster that killed more than 1,400” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ LeftThe lakes are Thulagi, Lower Barun, Lumding Tsho and Hongu II, in central and eastern Nepal. Design work and detailed studies will begin in the fiscal year that runs until mid-July 2027, authorities said. ABC News (Australia)LC “targeting the central and eastern lakes of Thulagi, Lower Barun, Lumding Tsho and Hongu II, will begin in the fiscal year that runs until mid-July 2027” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ LeftDraining "through gated structures" will start after a detailed study and could take up to six years, said Sanjeeb Baral, executive director of Nepal's Centre for Hydrology and Water Resources Research. The HinduLC “The work of draining “through gated structures” will start after a detailed study, and could take up to six years to complete, said Sanjeeb Baral” Read at The Hindu ↗ ABC News (Australia)LC “said Sanjeeb Baral, the Centre's executive director” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗
LeftSubash Tuladhar, an expert at the centre overseeing the project, said the aim is to lower the risk of the lakes breaching their natural dams and to reduce downstream flood risk. Canals will drain water into nearby rivers in a regulated way, and workers face health risks from long periods of high-altitude work as well as the danger of sudden flooding. The HinduLC ““Our aim is to lower the risk of the lakes breaching their natural dams and reduce the risk of downstream floods,” said Subash Tuladhar” Read at The Hindu ↗ ABC News (Australia)LC “Canals will drain water into nearby rivers in a regulated way, he said” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ LeftTuladhar said Nepal has the skills and experience for the $50-million project, which is to be funded by the Green Climate Fund, the UNDP and the government. It will also include sensors, a flood forecasting and warning system, and work to build downstream resilience and prepare communities. ABC News (Australia)LC “Nepal had the skills and experience required for the $50-million project to be funded by the Green Climate Fund, the UNDP and the government” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ The HinduLC “It will encompass installation of sensors, a flood forecasting and warning system” Read at The Hindu ↗ LeftThe lakes sit at heights of 4,050m to 5,483m and rank among Nepal's most potentially dangerous, according to a 2020 report by the UNDP and the International Centre for Integrated Mountain Development (ICIMOD). The HinduLC “The lakes, at heights ranging from 4,050 m to 5,483 m (13,280 ft to 18,000 ft), rank among Nepal’s most potentially dangerous” Read at The Hindu ↗
LeftSamjwal Ratna Bajracharya, a retired ICIMOD expert, said lowering the lakes by 3 m would significantly reduce the threat, and that the lakes are growing fast and could burst at any time because of earthquakes, avalanches, climatic conditions or unplanned human activity. Nepal lowered Tsho Rolpa by 3 m in 2000 and Imja, near Mount Everest, about 10 years ago. The HinduLC “Lowering the lakes by 3 m (10 ft) would significantly reduce the threat, said Samjwal Ratna Bajracharya” Read at The Hindu ↗ ABC News (Australia)LC “In similar previous efforts, Nepal lowered by 3 m (10 ft) the level of the central Himalayan glacial lake of Tsho Rolpa by in 2000” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ LeftThe August glacier collapse unleashed landslides and a flash flood in the border region with China. Rescuers are still searching for more than 5,000 missing people. The HinduLC “after August’s glacier collapse unleashed landslides and a flash flood that tore through valleys” Read at The Hindu ↗ ABC News (Australia)LC “Rescuers are still searching for more than 5,000 people missing in the border region with China” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ LeftABC reported that only 112 bodies had been identified and returned to families, that 5,285 people were missing in Nepal including hundreds of foreigners, and that Chinese state media put the toll in China at 43 dead and 519 missing, for a combined toll of nearly 1,500 dead and 5,800 missing. ABC News (Australia)LC “Just 112 bodies have been identified and returned to their families. A further 5,285 people are missing in Nepal, including hundreds of foreigners.”“In China, the toll is 43 dead and 519 missing, according to state media” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗
LeftThe floods devastated a dozen hydroelectric plants, roads, bridges, farms and settlements. Officials have said cash-strapped Nepal would need billions of dollars for early recovery; The Hindu put the figure at nearly $5 billion. The HinduLC “Cash-strapped Nepal would need nearly $5 billion for early recovery, officials have said.” Read at The Hindu ↗ ABC News (Australia)LC “Cash-strapped Nepal would need billions of dollars for early recovery, officials have said.” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ LeftPrime Minister Balendra Shah, 36, told the United Nations last month that the disaster was a warning to the world and blamed climate change despite Nepal's negligible emissions. Nepal has reported about 26 glacial lake outburst flood events in four decades and loses more than 300 lives a year on average to extreme climate events. ABC News (Australia)LC “Prime Minister Balendra Shah, 36, told the United Nations in an impassioned speech last month that blamed climate change despite his country's negligible emissions.” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ The HinduLC “loses more than 300 lives and property worth millions of dollars to extreme climate events annually on average” Read at The Hindu ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split.
Left2 outlets
- Framing
- Both outlets run the same report, which appears to be Reuters copy, as a disaster-response story: Nepal's plan to reduce future flood risk after the August glacier collapse. The attributed expert and official voices are the same in each.
- Emphasis
- ABC adds casualty and identification figures, including 112 bodies identified, 5,285 missing in Nepal and the toll in China. The Hindu adds the nearly $5 billion recovery estimate and a note on how retreating glaciers leave unstable lakes.
- Leaves out or plays down
- ABC gives no recovery cost figure beyond 'billions'. The Hindu leaves out the identification and China casualty figures.
- Charged language
- “high-stakes effort”“impassioned speech”
- For example
-
“Nepal will kick off a high-stakes effort this fiscal year to drain four glacial lakes” — ABC News (Australia)
“Climate scientists say as temperatures rise glaciers in the Himalayas retreat, leaving behind unstable glacial lakes” — The Hindu
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- The August disaster killed more than 1,400 people and more than 5,000 remain missing.
- Four lakes (Thulagi, Lower Barun, Lumding Tsho, Hongu II) are to be drained, with studies starting in the fiscal year to mid-July 2027.
- Draining could take up to six years and the project costs $50 million, funded by the Green Climate Fund, UNDP and the government.
Nepal place
Nepalese officials present the drainage project as a way to cut breach and downstream flood risk. Prime Minister Balendra Shah told the UN the disaster was a warning to the world and blamed climate change.
“Nepal's disaster served as a warning to the world, Prime Minister Balendra Shah, 36, told the United Nations” — ABC News (Australia)
““Our aim is to lower the risk of the lakes breaching their natural dams and reduce the risk of downstream floods,”” — The Hindu
Glacial lake outburst floods topic
Glacial lake outburst floods are described as a recurring threat, with about 26 events in four decades, and the four lakes are described as growing fast and potentially dangerous.
“Nepal, which has reported about 26 Glacial Lake Outburst Flood events in the past four decades” — The Hindu
Left2 articles
-
Nepal plans to drain four glacial lakes after flooding disaster
Neutral Reports the drainage plan with disaster-toll context, including identification difficulties and China's casualties.
-
Nepal plans to drain four glacial lakes after deadly floods
Neutral Reports the drainage plan with climate-science context and a nearly $5 billion recovery estimate.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 2 Oct 15:36 First ABC News (Australia)LC Nepal plans to drain four glacial lakes after flooding disaster
- 2 Oct 19:09 +3h 33m The HinduLC Nepal plans to drain four glacial lakes after deadly floods
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.