Skip to content
Bramble

Science

New megaraptoran dinosaur named from Isle of Wight fossil held since 1924

Researchers have named Invictibellatrix amberina, a tiger-sized predator that lived about 120 million years ago, from a partial braincase kept unstudied at the Natural History Museum since 1924. They say it is the first megaraptoran found in Europe.

4 outlets · 1L · 3C · 0R First reported Account updated
Image: New Scientist
Image: Daily Mirror
Image: Evening Standard
Image: CNA

1 / 4

The story, neutrally told

Centre · 2Researchers have named a new species of predatory dinosaur, Invictibellatrix amberina, from a partial skull found on the Isle of Wight that had gone unstudied in the Natural History Museum for about a century. Centre · 2The fossil, a fragmentary braincase, was acquired by the museum in London in 1924 and was found in the Lower Cretaceous Wessex Formation on the island's south-west coast, in rocks about 120 million years old. Centre · 2The study, published in the journal Royal Society Open Science, was led by Cassius Morrison, described as now at the University of Leeds; the Evening Standard describes the team as led by University College London, and co-author Charlie Scherer is a UCL doctoral student.

Centre · 1The researchers used CT scans to build a 3D model of the fossil and compared it with other dinosaurs; the closest match was the Argentinian megaraptoran Murusraptor, so they place the animal in the Megaraptora, which they say makes it the first megaraptoran found in Europe. Centre · 2The genus name means "unconquered female warrior". Megaraptorans were two-legged theropods with slender heads, lightly built skeletons and long, strong arms with large hand claws, and may be related to tyrannosaurs, though where they sit on the theropod family tree is debated. Centre · 2Size estimates differ between reports: New Scientist and the Evening Standard give a length of 3 to 4 metres, about 1.5 metres tall, with claws 10 to 20 cm long, and New Scientist gives a weight of 200 to 300 kg, while CNA says about 5 metres (16 feet) with the weight of a large tiger.

Centre · 2It is thought to have had feathers and to have hunted small dinosaurs, lizards and mammals; it was not the island's top predator, and CNA says it may have filled a role like that of a hyena today. Centre · 2Morrison said humans would have been about a third of its body weight, making them suitable prey, and that it would have been more dangerous to people than a T. rex, which would have been too massive to bother with something so small. Centre · 2A leading hypothesis holds that megaraptorans originated in Asia and spread through Europe into Africa and then South America, and the researchers say the new species supplies fossil evidence for the European step; New Scientist says the Isle of Wight was then attached to mainland Europe with a subtropical climate.

Centre · 1Jake Kotevski of Monash University told New Scientist that the finding, if the classification holds, would fill a gap in knowledge of the group, but that more fossils are needed to support or reject the hypothesis; he also regretted that the fossil could not be compared in more detail with the earlier Wessex Formation theropod Eotyrannus, whose remains do not overlap with it. Centre · 2The reports differ on the original finder: New Scientist says the fossil was acquired from a Reverend Reginald Hooley, while the Evening Standard credits amateur palaeontologist Reginald Walter Tooley with finding it at the foot of a cliff. The Standard says the research was funded by the Palaeontographical Society, the Royal Society and UK Research and Innovation.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left1 outlet

No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Centre3 outlets

Framing
All three outlets are centre-rated and report the naming as a science discovery story, leading on the century-old fossil and the first European megaraptoran, with Morrison's remark about humans as prey for colour.
Emphasis
New Scientist adds outside expert caution and the Eotyrannus comparison; the Evening Standard stresses the fossil being overlooked and the funders; CNA stresses how megaraptorans hunted compared with T. rex and the evolutionary debate.
Leaves out or plays down
The Evening Standard and CNA do not carry the outside expert's caveat that more fossils are needed. CNA does not mention the Eotyrannus comparison. The reports do not agree on the animal's length or the original finder.
Charged language
“unconquered female warrior”“enigmatic”“ruling queens”
For example
“Meet Invictibellatrix amberina, the unconquered female warrior” — New Scientist
“It is a real mystery that this fossil was overlooked for so long, sitting in a drawer for nearly 100 years.” — Evening Standard
“Isle of Wight fossil sheds light on enigmatic meat-eating dinosaurs” — CNA

Right0 outlets

No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Ask about this story

Loading…