Bill Withers' publisher sues Olivia Dean's label over alleged copying in I've Seen It
Mattie Music Group, which looks after Bill Withers' catalogue, has filed a US copyright lawsuit alleging Olivia Dean's I've Seen It copies Just The Two of Us. It targets her label and publishers, not Dean or her co-writers.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
MixedMattie Music Group, which looks after Bill Withers' back catalogue, has filed a copyright infringement lawsuit in US federal court in Los Angeles alleging that Olivia Dean's song I've Seen It copies Withers' 1981 classic Just The Two of Us. BBC NewsN “accused of copying the melody of Bill Withers' soul classic Just The Two of Us in a legal case filed in California” Read at BBC News ↗ The GuardianLC “a copyright infringement lawsuit filed on Thursday in US federal court in Los Angeles” Read at The Guardian ↗ LeftThe Guardian reports the suit was filed on Thursday 1 October; it says Mattie alleges the song took "substantial" aspects of the original, a 1981 collaboration with Grover Washington Jr. The GuardianLC “Mattie Music Group contended that Dean’s track I’ve Seen It stole “substantial” aspects of Withers’ 1981 collaboration with Grover Washington Jr” Read at The Guardian ↗ MixedThe defendants are Dean's record label Capitol Records, its parent Universal Music Group and her publishing companies. The Guardian names Sony Music Publishing as Dean's publisher and Kobalt Music Publishing America as the publisher of co-writer Max Wolfgang. BBC NewsN “names Dean's record label Capitol Records, parent company Universal Music Group and her publishing companies as the defendants” Read at BBC News ↗ The GuardianLC “Sony Music Publishing and Universal Music Group’s Capitol Records – Dean’s publisher and record label, respectively – were named as defendants by Mattie. So was Kobalt Music Publishing America” Read at The Guardian ↗
MixedDean and her co-writers Bastian Langbæk and Max Wolfgang are not defendants, and the BBC says no damages are sought from them. BBC NewsN “It does not seek damages from the singer herself” Read at BBC News ↗ The GuardianLC “The lawsuit does not list as defendants Dean or her I’ve Seen It collaborators” Read at The Guardian ↗ MixedThe complaint says Mattie hired a musicologist, named by the Guardian as Alexander Stewart, who concluded the works contain "substantial similarities", including repeated copying of the melody. BBC NewsN “He concluded "that the works contain substantial similarities" including the "repeated copying" of the melody” Read at BBC News ↗ The GuardianLC “hired musicologist Alexander Stewart to analyze I’ve Seen It and compare it to Just the Two of Us” Read at The Guardian ↗ LeftThe filing says the shared features are so striking that they point away from coincidence, independent creation or common musical elements. The GuardianLC “support an inference that the similarities did not result from coincidence, independent creation or reliance on common musical elements” Read at The Guardian ↗
MixedThe plaintiff says its representatives reached this view in early August 2026 and sent written notice to each defendant on 17 August, but the song stayed in distribution and use. The GuardianLC “provided “written notice to each defendant identifying the registration, the accused composition and the material musical similarities” on 17 August” Read at The Guardian ↗ BBC NewsN “the music was not pulled from distribution” Read at BBC News ↗ CentreThe suit alleges Dean and her co-writers had a "reasonable opportunity" to hear the original, citing its "extraordinary and sustained" success and decades of radio play. The BBC notes that Mattie would have to prove they had heard it. BBC NewsN “To prove plagiarism, Mattie Music Group would have to prove that Dean and her co-writers had previously heard Withers' original composition.” Read at BBC News ↗ LeftBeyond damages, Mattie seeks an injunction permanently restraining further infringement. The GuardianLC “Beside damages, the lawsuit said it seeks an injunction that permanently would “restrain further ongoing acts of copyright infringement by [the] defendants”.” Read at The Guardian ↗
MixedThe defendants had not responded in court when the articles were published. The BBC contacted them and Dean's representatives for comment; the Guardian says representatives for Dean, Capitol and Kobalt did not immediately respond, and Billboard reported Kobalt declined to comment. BBC NewsN “The defendants have yet to respond to the lawsuit.” Read at BBC News ↗ The GuardianLC “Representatives for Dean, Capitol Records and Kobalt did not immediately respond to requests for comment from the Guardian on Friday.” Read at The Guardian ↗ CentreI've Seen It closes Dean's 2025 album The Art of Loving. It has about 246 million Spotify streams, against 948 million for Just The Two of Us, according to the BBC. BBC NewsN “It is has been streamed on Spotify about 246 million times, while Just The Two of Us has racked up 948 million plays.” Read at BBC News ↗ MixedDean, 27, won best new artist at this year's Grammys, and The Art of Loving reached number one in the UK and number three in the US. Withers' track reached number two in the US in 1981 and won the Grammy for best R&B song. Withers died in March 2020, and Mattie Music Group, run by his widow Marcia Johnson, administers his estate. BBC NewsN “Withers' track went to number two in the US charts in 1981 and earned him a Grammy for best R&B song.” Read at BBC News ↗ The GuardianLC “run by his widow, Marcia Johnson.” Read at The Guardian ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- The Guardian leads with the plagiarism accusation, quoting the complaint at length, including the plaintiff's "obvious and inescapable conclusion".
- Emphasis
- Detail from the filing: named musicologist, 17 August notice, the injunction sought, all defendants including Sony and Kobalt, and the chart and awards records of both artists.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the Spotify stream comparison or that the plaintiff must prove the writers heard the original.
- Charged language
- “plagiarism”“stole”
- For example
-
““obvious and inescapable conclusion that I’ve Seen It copied in large and significant part” — The Guardian
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- The BBC reports the accusation as a legal case, noting what the plaintiff must prove and that the defendants have yet to respond.
- Emphasis
- The legal burden of showing the writers had heard the original, the stream comparison, and background on the song and Dean's career.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not name the musicologist or the court's city, and does not mention the injunction sought or the 17 August notice date.
- Charged language
- “accused of copying”
- For example
-
“To prove plagiarism, Mattie Music Group would have to prove that Dean and her co-writers had previously heard Withers' original composition.” — BBC News
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- The lawsuit was filed in a US court in California and concerns Dean's I've Seen It and Withers' Just The Two of Us.
- Dean and her co-writers are not named as defendants.
- Capitol Records and Universal Music Group are among the defendants.
- Mattie Music Group relies on a musicologist's analysis finding substantial similarities.
- The defendants had not publicly responded when the articles were published.
Mattie Music Group organisation
Says I've Seen It copied Just The Two of Us, relying on a musicologist, and says it gave notice in August without the song being withdrawn.
“obvious and inescapable conclusion” — The Guardian
“the music was not pulled from distribution” — BBC News
Olivia Dean person
Not a defendant. Her representatives had not responded to requests for comment when the articles were published.
“Representatives for Dean, Capitol Records and Kobalt did not immediately respond” — The Guardian
Bill Withers person
Withers, who died in 2020, is the author of the original song, whose catalogue is administered by Mattie.
“Mattie Music Group administers Withers’ estate” — The Guardian
Left1 article
-
Olivia Dean accused of plagiarism on her I’ve Seen It track
Neutral Detailed, complaint-driven report that attributes the allegations to Mattie's filing and notes the lack of comment from the defendants.
Centre1 article
-
Olivia Dean accused of copying Bill Withers' Just The Two of Us
Neutral Measured account of the filing that notes the plaintiff's burden of proof and the absence of any response, with background on the song.
Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 2 Oct 10:51 First BBC NewsN Olivia Dean accused of copying Bill Withers' Just The Two of Us
- 2 Oct 18:25 +7h 34m The GuardianLC Olivia Dean accused of plagiarism on her I’ve Seen It track
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.