Inquest hears parents' concerns over care of Trixie Morvoren, 1, who died at Royal Cornwall Hospital
An inquest in Truro is hearing that one-year-old Trixie Morvoren Cooke died on 29 April last year after falling ill at home in Newquay. Her parents say hospital staff showed no sense of urgency, while consultants say her collapse was unexpected.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2An inquest in Truro has heard that Trixie Morvoren, known as Trixie Mo, died on 29 April last year after she could not be resuscitated at the Royal Cornwall Hospital. Daily MirrorL “She tragically died on April 29 last year after she could not be resuscitated.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Daily ExpressR “Attempts to resuscitate her were unsuccessful.” Read at Daily Express ↗ Mixed · 2She had turned pale and was drifting in and out of consciousness at home in Newquay, a few months short of her second birthday, before being taken to hospital. Daily MirrorL “taken to Royal Cornwall Hospital after turning pale and drifting in and out of consciousness at home in Newquay” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Daily ExpressR “became unwell a few months before her second birthday” Read at Daily Express ↗ Mixed · 2Trixie Mo was born with Down syndrome and a congenital heart defect that needed surgery in Bristol by the time she was six months old. The inquest heard there were complications but she recovered after four days in intensive care. Daily MirrorL “Born with Down syndrome, Trixie Mo was diagnosed with a congenital heart defect that required surgery in Bristol by the time she was six months old” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Daily ExpressR “recovered after four days in intensive care despite complications” Read at Daily Express ↗
Mixed · 2Her mother, Ashleigh Cooke, said she had an en caul or 'veiled' birth, in which a baby is born enclosed in an unruptured amniotic sac. Such births occur in roughly one in 80,000 and are known as 'mermaid births', which inspired her middle name, Morvoren, Cornish for mermaid. Daily MirrorL “En caul births occur in one in roughly 80,000 or births. They are known as 'mermaid births'” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Daily ExpressR “inspiring her middle name Morvoren, which means mermaid in Cornish” Read at Daily Express ↗ Left · 1At the paediatric assessment unit, staff struggled to insert a cannula for blood samples and intravenous treatment, and several attempts were made. Daily MirrorL “staff struggled to insert a cannula so blood samples and intravenous treatment could be administered”“several attempts were made to insert a cannula and take blood” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Left · 1Her parents, Ashleigh and James Cooke, believe ultrasound-guided cannulation should have been used from the start, given her history of difficult cannulation and cardiac problems. The Mirror reports they also felt senior consultants rather than registrars should have cared for her. Daily MirrorL “believe ultrasound-guided cannulation should have taken place from the outset”“senior consultants should have taken care of Trixie Mo rather than her being seen by registrars” Read at Daily Mirror ↗
Mixed · 2Ashleigh Cooke told the inquest that 'everyone seemed very chilled' and that there 'never seemed to be any sense of urgency'. She asked why more effort was not made to give supplementary oxygen, and said a specialist cardiologist should have been involved once 'crackle-like' sounds were heard in her chest. Daily MirrorL “There never seemed to be any sense of urgency.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Daily ExpressR “That's when a specialist cardiologist should have been involved and urgency should have begun” Read at Daily Express ↗ Right · 1James Cooke said he felt excluded and 'very much in the dark', and believed staff spoke to Ashleigh, who was almost eight months pregnant, more as a colleague than as the mother of a seriously ill child. Only the Express reports this. Daily ExpressR “"I felt very much in the dark," he told the hearing.” Read at Daily Express ↗ Mixed · 2Consultant paediatrician Rachel Nicholls said registrars rather than consultants are the cannulation experts because they do it routinely, which is why she asked them. She said ultrasound-guided cannulation is a skill not every nurse or registrar has, and that the Royal Cornwall Hospitals Trust is working to improve this. Daily MirrorL “registrars rather than consultants are the cannulation experts as they do it routinely” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Daily ExpressR “the Royal Cornwall Hospitals Trust is working to improve this” Read at Daily Express ↗
Mixed · 2Dr Nicholls said the crackles could have indicated an infection, and that difficulty cannulating Trixie Mo made it harder to find the cause of her illness and treat it. She said the child was warm and did not seem to be continually deteriorating, and that she was shocked by the collapse. Daily MirrorL “I was not expecting the collapse in health that she suffered.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Daily ExpressR “difficulties cannulating her made it harder to establish the cause and provide treatment” Read at Daily Express ↗ Mixed · 2Consultant paediatrician Veronica Nijloveanu, who took over later that day, called the death an 'extremely rare scenario'. She said resuscitation processes were followed thoroughly and added: 'We don't understand what happened.' Consultant paediatrician Katy Huxstep said communication with patients and parents about treatment and procedures needs to improve. Daily MirrorL “We don't understand what happened.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Daily ExpressR “said communication with patients and parents about treatment and procedures should be improved” Read at Daily Express ↗ Mixed · 2The inquest is expected to conclude on Wednesday 7 October, so no finding on the cause of death has been reported. Daily ExpressR “The inquest is expected to conclude on Wednesday, October 7.” Read at Daily Express ↗ Daily MirrorL “The inquest is expected to conclude on Wednesday.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- A bereaved-family story that leads with the child's sudden decline and the mermaid-birth detail, then sets the parents' complaints beside the consultants' evidence.
- Emphasis
- Clinical detail of the cannulation difficulty, the consultants' testimony and the Trust's improvement work, plus a long tribute from the mother.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not include James Cooke's account of feeling excluded.
- Charged language
- “tragically dies”
- For example
-
“Baby girl, 1, turns pale and tragically dies in Cornwall after 'mermaid birth'” — Daily Mirror
“Rachel Nicholls, the consultant paediatrician who looked after Trixie Mo, told the hearing how registrars rather than consultants are the cannulation experts” — Daily Mirror
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- A family-grief story that leads with the parents' complaint of 'no sense of urgency' and adds an emotional angle on the mother's fear.
- Emphasis
- The parents' perspective, including James Cooke feeling excluded, and the mother fearing her daughter would die in her arms.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the Mirror's detail that the parents felt senior consultants rather than registrars should have treated her.
- Charged language
- “heartbroken parents”“tragically dies”
- For example
-
“The heartbroken parents of a little girl born in an extremely rare "mermaid birth"” — Daily Express
“Her mum Ashleigh Cooke feared she would die in her arms.” — Daily Express
What every side reports
- Trixie Morvoren died on 29 April last year after being taken to the Royal Cornwall Hospital from Newquay.
- She had Down syndrome and a congenital heart defect and had heart surgery in Bristol as a baby.
- Her parents told the inquest they felt there was no sense of urgency and that ultrasound-guided cannulation should have been used.
- Consultants said registrars are the cannulation experts and that the Trust is working to improve ultrasound-guided cannulation.
- The inquest is expected to conclude on Wednesday 7 October.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether hospital care showed sufficient urgency and used the right staff and methods
- Left
- The Mirror reports the parents' view that ultrasound-guided cannulation and senior consultants should have been used, alongside Dr Nicholls's explanation of why registrars did it.
- Centre
- No centre outlet covered the story.
- Right
- The Express reports the same parental concerns and consultant replies, and adds that James Cooke felt excluded and in the dark.
Trixie Morvoren person
Her parents describe a thriving child and say staff seemed casual and slow to act as she deteriorated.
“"She was thriving," Ashleigh said.” — Daily Mirror
“I was baffled that no-one seemed that concerned.” — Daily Express
Royal Cornwall Hospital organisation
Its consultants defended using registrars for cannulation and said the collapse was unexpected and the death 'extremely rare'. They acknowledged the need to improve ultrasound-guided cannulation and communication with parents.
“We don't understand what happened.” — Daily Mirror
“said communication with patients and parents about treatment and procedures should be improved” — Daily Express
Left1 article
-
Baby girl, 1, turns pale and tragically dies in Cornwall after 'mermaid birth'
Sympathetic Sympathetic account that gives the parents' concerns and the doctors' evidence in close detail.

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right1 article
-
Baby girl, 1, turns pale and tragically dies in Cornwall after 'mermaid birth'
Sympathetic Emotive account centred on the parents' grief and their complaint of no urgency, with added detail on the father's exclusion.

- 5 Oct 21:43 First Daily MirrorL Baby girl, 1, turns pale and tragically dies in Cornwall after 'mermaid birth'
- 5 Oct 23:17 +1h 34m Daily ExpressR Baby girl, 1, turns pale and tragically dies in Cornwall after 'mermaid birth'
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.