Pakistan says Mecca pact defence committee will meet in Riyadh over Houthi attacks
Pakistan's foreign minister Ishaq Dar said the Strategic Political Defence Committee of the Mecca Joint Defence Agreement will meet in Riyadh, with Houthi attacks on Saudi Arabia on the agenda. He also said more than six countries want to join the pact.
1 / 3
The story, neutrally told
CentrePakistani foreign minister Ishaq Dar said on Friday 2 October that the Strategic Political Defence Committee under the Mecca Joint Defence Agreement will meet in Riyadh. Anadolu AgencyN “will meet “soon” in the Saudi capital Riyadh.” Read at Anadolu Agency ↗ The Times of IndiaN “Pakistan on Friday said an emergency meeting of the strategic political defence committee under the Mecca Joint Defence Agreement will be held in Riyadh next week” Read at The Times of India ↗ CentreAnadolu Agency said Dar first described the meeting as agreed "in principle" and happening "very soon", and that he later told the daily Dawn it would take place "next week". Anadolu AgencyN “Later, according to the daily Dawn, he said that the meeting would take place “next week”.” Read at Anadolu Agency ↗ CentreThe Times of India, citing Reuters, reported that the agenda would include Houthi attacks in Saudi Arabia and political engagement with the Iran-backed group rather than kinetic action. The Times of IndiaN “Dar said the meeting would discuss pursuing political engagement with the Houthis instead of kinetic action, news agency Reuters reported.” Read at The Times of India ↗
CentreDar said Iranian officials, whom he met in New York, had suggested in "good faith" that the Houthis be engaged politically, and that Iran's president and foreign minister wish the Houthi-Saudi conflict to end. Anadolu AgencyN “they had suggested in “good faith” that the Houthis should be engaged politically.” Read at Anadolu Agency ↗ CentreDar said the Iranians "disassociate themselves from both Houthis as well as Iraqi militia", and that any decision would be taken by all three pact members. Anadolu AgencyN “The Iranians “disassociate themselves from both Houthis as well as Iraqi militia,” Dar said.”“Dar stressed, however, that any decision would be taken by all three members of the pact.” Read at Anadolu Agency ↗ CentreDar said at least six countries want to join the pact, which he called defensive in nature; the Times of India reported he said new requests cannot be entertained until the pact is fully operational, which could take up to a year. Anadolu AgencyN ““At least more than six countries are keen to join the Mecca, which is defensive in nature.”” Read at Anadolu Agency ↗ The Times of IndiaN ““It won't be possible to entertain new requests to join until the pact is fully operational,” he said.” Read at The Times of India ↗
CentrePakistan, Saudi Arabia and Türkiye signed the Mecca Joint Defence Agreement in August (the Times of India gives 7 August), under which an armed attack on one is treated as an attack on all three. The Times of IndiaN “Saudi Arabia, Turkey and Pakistan signed the Mecca Joint Defence Agreement on August 7” Read at The Times of India ↗ Anadolu AgencyN “The agreement stipulates that an attack against any one of the signatory states will be considered an attack against all parties.” Read at Anadolu Agency ↗ CentreThe committee has three members from each country: foreign ministers, defence ministers and chiefs of General Staff. Anadolu AgencyN “the committee has three members from each country – the foreign ministers, defense ministers and chiefs of General Staff.” Read at Anadolu Agency ↗ CentreThe committee first met in Istanbul on 31 August, where members agreed to set up a secretariat in Saudi Arabia and expand military cooperation, according to the Times of India. The Times of IndiaN “met in Istanbul on August 31 for the first meeting of the Strategic Political and Defence Committee, where they agreed to establish a secretariat in Saudi Arabia and expand military cooperation.” Read at The Times of India ↗
CentreThe foreign ministers of Saudi Arabia, Pakistan and Türkiye (Prince Faisal bin Farhan, Dar and Hakan Fidan) met in New York, discussed the Houthi attacks and condemned attacks on Mecca and on civilian and economic facilities in Saudi Arabia, backing Riyadh's right to self-defence under Article 51 of the UN Charter. The Times of IndiaN “The ministers also condemned attacks on Mecca and civilian and economic facilities in Saudi Arabia, while backing Riyadh's right to self-defence under Article 51 of the UN Charter.” Read at The Times of India ↗ CentreThe two outlets date that New York meeting differently: the Times of India says Thursday (1 October), while Anadolu says 24 September. Anadolu also reports the three military chiefs met in Riyadh on 25 September. The Times of IndiaN “after the foreign ministers of the three countries met in New York on Thursday.” Read at The Times of India ↗ Anadolu AgencyN “The three military chiefs met in Riyadh on Sept. 25 for a special meeting, while the foreign ministers met in New York on Sept. 24.” Read at Anadolu Agency ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre2 outlets
- Framing
- Both report Dar's statements. The Times of India leads with the agenda (political engagement with the Houthis) and calls the situation the pact's first major test; Anadolu leads with the committee meeting 'soon' and adds Dar's account of talks with Iran and the pact's expansion.
- Emphasis
- The Times of India stresses the emergency agenda and background on the pact; Anadolu stresses Dar's remarks on Iran and on countries wanting to join.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Anadolu does not mention the Article 51 self-defence statement or the Istanbul meeting; the Times of India does not mention Dar's remarks on Iran's position.
- Charged language
- “emergency”“1st major test”
- For example
-
“The emergency meeting comes after a fresh wave of Houthi attacks on Saudi Arabia, putting the newly signed defence arrangement under an early test.” — The Times of India
“At least 6 nations want to join pact signed by Pakistan, Türkiye and Saudi Arabia in August, says Ishaq Dar” — Anadolu Agency
Right2 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Ishaq Dar said the Strategic Political Defence Committee will meet in Riyadh.
- The pact was signed by Pakistan, Saudi Arabia and Türkiye in August; an attack on one counts as an attack on all.
- Dar said more than six countries want to join the pact.
- The meeting comes amid Houthi attacks on Saudi Arabia.
Where accounts differ
-
Date of the New York foreign ministers' meeting
- Centre
- The Times of India says it was held Thursday (1 October); Anadolu says 24 September.
-
Timing and character of the Riyadh meeting
- Centre
- The Times of India calls it an 'emergency meeting' next week; Anadolu says 'soon', agreed in principle, with Dawn quoting 'next week'.
Ishaq Dar person
Dar says the committee will meet in Riyadh, favours political engagement with the Houthis over kinetic action, says decisions rest with all three members, and calls the pact defensive.
“the meeting would discuss pursuing political engagement with the Houthis instead of kinetic action” — The Times of India
“Dar stressed, however, that any decision would be taken by all three members of the pact.” — Anadolu Agency
Pakistan place
Pakistan presents the pact as defensive and says it will honour it, while holding that new members must wait until it is fully operational.
““as Muslims we have to honor it.”” — Anadolu Agency
“countries seeking to join the agreement would have to wait until the pact becomes fully operational” — The Times of India
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre2 articles
-
'Political engagement with Houthis': Pak reveals agenda of emergency Mecca pact meet
Neutral Agenda-led report relaying Reuters on Dar's remarks, with background on the pact and a 'first major test' angle.
-
Mecca pact strategic political defense committee to meet 'soon': Pakistan's foreign minister
Neutral Reports Dar's remarks, including his account of talks with Iranian officials and the pact's possible expansion.
- 2 Oct 14:03 First The Times of IndiaN 'Political engagement with Houthis': Pak reveals agenda of emergency Mecca pact meet
- 2 Oct 15:13 +1h 10m The Straits TimesRC Pakistan says Mecca pact members to hold emergency talks on engaging Houthis via Reuters
- 2 Oct 15:55 +1h 52m Anadolu AgencyN Mecca pact strategic political defense committee to meet 'soon': Pakistan's foreign minister
- 2 Oct 17:35 +3h 31m Arab NewsRC Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, Türkiye to hold defense pact talks next week amid Houthi attacks
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.