Palm Beach GOP drops charged clerk Mike Caruso from voter guide after backing him
The Palm Beach County Republican Party first listed suspended clerk Mike Caruso, charged with child molestation, in its voter guide, then removed him a day later after criticism from the state party and Gov. Ron DeSantis. Caruso says he is innocent and will stay in the race.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Mike Caruso, the suspended Palm Beach County clerk of courts and comptroller, was arrested on 18 August by the Florida Department of Law Enforcement and has pleaded not guilty to charges including lewd or lascivious molestation, kidnapping and child abuse. Raw StoryL “Caruso has pleaded not guilty to charges including lewd or lascivious molestation, kidnapping, child abuse and luring or enticing a child.” Read at Raw Story ↗ NewsweekN “Caruso, 67, was arrested on August 18 on five felony charges, including kidnapping, child molestation and child abuse.” Read at Newsweek ↗ Left · 1The case centres on allegations by a male relative who was under 5 at the time; at an August hearing prosecutors disclosed that a woman separately alleges Caruso molested her when she was 4. Raw StoryL “At an Aug. 28 hearing, prosecutors disclosed that a second person, a woman, alleges Caruso molested her when she was 4.” Read at Raw Story ↗ Left · 1An Orange County judge released him on $160,000 bail, saying the state's case had weaknesses, though prosecutors objected. Raw StoryL “An Orange County judge released Caruso on $160,000 bail, saying the state's case had weaknesses and might not be proven, but prosecutors objected.” Read at Raw Story ↗
Mixed · 2Gov. Ron DeSantis, who had appointed Caruso a year earlier, suspended him immediately after the arrest; an interim clerk, Shannon Ramsey-Chessman, is serving. Raw StoryL “An interim clerk, Shannon Ramsey-Chessman, is serving now” Read at Raw Story ↗ NewsweekN “DeSantis immediately suspended Caruso from his role as Palm Beach County clerk and comptroller.” Read at Newsweek ↗ Left · 1On Monday 5 October, the Palm Beach County Republican Party listed Caruso in a voter guide posted on Instagram, and county chairman Carl Cascio told the Miami Herald the committee 'has the power and duty' under state law and party rules to campaign for its nominees. Raw StoryL “The county party listed Caruso in a GOP voter guide posted on Instagram Monday, reported the Miami Herald” Read at Raw Story ↗ Raw StoryL “has the power and duty" under state law and local party rules "to conduct campaigns for party nominees."” Read at Raw Story ↗ Left · 1Cascio's public letter noted that Caruso is the county's only Republican constitutional officer and is fighting to clear his name, and said the state party had directed the county to find a replacement candidate, with the elections supervisor delaying ballot printing, but Caruso refused to withdraw. Raw StoryL “Cascio wrote that the state party directed him to pick a replacement candidate after the arrest”“The county elections supervisor even delayed printing ballots to give Republicans time, but Caruso refused to withdraw.” Read at Raw Story ↗
Centre · 1The Republican Party of Florida had said it would not support Caruso if he stayed in the race; its chairman Evan Power said the party had withdrawn support at the arrest, asked the county to name a replacement, and renewed his call for Caruso to withdraw. NewsweekN “Power separately said the state GOP had withdrawn its support for Caruso when he was arrested and had asked local Republicans to select a potential replacement.” Read at Newsweek ↗ Centre · 1On Tuesday 6 October the county party removed Caruso from the guide, reposted on Instagram and X, saying the original had included every Republican nominee and that 'As soon as we were permitted to remove the nominee running for a constitutional office, we did.' NewsweekN ““As soon as we were permitted to remove the nominee running for a constitutional office, we did.”” Read at Newsweek ↗ Centre · 1The change followed criticism from prominent Florida Republicans: DeSantis called the inclusion 'disappointing', writing that 'some things are bigger than party', and Power said he appreciated the county party 'doing the right thing'. NewsweekN “Governor Ron DeSantis called the inclusion “disappointing,” writing on X that “some things are bigger than party.”” Read at Newsweek ↗
Centre · 1Caruso, through spokesperson Jude Engelmeyer, said the county party is entitled to make its own decisions on its guide, but that he maintains his innocence, remains the Republican nominee and intends to stay in the race and take office if elected. NewsweekN ““Mike maintains his innocence, remains the Republican nominee for Palm Beach County clerk and comptroller, and intends to remain in the race through the November election,”” Read at Newsweek ↗ Centre · 1Removing him from the guide does not change his status as nominee: under Section 100.111 of Florida law a county executive committee can designate a replacement only if a vacancy arises, for example by withdrawal, and that has not happened; the county committee had picked Tom Sutterfield as a potential replacement on 25 August. NewsweekN “But that process has not taken effect in Caruso’s race because he has not withdrawn. The Palm Beach GOP said that after his arrest, the state party instructed local officials to prepare to replace him if he withdrew.”“On August 25, the county Republican Executive Committee selected Tom Sutterfield as a potential replacement.” Read at Newsweek ↗ Left · 1Caruso faces Democrat Yvette Drucker, a Boca Raton city council member, in a county that leans Democratic, in the 3 November election; his campaign website is down and he has refunded two donors and a data vendor, though he kept paying his son for outreach. If he won, DeSantis or the next governor could suspend him again. Raw StoryL “Palm Beach County leans Democratic, and Caruso faces Democrat Yvette Drucker, a Boca Raton city council member.” Read at Raw Story ↗ Raw StoryL “If Caruso won, whoever takes office as the next governor could suspend him again.”“Records show he kept paying his son for campaign outreach” Read at Raw Story ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Reports the county GOP standing by Caruso as a rift with the state party, led with the county party's 'duty' claim and a 'civil war' headline.
- Emphasis
- The split between county and state Republicans, Caruso's retreating campaign (website down, refunds), and the second accuser.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not cover the later removal of Caruso from the guide, DeSantis's criticism, or the legal mechanics of replacing a nominee.
- Charged language
- “Republican civil war erupts”“scandal-plagued candidate”
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- Reports the county party's reversal under pressure from the state party and DeSantis, and explains why Caruso remains the nominee.
- Emphasis
- Statements from Evan Power, DeSantis and Caruso's representative, and Florida Statute 100.111 on replacing nominees.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the second accuser, the $160,000 bail or the campaign finance details reported by Raw Story.
- For example
-
“The change means the Palm Beach County GOP is no longer promoting Caruso on its voter guide, putting the local organization in line with the state party’s position.” — Newsweek
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Caruso was arrested on 18 August and has pleaded not guilty or maintained his innocence.
- DeSantis suspended him immediately after the arrest.
- The state GOP withdrew its support and asked the county party to name a replacement, but Caruso refused to withdraw.
- Caruso faces Democrat Yvette Drucker on the 3 November ballot.
Where accounts differ
-
Caruso's age
- Left
- Raw Story gives his age as 68.
- Centre
- Newsweek gives his age as 67.
-
Whether the county GOP is still backing Caruso
- Left
- Raw Story, on Monday, reports the county party standing behind him with a 'duty' to campaign for him.
- Centre
- Newsweek, on Tuesday, reports the county party removed him from its voter guide, in line with the state party.
Mike Caruso person
Says he is innocent, remains the Republican nominee and intends to win and serve; says the voters should decide.
““Ultimately, the decision belongs to the voters.”” — Newsweek
““My name is on the November ballot, and I intend to win this election.”” — Raw Story
Palm Beach County Republican Party organisation
First argued it had a duty to campaign for its nominees, then removed Caruso from its guide, saying it did so as soon as it was permitted.
“has the power and duty" under state law and local party rules "to conduct campaigns for party nominees."” — Raw Story
““As soon as we were permitted to remove the nominee running for a constitutional office, we did.”” — Newsweek
Left2 articles
-
Local GOP insists it has 'duty' to campaign for Republican charged with child molestation
Critical Presents the county GOP as defying the state party by campaigning for a charged candidate, quoting Cascio's 'duty' argument.

-
Republican civil war erupts in red state over backing scandal-plagued candidate
Critical Casts the county party's backing of Caruso as a party 'civil war' while detailing a faltering campaign.

Centre1 article
-
Palm Beach GOP Removes Republican Facing Child Sex Charges From Voter Guide
Neutral Reports the county party's removal of Caruso from the guide after criticism, with statements from all sides and legal context.

Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 5 Oct 15:45 First Raw StoryL Local GOP insists it has 'duty' to campaign for Republican charged with child molestation
- 5 Oct 21:45 +6h Raw StoryL Republican civil war erupts in red state over backing scandal-plagued candidate
- 6 Oct 16:38 +24h 53m NewsweekN Palm Beach GOP Removes Republican Facing Child Sex Charges From Voter Guide
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.