Skip to content
Bramble

US

Penn State Jewish Studies lecture on 'decolonizing' Holocaust museums draws backlash

A Penn State Jewish Studies Program lecture titled "Do We Need to Decolonize Holocaust Museums?" drew online condemnation. The university said it understood the concerns about the title, while the speaker and program director said the talk concerned museum objects and representation.

2 outlets · 0L · 0C · 2R First reported Account updated
Image: New York Post
Image: The Jerusalem Post

1 / 2

The story, neutrally told

Right · 2Penn State's Jewish Studies Program hosted a lecture on Tuesday titled "Do We Need to Decolonize Holocaust Museums?", which drew a wave of online criticism. Right · 1The speaker was Erica Lehrer of Concordia University in Montreal, described as a sociocultural anthropologist, historian and curator. Right · 1An advertisement for the event said Holocaust museums have been "largely exempt from decolonial critiques" and, while not obvious targets for scrutiny, are not free from "entanglements with state power" or from "biases, exclusions, and silences" inherited from museum practice.

Right · 1Commenters on the program's Instagram post and on X called the event "absolutely disgusting," "vile," "abhorrent" and "profoundly disturbing," with some accusing organizers of hijacking Holocaust memory to push a political agenda. Right · 2The group Stop Antisemitism posted the flyer with the comment "These lunatics are now coming after Holocaust Museums." Right · 1Jeff Miller, chairman of the US Holocaust Memorial Council, called it "absolutely disgraceful" that Penn State was hosting the discussion, said the university owed the public an explanation, and said academic freedom must not become an excuse for Holocaust distortion.

Right · 1Lehrer told the Jerusalem Post her questions concern how Holocaust museums might learn from Indigenous approaches to caring for objects so they stay connected to families and communities, and how victims, including Jews and Roma, are sometimes represented in stereotypical ways; she said her own mother's family heirlooms were donated to a Holocaust museum. Right · 1Lehrer said other scholars have raised such questions, citing a panel at the Lessons and Legacies Holocaust conference in Chicago the previous weekend and a forum due next year in Canadian Jewish Studies. Right · 1A Penn State spokesperson said the university condemns all forms of antisemitism, that a speaker's presence is not an endorsement of their views, and that it understood the concerns about the use of 'decolonization' in the title and recognized how hurtful it was to many in the community.

Right · 1Tommaso M. Milani, director of the Jewish Studies Program, said the talk examined how museums care for objects taken from Jewish individuals and communities and their responsibilities when items were never returned to survivors or descendants who asked for them, and that neither the lecture nor the discussion diminished the significance of the Holocaust. Right · 1The Holocaust Awareness Museum and Education Center in Pennsylvania told the Jerusalem Post that 'decolonizing' carries assumptions and can suggest the history presented is incomplete, biased or in need of ideological correction, and stressed the specific targeting of Jews for total annihilation. Right · 1The New York Post said it had asked Lehrer, Penn State and the Jewish Studies Program for comment and had not heard back by publication.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left0 outlets

No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Centre0 outlets

No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Right2 outlets

Framing
Both outlets lead with the online backlash. The New York Post centres social media outrage and gives no response from the university or speaker; the Jerusalem Post adds the speaker's, Penn State's and the program director's responses plus comment from a Pennsylvania Holocaust museum.
Emphasis
Condemnation from alumni, the daughter of survivors, Stop Antisemitism and Jeff Miller; the Jerusalem Post also stresses the speaker's explanation and the university's statement.
Leaves out or plays down
The New York Post carries no response from Penn State or Lehrer. Neither outlet quotes a defender of the lecture beyond the university and speaker themselves.
Charged language
“skewered”“slammed”“disgusting and abhorrent”“Lost their minds”“These lunatics are now coming after Holocaust Museums”
For example
“Pennsylvania State University was skewered online for hosting a Jewish studies lecture brazenly titled” — New York Post
“A lecture titled "Do We Need to Decolonize Holocaust Museums?" drew backlash, while its speaker said the discussion focused on artifact ownership and the representation of victims.” — The Jerusalem Post

Ask about this story

Loading…