Pentagon watchdog declines senators' request to probe Starlink throttling in Ukraine
The Defense Department's inspector general turned down a request from nine senators to investigate slowed Starlink and Starshield service in Ukraine, saying the Pentagon itself is better placed to address it. Accounts of who caused the slowdown conflict.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Left · 2The Pentagon's inspector general's office has declined a request from nine senators, four Republicans and five Democrats, to investigate disruptions to Starlink and its military version, Starshield, in Ukraine, according to reporting by the Associated Press. Raw StoryL “The senators, four Republicans and five Democrats, sought the probe after Ukrainian officials said this month” Read at Raw Story ↗ MeduzaLC “declined a request from nine senators to investigate outages in Starlink and its military version, Starshield, in Ukraine” Read at Meduza ↗ Left · 2Raw Story says the response was dated Tuesday and told the senators the Air Force was better positioned to address their concerns; Meduza, citing AP and CNN, says the office said the questions would be better directed to the Air Force and Space Force. Raw StoryL “the watchdog told the nine senators that the Air Force was better positioned to address their concerns” Read at Raw Story ↗ MeduzaLC “the questions would be better directed to the U.S. Air Force and Space Force” Read at Meduza ↗ Left · 1Mollie Halpern, a spokeswoman for the inspector general's office, said the watchdog "carefully considered the congressional request and determined that the matters raised were best addressed by the Department." Raw StoryL “determined that the matters raised were best addressed by the Department.” Read at Raw Story ↗
Left · 2The senators sought the probe after Ukrainian officials said in October that connection speeds had been slowed, which Kyiv said hampered its ability to intercept incoming Russian drones; Meduza adds that connectivity reportedly dropped when drones exceeded 160 kilometres per hour (99 mph). Raw StoryL “Officials in Kyiv said the restrictions hampered their ability to intercept incoming Russian drones.” Read at Raw Story ↗ MeduzaLC “Connectivity dropped when drones exceeded speeds of 160 kilometers per hour (99 mph).” Read at Meduza ↗ Left · 2Sen. Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH), the top Democrat on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee and one of the requesters, said it was "concerning" that the inspector general had apparently decided not to investigate disruptions Ukraine relies on to protect civilians, and called for an independent accounting and review. Raw StoryL “called for "an independent accounting and review to determine responsibility and prevent this from happening in the future."” Read at Raw Story ↗ MeduzaLC “It is concerning that the Inspector General has apparently decided not to investigate satellite communication disruptions” Read at Meduza ↗ Left · 2An anonymous congressional aide told the AP the watchdog was in effect declining to look into Musk and Starlink despite being well placed to do so; Raw Story adds the aide said congressional worries about Musk's control of Starlink go back years and helped lead to the creation of Starshield. Raw StoryL “worries in Congress about Musk's grip on Starlink stretch back years and helped drive the creation of Starshield in the first place” Read at Raw Story ↗ MeduzaLC “despite being well-positioned to do so” Read at Meduza ↗
Left · 2Accounts of the cause conflict. Raw Story reports Musk admitted over the weekend that SpaceX had throttled Starlink in Ukraine, saying Ukraine broke the terms of service (which Ukrainian officials rejected) while insisting Starshield changes were up to the US government; Meduza reports Musk accused the Ukrainian military of using the service for offensive drone strikes. Raw StoryL “Musk admitted over the weekend that SpaceX had throttled Starlink in Ukraine, claiming the country broke the service's terms, a charge Ukrainian officials rejected.” Read at Raw Story ↗ MeduzaLC “saying it had used the service for offensive drone strikes intended to kill people” Read at Meduza ↗ Left · 2President Donald Trump has denied ordering any restriction, and Vice President JD Vance has hinted at coordination between the White House and Musk, per Raw Story; Meduza says The Telegraph, citing four sources, and the Wall Street Journal reported that Musk ordered or proposed the Starshield restrictions. Raw StoryL “President Donald Trump has denied ordering any restriction, while Vice President JD Vance has hinted at coordination between the White House and Musk.” Read at Raw Story ↗ MeduzaLC “The Wall Street Journal also reported that Musk ordered the restrictions on Starshield for Ukraine.” Read at Meduza ↗ Left · 1The Pentagon referred questions to the inspector general's office, and the Air Force did not immediately respond to the AP's request for comment. Raw StoryL “The Pentagon pointed questions to the inspector general's office, and the Air Force did not immediately answer the AP's request for comment.” Read at Raw Story ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left2 outlets
- Framing
- Both outlets, relaying AP, frame the decision as a setback for bipartisan congressional oversight of Musk's role in Ukraine's battlefield communications.
- Emphasis
- Shaheen's concern, the anonymous aide's criticism, and the conflicting accounts from Musk, Trump and others; Raw Story stresses Musk's admission and administration contradictions, Meduza the press reports on Musk's role and his claims about Ukraine's use of drones.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Neither includes a response from the Air Force or Space Force; Meduza omits the inspector general's spokeswoman's quote, and Raw Story omits the Space Force and the WSJ/Telegraph reports.
- Charged language
- “hit a wall”“Musk's grip on Starlink”
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- The Pentagon inspector general's office declined a request from nine senators (four Republicans, five Democrats) to investigate Starlink/Starshield disruptions in Ukraine.
- The office pointed the senators toward the Air Force (Meduza adds Space Force) instead.
- Sen. Jeanne Shaheen criticised the decision.
- Trump has said he did not order restrictions, and Musk accused Ukraine of violating Starlink's terms.
Where accounts differ
-
Who caused the Starlink/Starshield slowdown
- Left
- Raw Story: Musk admitted SpaceX throttled Starlink, blamed Ukraine's breach of terms, and said Starshield was up to the US government; Trump denied ordering it. Meduza: Telegraph and WSJ reported Musk ordered or proposed the Starshield restrictions.
-
Why Musk says service was limited
- Left
- Raw Story: Ukraine broke the service's terms, which Ukrainian officials rejected. Meduza: Musk said Ukraine's military used it for offensive drone strikes.
US Department of Defense organisation
The inspector general's office says it considered the request and concluded the matters are best handled by the Department; the Pentagon referred questions to it.
“determined that the matters raised were best addressed by the Department.” — Raw Story
“The Pentagon pointed questions to the inspector general's office” — Raw Story
Elon Musk person
Musk acknowledged SpaceX throttled Starlink in Ukraine, accusing Ukraine of violating terms of service, and said any Starshield changes were for the US government.
“He insisted, however, that any changes to Starshield were in the hands of the U.S. government.” — Raw Story
“Musk himself accused the Ukrainian military of violating Starlink’s terms of service” — Meduza
Left2 articles
-
Pentagon watchdog refuses to probe Musk’s Starlink slowdown: report
Critical Presents the refusal as a dead end for a bipartisan inquiry and lays out contradictory accounts from Musk, Trump and Vance.
-
MeduzaLC ·
Pentagon watchdog declines to investigate Starlink outages in Ukraine
Neutral Short news brief summarising AP and CNN reporting, adding press reports that Musk ordered the restrictions and his own justification.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 29 Oct 01:42 First Raw StoryL Pentagon watchdog refuses to probe Musk’s Starlink slowdown: report
- 29 Oct 08:24 +6h 43m MeduzaLC Pentagon watchdog declines to investigate Starlink outages in Ukraine
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…