Planet appears to have formed around a white dwarf after its star died
Astronomers led by Jamie Williams of the University of Warwick report in Nature Astronomy a gas giant, HS0209+0832b, that seems to have formed from material shed by a dying star. They call it a "phoenix planet".
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Astronomers report a gas-giant exoplanet, HS0209+0832b, that appears to have formed after its host star died, in a paper published in Nature Astronomy. MetroLC “according to a paper published today in Nature Astronomy” Read at Metro ↗ CNAN “lead author of the study published this week in the journal Nature Astronomy” Read at CNA ↗ Mixed · 2The planet orbits HS0209+0832, a white dwarf, which is the compact remnant left when a star like the sun dies; the team has nicknamed it a "phoenix planet". MetroLC “named after the mythological bird” Read at Metro ↗ CNAN “now orbits the highly compact stellar remnant that was left behind, called a white dwarf” Read at CNA ↗ Mixed · 2Lead author Jamie Williams, a doctoral student at the University of Warwick, said it is the first example of a planet forming around a white dwarf; such second-generation planets had previously been found only around neutron stars such as pulsars. CNAN “"This is the first example of a planet forming around a white dwarf,"” Read at CNA ↗ MetroLC “second-generation planets have been discovered around neutron stars” Read at Metro ↗
Mixed · 2The evidence is chemical: the planet and star appear to share similar chemistry, and the planet is rich in niobium, copper and zinc, elements that dying stars expel. Metro adds that niobium had never before been detected in a white dwarf. CNAN “It is rich in niobium, copper and zinc” Read at CNA ↗ MetroLC “which has never been detected in a white dwarf before” Read at Metro ↗ Mixed · 2The planet is a gas giant, perhaps slightly more massive than Jupiter, with a 4.4-day orbit at about 4 per cent of the Earth–sun distance. CNA reports that the white dwarf's extreme ultraviolet radiation is evaporating its outer atmosphere, with some of that material falling onto the star. CNAN “It orbits the white dwarf every 4.4 days at only 4 per cent the distance between Earth and the sun.” Read at CNA ↗ MetroLC “would be just 4.4 Earth days” Read at Metro ↗ Mixed · 2The researchers used data from the Hubble, TESS and FUSE space telescopes and hope to use the James Webb Space Telescope to confirm their conclusions. Metro says the finding could be the first observational evidence of such a planet, if confirmed. CNAN “The researchers used data from the orbiting Hubble, TESS and FUSE telescopes, and hope to use the James Webb Space Telescope to confirm their conclusions.” Read at CNA ↗ MetroLC “what could be the first observational evidence that new planets can form around white dwarfs” Read at Metro ↗
Left · 1Williams suspects that a companion star spun the white dwarf's leftover layers into a disc, which gravity then clumped into a planet. The planet is too hot for life, at over 1,500°C according to Williams. MetroLC “Over time, gravity clumped some of this celestial junk into a planet.”“This makes life impossible.” Read at Metro ↗ Centre · 1Williams said other second-generation planets, such as rocky ones, could stay in a white dwarf's habitable zone for billions of years, making them candidates in the search for life. More than 95 per cent of Milky Way stars will become white dwarfs, so such planets could outnumber those around pulsars. CNAN “over 95 per cent of stars in the Milky Way will evolve to become a white dwarf”“it could remain in the habitable zone for billions of years” Read at CNA ↗ Left · 1Metro says that because the white dwarf's progenitor star resembled the sun, Williams thinks a second-generation planet could form after the sun dies in about five billion years. MetroLC “it is possible a second-generation planet could form after our sun dies” Read at Metro ↗
Centre · 1CNA also covers a second Nature Astronomy study, led by MIT's Aaron Householder, of a red dwarf in an 87-minute orbit with a brown dwarf in Taurus. The star appears to be siphoning material from the brown dwarf. CNAN “These two companions orbit each other every 87 minutes”“the star's gravitational pull appears to be siphoning material from the brown dwarf” Read at CNA ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- A popular-science explainer built on an interview with the lead researcher, asking what the find means for the sun's future.
- Emphasis
- Sun's eventual fate, the niobium detection, life prospects and the star 'feeding' off the planet.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the Hubble, TESS and FUSE data sources or planned James Webb follow-up, or the atmospheric evaporation.
- Charged language
- “Phoenix planet”“celestial junk”“cosmic fluke”
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- A wire-style science report opening with the phoenix myth, then the discovery, its chemistry and orbit.
- Emphasis
- The planet's properties, how widespread such planets may be, and a second unrelated Nature Astronomy study.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the sun's future or the star's niobium being a first for white dwarfs.
- Charged language
- “Alien 'phoenix planet'”“death throes”
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- The planet HS0209+0832b orbits the white dwarf HS0209+0832.
- The study was published in Nature Astronomy, led by Jamie Williams of the University of Warwick.
- The planet is a gas giant with a 4.4-day orbit and is too hot for life.
- The planet is called a 'phoenix planet' and is described as second-generation.
Where accounts differ
-
Distance to the white dwarf
- Left
- Metro gives about 1,580,000,000,000,000 miles from Earth.
- Centre
- CNA gives about 250 light-years, with a light-year at 5.9 trillion miles (9.5 trillion km).
-
Strength of the finding
- Left
- Metro says it 'could be' the first observational evidence and that findings still need confirming.
- Centre
- CNA quotes Williams calling it 'the first example' and says the team hopes to confirm with the James Webb Space Telescope.
Exoplanets topic
Exoplanet science: the find is presented as a new class of second-generation planet around white dwarfs, which could be targets in the search for life.
“It is classified as a second-generation planet” — CNA
“this class of planet could be a good candidate to search for life in the future” — Metro
Left1 article
-
MetroLC ·
‘Phoenix planet’ born from star’s ashes could tell us what will happen when our sun dies
Mixed Light, explanatory interview piece linking the find to the sun's future, with playful language.

Centre1 article
-
CNAN ·
Alien 'phoenix planet' was born from the ashes of a dying star
Neutral Straight science report centred on the discovery and researchers' quotes, adding a second study.

Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 5 Oct 16:00 First MetroLC ‘Phoenix planet’ born from star’s ashes could tell us what will happen when our sun dies
- 6 Oct 14:37 +22h 37m CNAN Alien 'phoenix planet' was born from the ashes of a dying star
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.